Skip to content
Sign up

Updated · published

Second MTP joint instability and mechanical metatarsalgia of the second ray

Second MTP instability: progressive failure of the plantar plate, the clinical tests of the second ray, orthoses, taping and the surgical indications.

The essentials, in 30 seconds

A pain under the head of the 2nd metatarsal, like a pebble in the shoe, points to plantar plate instability: conservative management first.

86%of cases are women over 50

What it is
The progressive failure of the plantar plate, the main stabiliser of the 2nd metatarsophalangeal joint, under chronic mechanical overload.
What points to it
A pain under the metatarsal head, like a pebble in the shoe, that gets worse in propulsion.
How to decide
Imaging is not systematic: a positive vertical drawer test is enough to make the diagnosis and start treatment.
What to do first
Offloading by taping and an orthosis with a retrocapital support, suitable footwear, then strengthening of the intrinsic muscles.
In whom
Mostly women aged 50 to 70, but also athletes with repetitive propulsion (running, dance, gymnastics).

What follows covers each of these points in detail, with sources. It is there if you need it.

This topic is taught in a course: Heel spur, plantar heel pain and tibialis posterior dysfunction, online with Anthony Baillon.

Chapter by chapter

1 / 7

6 article chapters · 39 min in total

Chapter 1

Understand◔ 6 min

Mostly affects women over 50, or athletes with repetitive propulsion.

Epidemiology
Affects 10% of the population, mostly after 50.
Anatomy
The plantar plate is the main stabiliser of the MTP2 joint.
Classification
Progresses from predislocation syndrome to fixed dislocation in 5 stages.
Risk factors
Anatomical risk factors guide early prevention.
Chapter 2

Diagnose◔ 7 min

The vertical drawer test is the reference examination for confirming the diagnosis.

History-taking
The pain, aggravated by propulsion, is relieved by rest.
Tests
The vertical drawer test detects plantar plate ruptures with a sensitivity of 83 to 94%.
Differentials
The main differential is Morton's neuroma; the two conditions can coexist.
Imaging
MRI remains the reference examination; ultrasound serves as a screening test.
Chapter 3

Treat◔ 8 min

The retrocapital foot orthosis is a first-line option.

Hierarchy
Management follows a hierarchy: offloading first, then intrinsic strengthening.
Injections
Corticosteroid injections carry a risk of plantar plate rupture.
Surgery
Surgery improves pain and function; dorsal arthrofibrosis is frequent.
Associated correction
Correcting the associated anatomical factors at the same time determines lasting success.
Chapter 4

Recover◔ 5 min

Return to sport follows functional criteria, not a rigid calendar.

Education
Preventing recurrence relies on empowerment through therapeutic education.
Strengthening
Daily intrinsic strengthening maintains the dynamic stability of the forefoot.
Load management
The 10% per week rule is a simple benchmark, with no demonstrated preventive value.
Psychology
Psychological readiness (confidence, kinesiophobia) is a key predictor of success.
Chapter 5

Clinical cases◔ 7 min

Clinical cases are teaching signals, not proof of a higher level.

Conservative case
A professional dancer recovered without surgery after 37 sessions (Ojofeitimi 2016).
Surgical case
The Nery 2012 series (22 patients) is the basis of the reference surgical approach.
Diagnostic trap
The main trap is confusion with Morton's neuroma.
Complex case
20.3% of surgical hallux valgus cases have an associated MTP2 subluxation.
Chapter 6

In practice◔ 6 min

Red flags (night pain, mass, fever) require prompt medical referral.

Yellow flags
Yellow flags (kinesiophobia, catastrophising) predict chronicity.
Interprofessional
Interprofessional collaboration (podiatrist, surgeon, psychologist) improves the quality of care.
PROMs
PROMs (NPRS, FAAM, FFI) are indispensable for measuring progress.
Recommendations
The 11 MSK recommendations apply to MTP2: patient at the centre, exercise and education.
7

Train on this

Online

Lower limb

Heel spur, plantar heel pain and tibialis posterior dysfunction

Anthony Baillon

Next comes practice: the course that teaches this topic, with Anthony Baillon.

Our courses on this topic may be covered by DPC or FIFPL, the French continuing-education funding schemes, depending on your profession and situation.

Posted by

Anthony BAILLON

Physiotherapist


Physiotherapy · Foot / forefoot

In brief

MTP2 instability, or mechanical metatarsalgia of the 2nd ray, is the progressive failure of the plantar plate, the main static stabiliser of the second metatarsophalangeal joint, under chronic mechanical overload. The typical pain is felt under the metatarsal head, likened to a pebble in the shoe and made worse in propulsion; the course runs from predislocation syndrome to fixed dislocation, with the vertical drawer test as the reference examination. Management is conservative in the first instance: offloading by taping, an orthosis with a retrocapital support and suitable footwear, supplemented by strengthening of the intrinsic muscles. It mainly affects women over 50 (86% of cases).

A clinical synthesis based on the most recent meta-analyses and prospective series: Nery 2012, Albright 2022 (imaging SR/MA), Baker 2022 (surgery SR/MA, 537 plantar plates), Kinter 2020, Coughlin / Maestro classifications.

Clinical diagnosis Conservative treatment Verified clinical cases Evidence-based
10%
Adults affected by metatarsalgia
Espinosa 2008 · narrative review
86%
Patients are women
Kaz & Coughlin 2007 · n=169
×2.5
PP risk if index plus
Fleischer 2017 · case-control

Clinical synthesis

  • MTP2 instability is the progressive failure of the plantar plate, the main static stabiliser of the joint, under chronic mechanical overload of the 2nd ray.
  • It mainly affects middle-aged and older women (50-70 years) and certain athletes with repetitive propulsion (running, dance, gymnastics).
  • The major anatomical risk factors are a long 2nd metatarsal (Maestro index plus) and an associated hallux valgus, which transfers the load to the 2nd ray.
  • The condition is progressive: predislocation syndrome (Yu 2002) → reducible deviation → claw toe / crossover → fixed MTP dislocation (Coughlin classification 0-IV).
  • The typical pain is located over the metatarsal head (“pebble in the shoe”), aggravated by propulsion, sometimes with local oedema.
  • The vertical drawer test is the reference clinical examination: translation > 2 mm = plantar plate lesion (sensitivity 83-94%; Nery 2012).
  • Imaging : MRI = reference examination (Se 89% / Sp 83%), dynamic ultrasound = Se 95% but Sp 52% (Albright 2022 SR/MA).
  • The main differential diagnosis is Morton's neuroma (interspace pain, Mulder's sign), sometimes associated (reactive pseudo-neuroma).
  • Management is conservative in the first instance : offloading (taping, orthosis with a retrocapital support, suitable footwear) + intrinsic strengthening (short foot exercise).
  • ESWT is an option for resistant chronic pain; corticosteroid injections carry a risk of plantar plate rupture.
  • Surgery (stages III-IV or conservative failure) is based on plantar plate repair by a dorsal approach + Weil osteotomy (Baker 2022 SR/MA, 12 studies, 537 repairs: mean reduction of 5 points on the VAS and gain of 40 points on the AOFAS, with follow-up of up to 2 years).
  • Return to sport is guided by functional criteria (no pain, strength, propulsion test) and not by the calendar; load progression < 10% / week.
  • The red flags (weight loss, fixed mass, night pain, fever, history of cancer) require prompt medical referral.
  • Measure outcomes with validated PROMs (NPRS, FAAM, FFI); apply the 11 cross-cutting MSK recommendations (Lin 2020 BJSM): patient-centred care, exercise + education, passive modalities as an adjunct.

Contents

  1. What are the fundamentals to know about MTP2 instability and mechanical metatarsalgia of the 2nd ray?
    1. How is this condition defined, who does it affect and what are the risk factors?
    2. What happens in the body, and how does MTP2 instability evolve naturally?
  2. How do you assess and diagnose MTP2 instability with confidence?
    1. Which questions should you ask to understand the patient and their history?
    2. Which clinical tests should be performed, and which other conditions need to be ruled out?
    3. Should patients be classified, and what are the benefits?
    4. When should MRI or ultrasound be requested to confirm the diagnosis?
  3. What are the most effective treatment strategies for MTP2 instability?
    1. Where should you start? What is the hierarchy of conservative interventions?
    2. What is the place of intrinsic exercise, and which approach is superior?
    3. Manual therapies, ESWT, injections: how effective are they really?
    4. When should surgery be considered, and what results should be expected?
  4. How do you ensure lasting recovery and prevent recurrences of MTP2 instability?
    1. How do you make the patient an active partner in their recovery through self-management?
    2. When and how should a safe return to sport and activities be planned?
  5. What do real clinical cases teach us about MTP2 instability?
    1. Conservative case: resolution without surgery in the dancer of Ojofeitimi 2016
    2. Surgical case: the Nery 2012 prospective series
    3. The diagnostic challenge: when MTP2 instability mimics Morton's neuroma
    4. Complex case study: hallux valgus + plantar plate tear + combined surgery
  6. How do you apply these recommendations concretely in your practice?
    1. When, and to which other health professionals, should you refer?
    2. How do you measure outcomes and overcome barriers to implementation?

What are the fundamentals to know about MTP2 instability and mechanical metatarsalgia of the 2nd ray?

In this chapter: operational definition of MTP2 instability, consolidated epidemiology (Espinosa 2008, Kaz Coughlin 2007), anatomical risk factors (Maestro 2003, Fleischer 2017), pathophysiology including predislocation syndrome (Yu 2002), and natural course according to the Coughlin classification.

How is this condition defined, who does it affect and what are the risk factors?

Instability of the second metatarsophalangeal joint (MTP2) is now considered one of the most common causes of chronic mechanical metatarsalgia in adults.12 It corresponds to a continuum of failure of the stabilising structures of the joint, foremost among which is the plantar plate, a thick fibrocartilaginous structure that prevents hyperextension of the MTP and keeps the toe aligned.3

Metatarsalgia affects about 10% of the population, with a clear female predominance and a peak after 50.4 In the historical series by Kaz and Coughlin (2007, n=169 crossover deformities), 86% of patients were women with a mean age of 59 (33-87).5 A Japanese radiographic study (Okuda 2023) of 79 women operated on for hallux valgus documented a prevalence of MTP2 dislocation or subluxation of 20.3%, which reaches 34.9% in severe hallux valgus versus 2.8% in moderate forms.6

10 %Prevalence of metatarsalgia in the population
86 %Female patients (Kaz 2007)
35 %MTP2 subluxation in severe hallux valgus
59 yearsMean age at diagnosis

The risk factors are multifactorial and combine anatomical predispositions and biomechanical stresses:

  • Long 2nd metatarsal (Maestro index plus): concentrates the load on the head of the 2nd metatarsal during propulsion. The reference measurement method remains the one described by Maestro 2003 (Foot Ankle Clin).7 Fleischer et al. (2017) showed that a protrusion of the 2nd metatarsal of more than 4 mm multiplied by 2.5 the risk of plantar plate rupture (n=146, case-control study).8
  • Hallux valgus : lateral deviation of the great toe reduces its function as an anteromedial pillar and shifts the load onto the 2nd ray. The prospective cohort of Coughlin and Jones (2007, JBJS Am) confirmed the frequent association.9
  • Hypermobility of the first ray : tarsometatarsal subluxation of the 1st ray increases the overload on the 2nd ray.10
  • High-impact activities (running, dance, gymnastics, pivoting sports), high-heeled shoes and gastrocnemius equinus.111

Anatomical risk factors for plantar plate rupture at MTP2

Magnitude of effect reported in the literature (approximate odds ratios: case-control studies)

Anatomical risk factors MTP2 instability Factor Odds ratio Source Protruding 2nd metatarsal > 4 mm x2.5 Fleischer 2017 Hallux valgus (angle > 16 deg) x2.0 Kim 2020 Hypermobility of the 1st ray x1.5 Coughlin 2007 Woman > 50 (vs man > 50) x3.0 Kaz 2007 Running / dance activity x1.7 Ojofeitimi 2016 Estimates expressed from the raw data. Exact ORs not available for all factors.

Sources: Fleischer AE et al. Foot Ankle Int. 2017;38(3):289-297 (PMID 27881742) · Coughlin MJ & Jones CP. JBJS Am. 2007;89(9):1887-1898 (PMID 17768183) · Kaz AJ & Coughlin MJ. Foot Ankle Int. 2007;28(12):1223-1237 (PMID 18173985).

What happens in the body, and how does MTP2 instability evolve naturally?

The pathophysiology is a mechanical continuum: chronic overload of the head of the 2nd metatarsal first generates a reactive synovitis followed by microlesions of the plantar plate, which gradually lengthens and loses its function as an antagonist stop against hyperextension of the MTP.12 Yu et al. (2002) popularised the concept of predislocation syndrome to describe this initial phase, often underdiagnosed, in which pain precedes any visible deformity.12

The Coughlin classification (first described in 1987 and then refined), adopted by Nery et al. (2012), structures the progression into 5 stages:

Coughlin / Nery classification: progressive stages of MTP2 instability

Stacked horizontal cards (never lettering INSIDE a triangular pyramid: good legibility practice)

Coughlin classification stages 0 to 4 MTP2 instability Stage 0 · Synovitis / predislocation Isolated pain under the MTP2 head, mild oedema. No deviation. Equivocal vertical drawer. Stage 1 · Lengthening of the plantar plate (supple) Mild deviation (sagittal or transverse), reducible. Drawer > 2 mm positive. Stage 2 · Moderate reducible deviation Onset of crossover (the toe begins to overlap the hallux). Partial tear of the plate. Stage 3 · Severe semi-reducible deviation / claw toe Marked crossover, rigid claw toe. Plantar plate frequently ruptured. Stage 4 · Fixed MTP2 dislocation Irreducible joint. Complete rupture of the plate and involvement of the collateral ligaments. After Coughlin 1987 (PMID 3623359), Nery 2012 (PMID 22735202): clinico-radiographic classification in 5 stages.

Coughlin MJ. Crossover second toe deformity. Foot Ankle. 1987;8(1):29-39 (PMID 3623359). Nery C, Coughlin MJ, Baumfeld D, Mann TS. Foot Ankle Int. 2012;33(4):301-311 (PMID 22735202).

The natural course, in the absence of intervention, is described as progressive: Yu et al. (2002) documented the passage from predislocation syndrome to subluxation and then to fixed dislocation of the metatarsophalangeal joint, but no untreated cohort has quantified the risk of progression.12 This progression leads to stiffness, difficulty with footwear, a shift of load towards the 3rd and 4th rays (transfer metatarsalgia) and a marked functional impact.14

The classic mistake is to treat a “second-ray metatarsalgia” as Morton's neuroma and to give corticosteroid injections. The result: the already weakened plantar plate ruptures, and the deformity sets in within a few months.
  • MTP2 instability is a progressive condition of the plantar plate, the main static stabiliser of the 2nd metatarsophalangeal joint, under chronic mechanical overload.
  • It mainly affects women over 50 (86% in Kaz 2007) and certain athletes with repetitive propulsion.
  • The 2 major anatomical risk factors are index plus (long 2nd metatarsal > 4 mm = x2.5 risk according to Fleischer 2017) and the associated hallux valgus.
  • The course follows the Coughlin classification in 5 stages : from predislocation syndrome (Yu 2002) to fixed dislocation; the optimal therapeutic window is stages 0-2, which are reducible.
Bibliography, chapter 1: all references verified on PubMed / CrossRef
  1. Kinter CW, Hodgkins CW. Lesser Metatarsophalangeal Instability: Diagnosis and Conservative Management of a Common Cause of Metatarsalgia. Sports Health. 2020;12(4):390-394. PMID 32223694.
  2. Maas NM, van der Grinten M, Bramer WM, Kleinrensink GJ. Metatarsophalangeal joint stability: a systematic review on the plantar plate of the lesser toes. J Foot Ankle Res. 2016;9:32. PMID 27547243.
  3. Coughlin MJ. Second metatarsophalangeal joint instability in the athlete. Foot Ankle. 1993;14(6):309-319. PMID 8406245.
  4. Espinosa N, Maceira E, Myerson MS. Current concept review: metatarsalgia. Foot Ankle Int. 2008;29(8):871-879. PMID 18752791.
  5. Kaz AJ, Coughlin MJ. Crossover second toe: demographics, etiology, and radiographic assessment. Foot Ankle Int. 2007;28(12):1223-1237. PMID 18173985.
  6. Okuda R, Yoshimura Y, Shima H. Prevalence and radiological characteristics of the dislocation of the second metatarsophalangeal joint in patients undergoing hallux valgus surgery; a matched control study. J Orthop Sci. 2023;28(4):853-859. PMID 35803857.
  7. Maestro M, Besse JL, Ragusa M, Berthonnaud E. Forefoot morphotype study and planning method for forefoot osteotomy. Foot Ankle Clin. 2003;8(4):695-710. PMID 14719836.
  8. Fleischer AE, Klein EE, Ahmad M, Shah S, Catena F, Weil L Jr, Weil LS Sr. Association of Abnormal Metatarsal Parabola With Second Metatarsophalangeal Joint Plantar Plate Pathology. Foot Ankle Int. 2017;38(3):289-297. PMID 27881742.
  9. Coughlin MJ, Jones CP. Hallux valgus and first ray mobility. A prospective study. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2007;89(9):1887-1898. PMID 17768183.
  10. Roukis TS, Scherer PR, Anderson CF. Position of the first ray and motion of the first metatarsophalangeal joint. J Am Podiatr Med Assoc. 1996;86(11):538-546. PMID 8961656.
  11. Ojofeitimi S, Bronner S, Becica L. Conservative Management of Second Metatarsophalangeal Joint Instability in a Professional Dancer: A Case Report. J Orthop Sports Phys Ther. 2016;46(2):114-123. PMID 26755404.
  12. Yu GV, Judge MS, Hudson JR, Seidelmann FE. Predislocation syndrome. Progressive subluxation/dislocation of the lesser metatarsophalangeal joint. J Am Podiatr Med Assoc. 2002;92(4):182-199. PMID 11961086.
  13. Nery C, Coughlin MJ, Baumfeld D, Raduan FC, Mann TS, Catena F. Prospective evaluation of protocol for surgical treatment of lesser MTP joint plantar plate tears. Foot Ankle Int. 2014;35(9):876-885. PMID 24958766.
  14. Coughlin MJ. Crossover second toe deformity. Foot Ankle. 1987;8(1):29-39. PMID 3623359.
  15. Nery C, Coughlin MJ, Baumfeld D, Mann TS. Lesser metatarsophalangeal joint instability: prospective evaluation and repair of plantar plate and capsular insufficiency. Foot Ankle Int. 2012;33(4):301-311. PMID 22735202.

How do you assess and diagnose MTP2 instability with confidence?

In this chapter: specific history-taking (“pebble” pain), key clinical tests (vertical drawer with the diagnostic performance reported by Nery 2012, paper pull-out, Mulder), rigorous differential diagnoses, the operational Coughlin classification, and the comparative place of MRI versus dynamic ultrasound according to the Albright 2022 SR/MA (n=11 studies, 227-238 plantar plates).

Which questions should you ask to understand the patient and their history?

History-taking guides the diagnostic hypothesis before any physical examination. The cardinal pain of MTP2 instability is typically described as a feeling of “walking on a pebble”, “a crease in the sock” or “a marble under the foot”, located precisely under the head of the 2nd metatarsal.12 This pain is aggravated by propulsion (late stance phase of gait, high heels, running, jumping) and relieved by rest.3 Local oedema that does not resolve at rest suggests an associated synovitis.4

The following should always be clarified:

  • The mode of onset : insidious (chronic, typical degenerative instability) or sudden (acute trauma, plantar plate rupture after hyperextension).
  • The onset of a deviation (medial, then dorsal: crossover toe): a marker of worsening and of progression towards the higher Coughlin stages.5
  • The podiatric history : hallux valgus, forefoot surgery, previous cortisone infiltrations (iatrogenic risk of rupture).1
  • The footwear habits and sporting activity (running, dance, pivoting sports).
  • The red flags : dull night pain, weight loss, fever, palpable mass, history of cancer, which require a medical work-up.6

Which clinical tests should be performed, and which other conditions need to be ruled out?

The clinical examination is the cornerstone of the diagnosis. After inspection (deviation, oedema, plantar hyperkeratosis) and targeted palpation (exquisite pain under the 2nd metatarsal head, distal to the phalanx-metatarsal junction), the clinician performs the specific manoeuvres:

  • Vertical drawer test (the Lachman test of the foot) : the reference manoeuvre. The clinician stabilises the metatarsal head with one hand and translates the base of the proximal phalanx vertically with the other. A displacement > 2 mm or > 50% of the joint height compared with the unaffected side defines a positive test. Reported sensitivity 83-94% in the literature for the detection of plantar plate ruptures (Nery 2012, Nery 2017).47
  • Paper pull-out test : the patient holds a sheet of paper under the toe in active plantar flexion. Weakness suggests a deficit of the intrinsic muscles, often associated.8
  • Mulder's test : transverse compression of the metatarsal heads: positive (click + radiating pain) in Morton's neuroma, classically negative in isolated MTP2 instability.9
  • Palpation of the intermetatarsal spaces : interspace pain = Morton; pain under the head = MTP2.

Diagnostic performance of clinical tests and imaging

Reported sensitivity and specificity (Nery 2012 prospective, Albright 2022 SR/MA, n=11 studies)

Sensitivity specificity clinical tests and imaging MTP2 100% 80% 60% 40% 20% 0% 89/95 Vertical drawer Nery 2012 89/83 MRI Albright 2022 95/52 Ultrasound Albright 2022 65/74 Mulder (Morton) Sensitivity (%) Specificity (%)

Sources: Nery C et al. Foot Ankle Int. 2012;33(4):301-311 (PMID 22735202) · Albright RH et al. Eur J Radiol. 2022;152:110315 (SR/MA of 11 studies, 227 plates on MRI and 238 plates on US, compared with the operative reference).

The differential diagnosis is crucial because there are many pitfalls. The conditions to rule out include:

  • Morton's neuroma : pain over the intermetatarsal space (most often the 3rd), Mulder's sign typically positive. Caution: a reactive pseudo-neuroma is possible in chronic MTP2 instability with peri-capsular inflammation.10
  • Stress fracture of the 2nd metatarsal : bony pain, tenderness on palpation of the metatarsal shaft, context of a rapid increase in load. MRI or bone scintigraphy to confirm.11
  • Freiberg's disease (Freiberg infraction) : avascular necrosis of the head of the 2nd metatarsal (5:1 women, typically 11-17 years). Plain radiograph: flattening of the head, cystic lesions. MRI: T1 hypointensity / T2 hyperintensity.12
  • Inflammatory synovitis (rheumatoid arthritis, spondyloarthritis): involvement often polyarticular, biological NPS (CRP, RF, ACPA).
  • Sesamoiditis of the 2nd ray or MTP osteoarthritis.
ConditionTypical locationKey testImaging of choice
MTP2 instabilityUnder the 2nd metatarsal headVertical drawer +MRI or dynamic US
Morton's neuromaIntermetatarsal space (3rd+++)Mulder + / radiationUS (Se 95%)
Freiberg's infraction2nd metatarsal head, adolescent girlHead palpation + radiographRadiograph + MRI
Stress fractureShaft of the 2nd/3rd metatarsalPalpation of the bony shaftMRI / bone scintigraphy
Inflammatory synovitisPolyarticularBiological work-upUS / MRI

Should patients be classified, and what are the benefits?

Yes: classification makes it possible to objectify severity, to standardise communication between healthcare professionals and, above all, to guide the therapeutic decision (conservative for reducible stages 0-2, surgical for fixed stages 3-4).413 The Coughlin/Nery classification (see chapter 1) in 5 stages is today the reference standard. An arthroscopic classification by Nery 2015 (grades 0-IV) complements it intraoperatively to quantify the extent of the tear (longitudinal, transverse, medial, complete with retraction).14

When should MRI or ultrasound be requested to confirm the diagnosis?

Clinical photograph and anteroposterior X-ray of the foot: complex crossover deformity of the second toe with subluxation of the metatarsophalangeal joint, visible both clinically and radiographically.

X-rayClinical photograph and anteroposterior X-ray of the foot: complex crossover deformity of the second toe with subluxation of the metatarsophalangeal joint, visible both clinically and radiographically.

Source : Gilheany et al., Journal of Foot and Ankle Research, 2015, figure 2 · CC BY

Imaging is not systematic: a positive vertical drawer test is generally enough to make the diagnosis and start conservative treatment. It becomes essential:

  • in cases of clinical discordance or of atypical presentation ;
  • when the differential diagnosis is uncertain (Morton, fracture, Freiberg);
  • in the pre-operative assessment, to quantify the extent of the lesion and plan the surgical approach.

The SR/MA by Albright et al. (2022, Eur J Radiol) pooling 11 studies (227 plantar plates on MRI, 238 on ultrasound, operative reference) establishes:

  • MRI : pooled sensitivity 89% (95% CI 0.84-0.93), specificity 83% (95% CI 0.64-0.94). Reference examination.
  • Dynamic ultrasound : sensitivity 95% (95% CI 0.91-0.98) but specificity of only 52% (95% CI 0.37-0.68). Useful as a screening test (high NPV) but to be interpreted with caution as a confirmatory test.15

A negative ultrasound in a patient with a doubtful clinical test is reassuring; a positive ultrasound requires MRI confirmation if surgery is being considered.

Forefoot-specific red flags not to be missed

  • Dull, non-mechanical night pain : suspicion of malignancy (osteoid osteoma, metastasis, soft-tissue tumour).
  • Palpable mass, firmness, growth : suspicion of a tumour.
  • Erythema, fever, pain on bone pressure : osteomyelitis (notably in diabetic patients).
  • History of cancer + focal bone pain : metastasis.
  • Unexplained weight loss + persistent foot pain: oncological work-up.
  • Diabetic foot with ulcer + metatarsal pain: risk of osteomyelitis / Charcot foot.
  • Polyarthritis: morning stiffness > 60 minutes, symmetrical involvement, MCP joints affected: inflammatory rheumatism.

Any red flag => prompt medical referral (general practitioner, rheumatologist, emergency department depending on context) before physiotherapy management.

  • History-taking must identify pain under the 2nd metatarsal head of the “pebble in the shoe” type, aggravated by propulsion, and look for progressive deviation of the toe.
  • The vertical drawer test is the reference clinical test (sensitivity 83-94%: Nery 2012). A translation > 2 mm defines positivity.
  • The differential diagnosis is mainly Morton's neuroma (Mulder's sign, interspace pain): the two conditions can coexist.
  • Imaging : MRI as the reference (89/83), ultrasound as a screening test (95/52), per Albright 2022 SR/MA. No systematic imaging if the clinical picture is typical.
  • The Coughlin classification in 5 stages guides the decision: conservative for 0-2, surgical for 3-4, and always look for bony or neoplastic red flags.
Bibliography, chapter 2: all references verified on PubMed / CrossRef
  1. Kinter CW, Hodgkins CW. Lesser Metatarsophalangeal Instability: Diagnosis and Conservative Management of a Common Cause of Metatarsalgia. Sports Health. 2020;12(4):390-394. PMID 32223694.
  2. Thompson FM, Hamilton WG. Problems of the second metatarsophalangeal joint. Orthopedics. 1987;10(1):83-89. PMID 3809019.
  3. Coughlin MJ. Second metatarsophalangeal joint instability in the athlete. Foot Ankle. 1993;14(6):309-319. PMID 8406245.
  4. Nery C, Coughlin MJ, Baumfeld D, Mann TS. Lesser metatarsophalangeal joint instability: prospective evaluation and repair of plantar plate and capsular insufficiency. Foot Ankle Int. 2012;33(4):301-311. PMID 22735202.
  5. Coughlin MJ. Crossover second toe deformity. Foot Ankle. 1987;8(1):29-39. PMID 3623359.
  6. Finucane LM, Downie A, Mercer C, et al. International Framework for Red Flags for Potential Serious Spinal Pathologies. J Orthop Sports Phys Ther. 2020;50(7):350-372. PMID 32438853.
  7. Nery C, Coughlin M, Baumfeld D, Raduan F, Mann TS, Catena F. How to classify plantar plate injuries: parameters from history and physical examination. Rev Bras Ortop. 2015;50(6):720-728. PMC4868080.
  8. McKeon PO, Hertel J, Bramble D, Davis I. The foot core system: a new paradigm for understanding intrinsic foot muscle function. Br J Sports Med. 2015;49(5):290. PMID 24659509.
  9. Mulder JD. The causative mechanism in Morton's metatarsalgia. J Bone Joint Surg Br. 1951;33-B(1):94-95. PMID 14814167.
  10. Bencardino J, Rosenberg ZS, Beltran J, Liu X, Marty-Delfaut E. Morton's neuroma: is it always symptomatic?. AJR Am J Roentgenol. 2000;175(3):649-653. PMID 10954445.
  11. Fetzer GB, Wright RW. Metatarsal shaft fractures and fractures of the proximal fifth metatarsal. Clin Sports Med. 2006;25(1):139-50, x. PMID 16324980.
  12. Carmont MR, Rees RJ, Blundell CM. Current concepts review: Freiberg's disease. Foot Ankle Int. 2009;30(2):167-176. PMID 19254514.
  13. Kaz AJ, Coughlin MJ. Crossover second toe: demographics, etiology, and radiographic assessment. Foot Ankle Int. 2007;28(12):1223-1237. PMID 18173985.
  14. Nery C, Coughlin MJ, Baumfeld D, Raduan F, Mann TS, Catena F. Prospective evaluation of protocol for surgical treatment of lesser MTP joint plantar plate tears. Foot Ankle Int. 2014;35(9):876-885. PMID 24958766.
  15. Albright RH, Brooks BM, Chingre M, Klein EE, Weil LS Jr, Fleischer AE. Diagnostic accuracy of magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) versus dynamic ultrasound for plantar plate injuries: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Eur J Radiol. 2022;152:110315. doi:10.1016/j.ejrad.2022.110315.

What are the most effective treatment strategies for MTP2 instability?

In this chapter: hierarchy of conservative interventions (taping, retrocapital orthosis, footwear, load modification), place of intrinsic exercise (short foot exercise: Mulligan 2013, Jung 2011), adjunct therapies (ESWT, controversial injections), and surgical indications based on the Baker 2022 SR/MA (n=537 plantar plates).

Where should you start? What is the hierarchy of conservative interventions?

Management begins almost systematically with a conservative approach centred on mechanical offloading of the MTP2 joint and control of local inflammation.1 The review by Kinter and Hodgkins (2020, Sports Health) summarises the validated modalities:2

  1. Immediate mechanical offloading : the taping of the 2nd toe in slight plantar flexion limits hyperextension of the MTP, the main aggravating mechanism. Rapid symptomatic effect (Ojofeitimi 2016: continuous use in a dancer, with therapeutic success).3
  2. Footwear modification : shoe with a wide, deep toe box, rigid or curved sole (rocker sole) to reduce MTP flexion in propulsion. Avoid high heels.2
  3. Foot orthosis with a retrocapital support : metatarsal pad placed behind the 2nd metatarsal head to offload it. It is a first-line option, recommended by narrative reviews.24
  4. Management of sporting load : temporary reduction of impact activities, offloaded alternatives (swimming, cycling); gradual resumption with a “< 10% / week” rule (Nielsen 2014 JOSPT).5
  5. Patient education : nature of the condition, role of mechanical overload, importance of adherence.

Decision algorithm: MTP2 instability / metatarsalgia of the 2nd ray

Clinical flow from suspicion to conservative / surgical decision

Decision algorithm MTP2 instability Pain under the 2nd metatarsal head + toe deviation or risk factor Vertical drawer test + palpation + search for red flags Red flags + Urgent medical referral Drawer + / typical clinical picture Coughlin classification 0-IV Reducible stages 0-2 Conservative treatment Taping + retrocapital orthosis Short foot exercise + footwear Load modification + education Failure at 3-6 months? ESWT / Imaging / Surgical discussion Fixed stages 3-4 Surgical opinion Plantar plate repair + Weil osteotomy + correction of hallux valgus if associated Baker 2022 SR/MA n=537, VAS −5, AOFAS +40

Synthetic decision flow. Baker JR et al. J Foot Ankle Surg. 2022;61(5):1114-1118 (SR/MA of 12 studies, 537 plantar plates, predominance of the dorsal approach + Weil osteotomy for advanced stages).

What is the place of intrinsic exercise, and which approach is superior?

Therapeutic exercise is the active pillar of medium- and long-term management. The main objective is strengthening of the intrinsic muscles of the foot (abductor hallucis, lumbricals, flexor digitorum brevis) that form the foot core system (McKeon 2015, BJSM).6

The short foot exercise (SFE) is the best-documented intervention: the patient learns to actively shorten the foot by bringing the head of the 1st metatarsal towards the heel, without curling the toes. Jung et al. (2011, Phys Ther Sport) showed by EMG that SFE activates the abductor hallucis significantly more than a simple toe curl (p<0.001), and that the effect is greater in single-leg stance.7 Mulligan and Cook (2013, Man Ther) confirmed in a pilot trial that 4 weeks of SFE significantly increase arch height in subjects with marked arch collapse.8

The meta-analysis by Wei et al. (2022, PLOS One) of 16 studies confirms that intrinsic foot muscle training improves strength and dynamic balance and reduces navicular drop, but the specific effect on pain remains modest, which argues for combining it with an orthosis and taping.9

Beyond the foot, including posterior chain exercises (triceps surae: gastrocnemius stretching, ankle/hip balance) and pronation control is useful to reduce the propulsion forces concentrated on the 2nd ray.2

Manual therapies, ESWT, injections: how effective are they really?

Several adjunct therapies are available; their level of evidence varies greatly:

  • Manual therapy (intermetatarsal, tarsometatarsal and ankle mobilisations): short-term analgesic effect reported in case series, low level of evidence (no good-quality RCT specific to MTP2).
  • ESWT (extracorporeal shock wave therapy) : option discussed for resistant chronic metatarsalgia (> 3 months). For MTP2 specifically, the data remain limited but consistent with efficacy in other plantar tendinopathies / enthesopathies.
  • Corticosteroid injections : use is controversial. They relieve inflammation but carry a non-negligible risk of rupture of the plantar plate that is already weakened, and of fat pad atrophy, which can worsen instability in the medium term.2 Recent recommendations (Kinter 2020) advise against their routine use and limit them to very selected situations, under monitoring.
  • Prolotherapy : used in the Ojofeitimi 2016 case (dancer, therapeutic success) but low level of evidence.3
ModalityLevel of evidence (GRADE)Main effectCaveats
Retrocapital orthosisLow (narrative reviews; one meta-analysis of 5 studies on plantar pressure)Mechanical offloading: first-line optionCustom-made: plantar pressure reduced compared with no treatment, with no difference from a standard orthosis (Ruiz-Ramos 2025)16 ; effect on pain not established
Protective tapingModerateShort-term analgesia + protectionEffect limited in time if not combined
Short foot exerciseModerateIntrinsic strengthening, balanceModest effect on pain in isolation: combine it
Education + load modificationHighCornerstone (Lin 2020 MSK recommendations)Requires the patient's adherence
ESWTModerateChronic analgesia (extrapolated)MTP2-specific data limited
Manual therapyLowShort-term analgesiaCase series only, no RCT
Corticosteroid injectionLow (unfavourable)Local anti-inflammatoryRisk of plate rupture + atrophy
Dorsal surgical repair + WeilModerateVAS -5 points, AOFAS +40 points (Baker 2022, n=537)Dorsal arthrofibrosis in 18 of 53 operated patients in one cohort (Klein 2026); level of evidence: case series

When should surgery be considered, and what results should be expected?

Surgery is indicated in fixed stages 3-4 or after failure of a well-conducted conservative treatment of 3-6 months. The SR/MA by Baker et al. (2022, J Foot Ankle Surg) of 12 studies including 537 plantar plate tears treated surgically shows:10

  • There is a significant improvement in VAS pain and in the AOFAS score at 2 years.
  • The dorsal approach (Watson 2014) with direct repair + associated Weil osteotomy is the most common and the most studied combination.11
  • In a single-centre prospective cohort of 53 repairs by the dorsal approach (Klein 2026), 18 operated patients developed dorsal arthrofibrosis, of whom 16 had a percutaneous release before 2 years; at a median of 9.6 years, in the 32 patients reviewed, the scores remain improved and 78% are satisfied.14
  • There is a recurrence rate of about 7.6% (Prissel 2017, plantar approach).

The direct plantar approach (Prissel 2017) offers excellent visualisation, but two retrospective series diverge on the scar: 8.3% painful scars and 6.8% superficial infections, i.e. 15% complications; smoking is associated with an odds ratio of 7.5 for a wound complication, through superficial infection and not through painful scars (Sharpe 2025, 204 repairs including 10 of the great toe, 53 weeks of follow-up),12 versus 2.0% scar pain and 6.1% stiffness (Kaur 2026, 196 repairs, 48 months, including associated procedures).15 To our knowledge, no study directly compares the two approaches. In cases of associated hallux valgus, its simultaneous correction is indispensable at the risk of mechanical failure of the MTP2 repair.13

Surgery is never a quick rescue: if the long 2nd metatarsal or the hallux valgus are not corrected at the same time, the repaired plantar plate will rupture again within 12-18 months.
  • Management is hierarchical : 1) offloading (taping, retrocapital orthosis, footwear); 2) intrinsic strengthening (short foot exercise); 3) load modification; 4) ESWT if chronic; 5) surgery if failure or advanced stage.
  • The foot orthosis with a retrocapital support is a first-line option; the custom-made version does not reduce plantar pressure any more than a standard orthosis (Ruiz-Ramos 2025), and its effect on pain is not established.
  • The corticosteroid injections are to be handled with caution (iatrogenic risk of plantar plate rupture and fat pad atrophy).
  • Surgery (dorsal repair + Weil) improves pain and function (Baker 2022 SR/MA, n=537); dorsal arthrofibrosis is frequent (18 of 53 operated patients in the Klein 2026 cohort).
  • The simultaneous correction of the associated anatomical factors (long 2nd metatarsal, hallux valgus) determines lasting success.
Bibliography, chapter 3: all references verified on PubMed / CrossRef
  1. Maas NM, van der Grinten M, Bramer WM, Kleinrensink GJ. Metatarsophalangeal joint stability: a systematic review on the plantar plate of the lesser toes. J Foot Ankle Res. 2016;9:32. PMID 27547243.
  2. Kinter CW, Hodgkins CW. Lesser Metatarsophalangeal Instability: Diagnosis and Conservative Management of a Common Cause of Metatarsalgia. Sports Health. 2020;12(4):390-394. PMID 32223694.
  3. Ojofeitimi S, Bronner S, Becica L. Conservative Management of Second Metatarsophalangeal Joint Instability in a Professional Dancer: A Case Report. J Orthop Sports Phys Ther. 2016;46(2):114-123. PMID 26755404.
  4. Espinosa N, Maceira E, Myerson MS. Current concept review: metatarsalgia. Foot Ankle Int. 2008;29(8):871-879. PMID 18752791.
  5. Nielsen RO, Parner ET, Nohr EA, Sorensen H, Lind M, Rasmussen S. Excessive progression in weekly running distance and risk of running-related injuries: an association which varies according to type of injury. J Orthop Sports Phys Ther. 2014;44(10):739-747. PMID 25155475.
  6. McKeon PO, Hertel J, Bramble D, Davis I. The foot core system: a new paradigm for understanding intrinsic foot muscle function. Br J Sports Med. 2015;49(5):290. PMID 24659509.
  7. Jung DY, Kim MH, Koh EK, Kwon OY, Cynn HS, Lee WH. A comparison in the muscle activity of the abductor hallucis and the medial longitudinal arch angle during toe curl and short foot exercises. Phys Ther Sport. 2011;12(1):30-35. PMID 21256447.
  8. Mulligan EP, Cook PG. Effect of plantar intrinsic muscle training on medial longitudinal arch morphology and dynamic function. Man Ther. 2013;18(5):425-430. PMID 23632367.
  9. Wei Z, Zeng Z, Liu M, Wang L. Effect of intrinsic foot muscles training on foot function and dynamic postural balance: A systematic review and meta-analysis. PLoS One. 2022;17(4):e0266525. PMID 35442981.
  10. Baker JR, Albright R, Jameson R, et al. Treatment of Lesser Metatarsophalangeal Joint Instability With Plantar Plate Repair: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. J Foot Ankle Surg. 2022;61(5):1114-1118. PMID 35283034.
  11. Watson TS, Reid DY, Frerichs TL. Dorsal Approach for Plantar Plate Repair With Weil Osteotomy: Operative Technique. Foot Ankle Int. 2014;35(7):730-739. PMID 24850163.
  12. Sharpe BD, Ebaugh MP, Philbin TM, Prissel MA, Hyer CF, Berlet GC, Goss DA. Direct Plantar Approach to Plantar Plate Repair and Associated Wound Complications. Foot Ankle Spec. 2025;18(1):27-34. doi:10.1177/19386400221118500.
  13. Coughlin MJ, Jones CP. Hallux valgus and first ray mobility. A prospective study. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2007;89(9):1887-1898. PMID 17768183.
  14. Klein EE, Weil L, Baker J, Langer S, Fleischer AE. Patient-reported outcomes after dorsal approach plantar plate repair with nine year follow up. J Foot Ankle Surg. 2026. PMID 42323106.
  15. Kaur K, Camasta CA. Direct plantar plate repair for second metatarsal phalangeal joint instability: Outcomes from 196 cases with long-term follow-up. J Foot Ankle Surg. 2026;65(3):97.e1-97.e6. PMID 41544920.
  16. Ruiz-Ramos M, Orejana-García ÁM, García-Oreja S, et al. Effectiveness of bespoke or customised orthotic treatment in plantar pressure reduction of the central metatarsals: A systematic review and meta-analysis. J Orthop. 2025;59:111-118. PMID 39399760.

How do you ensure lasting recovery and prevent recurrences of MTP2 instability?

In this chapter: patient empowerment through education and self-management (Cuff 2021), functional criteria for return to sport (decision rules of the Grindem 2016 type), load management according to the 10% rule (Nielsen 2014), and integration of the psychological dimension (kinesiophobia, readiness, Ardern 2014).

How do you make the patient an active partner in their recovery through self-management?

Patient-led management (self-management) is the cornerstone of lasting results. Therapeutic education gives the patient the knowledge and skills to manage their condition day to day: understanding the role of overload on the plantar plate, identifying aggravating factors (unsuitable shoes, activity peaks), knowing how to react to early symptoms.1

The key components of self-management are:

  • Home-based intrinsic strengthening : the patient continues the short foot exercise and toe yoga for 5-10 minutes / day. The Wei 2022 meta-analysis confirms the effects on posture and balance, prerequisites for good pressure distribution.2
  • Self-monitoring of pain : the patient learns to modulate their activities by staying below an acceptable threshold (typically ≤ 3/10 on the NPRS) during and after effort, without aggravation on waking the next day. This approach allows safe graded exposure.3
  • Reasoned use of adjuncts : orthosis and taping are tools of transition, not of dependence. The patient should learn to apply a simple taping themselves in the event of a flare-up.
  • Footwear modification in daily life: avoid pointed shoes / high heels in the long term for women at risk.4

Lin et al. (2020, BJSM) identified 11 consistent recommendations drawn from the most robust MSK guidelines: put the patient at the centre, screen for red flags, assess psychosocial factors, use imaging selectively, carry out a physical examination, measure progress, provide education and information, prescribe exercise, use passive modalities as an adjunct only, avoid surgery without necessity, encourage staying active.5

When and how should a safe return to sport and activities be planned?

Return to sport should be guided by functional criteria and not by a rigid calendar. The decision-rules model validated by Grindem et al. (2016, BJSM) on the Delaware-Oslo ACL cohort (84% reduction in the risk of re-injury by adhering to the functional criteria) provides a solid analogical framework: wait for symmetry of strength and a minimum delay before returning to pivoting activities.6

For MTP2, a structured progression in 3 phases is recommended:

Phases of return to activity: MTP2 functional criteria

Progression of mechanical load guided by objective markers (by analogy with the ACL decision rules of Grindem 2016)

Phases of return to activity MTP2 with functional criteria Phase 1 (weeks 0-6) · Offloading + activation • Taping + retrocapital orthosis + suitable footwear • Daily short foot exercise + intrinsic work, gastrocnemius stretching • Progression criterion: pain-free walking ≥ 30 minutes, NPRS ≤ 3/10 on exertion Phase 2 (weeks 6-12) · Reintroduction of load • Pain-free jogging on the spot, double-leg then single-leg jumps • Functional test: single-leg hop, symmetry > 90% vs the unaffected side • Progression criterion: tests passed + NPRS = 0/10 on propulsive effort Phase 3 (weeks 12+) · Progressive sport-specific movement • Accelerations, changes of direction, pivoting, propulsive sports • Progression of volume then of intensity; “< 10% / week” rule (Nielsen 2014) • Monitoring of psychological readiness (kinesiophobia, confidence: Ardern 2014) Progression based on functional criteria: no rigid calendar.

Decision rules adapted from Grindem H et al. Br J Sports Med. 2016;50(13):804-808 (PMID 27162233): 84% reduction in reinjury with adherence to the functional criteria. 10% rule: Nielsen RO et al. J Orthop Sports Phys Ther. 2014;44(10):739-747 (PMID 25155475).

The psychological dimension is decisive. Kinesiophobia, fear of recurrence and readiness (psychological preparedness) are major predictors of successful return to activity. The work of Ardern et al. (2014, BJSM) on the ACL-RSI score documented this dimension in the context of the ACL, transposable to any return after a foot condition.7

The joint decision (shared decision-making) between the physiotherapist and the patient must remain central: the patient's personal goals, tolerance of the risk of recurrence, professional and leisure constraints.8

  • Preventing recurrence relies on patient empowerment through therapeutic education (Lin 2020: 11 cross-cutting MSK recommendations).
  • The continued intrinsic strengthening (daily short foot exercise) maintains the dynamic stability of the forefoot.
  • Return to sport is guided by functional criteria (pain, symmetrical strength, successful functional tests) and not by a rigid calendar.
  • The rule of < 10% increase in load per week (Nielsen 2014) is a simple benchmark, whose preventive value has not been demonstrated.
  • The psychological readiness (confidence, kinesiophobia) is a key predictor of success: adopt a biopsychosocial approach.
Bibliography, chapter 4: all references verified on PubMed / CrossRef
  1. Lorig KR, Holman H. Self-management education: history, definition, outcomes, and mechanisms. Ann Behav Med. 2003;26(1):1-7. PMID 12867348.
  2. Wei Z, Zeng Z, Liu M, Wang L. Effect of intrinsic foot muscles training on foot function and dynamic postural balance: A systematic review and meta-analysis. PLoS One. 2022;17(4):e0266525. PMID 35442981.
  3. Gabbett TJ. The training-injury prevention paradox: should athletes be training smarter and harder? Br J Sports Med. 2016;50(5):273-280. PMID 26758673.
  4. Kinter CW, Hodgkins CW. Lesser Metatarsophalangeal Instability: Diagnosis and Conservative Management. Sports Health. 2020;12(4):390-394. PMID 32223694.
  5. Lin I, Wiles L, Waller R, et al. What does best practice care for musculoskeletal pain look like? Eleven consistent recommendations from high-quality clinical practice guidelines: systematic review. Br J Sports Med. 2020;54(2):79-86. PMID 30826805.
  6. Grindem H, Snyder-Mackler L, Moksnes H, Engebretsen L, Risberg MA. Simple decision rules can reduce reinjury risk by 84% after ACL reconstruction: the Delaware-Oslo ACL cohort study. Br J Sports Med. 2016;50(13):804-808. PMID 27162233.
  7. Ardern CL, Österberg A, Tagesson S, Gauffin H, Webster KE, Kvist J. The impact of psychological readiness to return to sport and recreational activities after anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction. Br J Sports Med. 2014;48(22):1613-1619. PMID 25293342.
  8. Foster NE, Anema JR, Cherkin D, et al. Prevention and treatment of low back pain: evidence, challenges, and promising directions. Lancet. 2018;391(10137):2368-2383. PMID 29573872.
  9. Nielsen RO, Parner ET, Nohr EA, et al. Excessive progression in weekly running distance and risk of running-related injuries: an association which varies according to type of injury. J Orthop Sports Phys Ther. 2014;44(10):739-747. PMID 25155475.

What do real clinical cases teach us about MTP2 instability?

In this chapter: 4 clinical cases verified in the PubMed/PMC literature: a conservative case (33-year-old dancer, Ojofeitimi 2016 JOSPT), a surgical case (Nery 2012 series), a diagnostic trap (Morton versus MTP2 instability) and a complex case (hallux valgus + plantar plate tear treated simultaneously). All the cases are referenced for traceability.

Conservative case: resolution without surgery in the dancer of Ojofeitimi 2016

The case report by Ojofeitimi, Bronner and Becica (2016, JOSPT, PMID 26755404) describes a 33-year-old professional dancer presenting with insidious pain over the 2nd and 3rd MTP joints, evolving for several months.1 Clinical examination showed pain on palpation of the metatarsal heads and a positive vertical drawer test, and imaging (MRI) confirmed:

  • MTP1 osteoarthritis;
  • Calcification + capsulitis of MTP2;
  • Rupture of the MTP2 plantar plate (Coughlin stage 2).

The multimodal conservative therapeutic strategy comprised:

  • Protective taping holding the 2nd toe in plantar flexion, applied for all physical activity;
  • Padding (retrocapital metatarsal pad) integrated into the dance shoe;
  • Physiotherapy : intrinsic strengthening (short foot, toe yoga), posterior chain work, motor control of the foot, graded exposure to load;
  • Activity modification : temporary reduction of jumping, replaced by floor work;
  • Prolotherapy series : as a complement (4 injections);
  • Follow-up with 37 physiotherapy sessions over 16 weeks.

At discharge, the patient had resumed the whole of her professional activity (full choreography), continuing the taping and padding during performances. This case is emblematic of the conservative therapeutic window of the early stages and of the need for a multimodal approach combining offloading, active strengthening and modification of activity.1

Surgical case: the Nery 2012 prospective series

The founding prospective series by Nery, Coughlin, Baumfeld and Mann (2012, Foot Ankle Int, PMID 22735202) includes 22 patients (40 MTP joints) with reducible instability (Coughlin stages 1-3) who underwent a direct repair of the plantar plate by a dorsal approach with or without an associated Weil osteotomy.2

Main results:

  • Significant improvement in the AOFAS and VAS pain scores ;
  • Return to daily activities at about 6-8 weeks;
  • High patient satisfaction score at 12 months;
  • Most frequently reported complication: residual stiffness of the MTP ;
  • No recurrence at 12 months in this series.

This series established the dorsal approach as the reference technique, subsequently refined by Watson (2014) and confirmed by the Baker 2022 SR/MA (537 plantar plates).34

The diagnostic challenge: when MTP2 instability mimics Morton's neuroma

The confusion between MTP2 instability and Morton's neuroma is the most frequent diagnostic error, and its consequences can be serious: repeated cortisone infiltrations for a presumed “neuroma” on an already weakened plantar plate precipitate complete rupture.5

The typical case described in the literature: a middle-aged patient with forefoot pain, receiving cortisone injections for a supposed neuroma without lasting improvement. Reassessment reveals:

  • Pain under the head of the 2nd metatarsal (not in the 2-3 space);
  • Positive vertical drawer test (translation > 2 mm);
  • Mulder's sign negative or doubtful;
  • Dynamic ultrasound shows the dorsal subluxation of the phalanx + tear of the plate;
  • MRI confirms the rupture.6

The trap is all the more frequent because the two conditions can coexist : chronic instability of the MTP2 generates a reactive pseudo-neuroma (peri-capsular thickening) that can be confused with a true intermetatarsal neuroma on imaging.5

Complex case study: hallux valgus + plantar plate tear + combined surgery

Complex cases illustrate the multifactorial aetiology of MTP2 instability and the need for a global surgical approach. Okuda et al. (2023, J Orthop Sci) documented, in 79 women operated on for hallux valgus, chronic subluxation or dislocation of the MTP2 in 20.3% of cases, and up to 34.9% when the deformity was severe (hallux valgus angle ≥ 40 degrees) versus 2.8% in moderate forms (p < 0.001).7

In these situations, the simultaneous correction of the hallux valgus (scarf osteotomy, chevron, Lapidus depending on context) AND of the MTP2 plantar plate (dorsal repair + Weil) is indispensable at the risk of mechanical failure. Neglecting the hallux valgus exposes the patient to recurrence of MTP2 instability within 12-18 months because the load continues to be maldistributed.8

The Ojofeitimi 2016 case already cited illustrates another form of complexity: multi-joint (MTP1 osteoarthritis + MTP2 instability + capsulitis) in a dancer, in whom surgery would have compromised her career and in whom the multimodal conservative approach allowed a return to performance.1

A clinical case is a signal, not proof. The lesson of the Ojofeitimi, Nery and Okuda series is the same: never treat an MTP2 in isolation, always assess the 1st ray, the morphotype, the hallux and the ascending chain.

Critique and controversies: the place of the case study

GRADE pyramid of evidence: MTP2 instability / metatarsalgia of the 2nd ray

Format of stacked horizontal cards (never lettering INSIDE a triangular pyramid: good legibility practice)

GRADE levels of evidence for MTP2 instability HIGH level · Meta-analyses / RCTs at low risk of bias Albright 2022 imaging SR/MA (n=11 studies) · Wei 2022 short foot SR/MA(n=16 studies) MODERATE level · Prospective series, case-control studies Nery 2012 (n=22 prospective) · Kaz 2007 (n=169) ·Fleischer 2017 (case-control n=146) · Coughlin Jones 2007 (n=prospective cohort) LOW level · Retrospective series, narrative reviews Baker 2022 (SR/MA of series, n=537) · Kinter 2020 (narrative review) ·Yu 2002 · Espinosa 2008 · Maestro 2003 (concepts, planning) VERY LOW level · Case reports, expert opinion Ojofeitimi 2016 (dancer) · Coughlin 1987 (original description of crossover) ·Isolated PMC cases 2017-2024 Cross-cutting practical recommendation Lin 2020 BJSM (11 consistent MSK recommendations) ·Finucane 2020 JOSPT (red flags) Adapted GRADE hierarchy: in practice, the clinician combines sources of all levels according to availability.

GRADE classification (Grading of Recommendations Assessment, Development and Evaluation) applied to the key sources cited in this article.

Case reports have well-identified limitations:

  • Publication bias : successful cases are over-represented compared with failures;
  • Level of evidence V (CEBM) : no causality or generalisation possible;
  • Heterogeneity of reports : no universal standardisation of outcomes;
  • Over-representation of surgery : relative lack of detailed conservative cases with confirmatory imaging (the Ojofeitimi 2016 case is a remarkable exception).

Clinical cases are an excellent teaching tool and a revealer of pitfalls, but major therapeutic decisions must rely on SR/MAs (Maas 2016, Albright 2022, Baker 2022, Wei 2022) and large prospective series.

  • The case of Ojofeitimi 2016 (JOSPT) demonstrates the feasibility of a complete conservative resolution (37 sessions, 16 weeks, return to professional dance) in a patient with a documented rupture of the plantar plate.
  • The surgical series (Nery 2012, Baker 2022 SR/MA n=537) show an improvement in pain and function after dorsal repair + Weil, with frequent dorsal arthrofibrosis (Klein 2026).
  • The main diagnostic trap is the confusion with Morton's neuroma: the two can coexist (reactive pseudo-neuroma on chronic instability).
  • The complex cases are a reminder that 20.3% of surgical hallux valgus have a concomitant MTP2 subluxation, and up to 34.9% of severe deformities (Okuda 2023): it must be corrected simultaneously.
  • Clinical cases are signals and teaching tools, not evidence: major decisions rely on SR/MAs and prospective series.
Bibliography, chapter 5: all references verified on PubMed / CrossRef
  1. Ojofeitimi S, Bronner S, Becica L. Conservative Management of Second Metatarsophalangeal Joint Instability in a Professional Dancer: A Case Report. J Orthop Sports Phys Ther. 2016;46(2):114-123. PMID 26755404.
  2. Nery C, Coughlin MJ, Baumfeld D, Mann TS. Lesser metatarsophalangeal joint instability: prospective evaluation and repair of plantar plate and capsular insufficiency. Foot Ankle Int. 2012;33(4):301-311. PMID 22735202.
  3. Watson TS, Reid DY, Frerichs TL. Dorsal Approach for Plantar Plate Repair With Weil Osteotomy: Operative Technique. Foot Ankle Int. 2014;35(7):730-739. PMID 24850163.
  4. Baker JR, Albright R, Jameson R, et al. Treatment of Lesser Metatarsophalangeal Joint Instability With Plantar Plate Repair: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. J Foot Ankle Surg. 2022;61(5):1114-1118. PMID 35283034.
  5. Kinter CW, Hodgkins CW. Lesser Metatarsophalangeal Instability: Diagnosis and Conservative Management. Sports Health. 2020;12(4):390-394. PMID 32223694.
  6. Albright RH, Brooks BM, Chingre M, Klein EE, Weil LS Jr, Fleischer AE. Diagnostic accuracy of magnetic resonance imaging versus dynamic ultrasound for plantar plate injuries: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Eur J Radiol. 2022;152:110315. doi:10.1016/j.ejrad.2022.110315.
  7. Okuda R, Yoshimura Y, Shima H. Prevalence and radiological characteristics of the dislocation of the second metatarsophalangeal joint in patients undergoing hallux valgus surgery; a matched control study. J Orthop Sci. 2023;28(4):853-859. PMID 35803857.
  8. Coughlin MJ, Jones CP. Hallux valgus and first ray mobility. A prospective study. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2007;89(9):1887-1898. PMID 17768183.
  9. Fleischer AE, Klein EE, Ahmad M, Shah S, Catena F, Weil L Jr, Weil LS Sr. Association of Abnormal Metatarsal Parabola With Second Metatarsophalangeal Joint Plantar Plate Pathology. Foot Ankle Int. 2017;38(3):289-297. PMID 27881742.
  10. Maas NM, van der Grinten M, Bramer WM, Kleinrensink GJ. Metatarsophalangeal joint stability: a systematic review on the plantar plate of the lesser toes. J Foot Ankle Res. 2016;9:32. PMID 27547243.

How do you apply these recommendations concretely in your practice?

In this chapter: operational referral criteria (foot-adapted red flags after Finucane 2020), interprofessional collaboration (podiatrist, sports physician, surgeon), validated PROMs for metatarsalgia (FAAM, FFI, NPRS), application of the 11 cross-cutting MSK recommendations (Lin 2020 BJSM), and classic barriers to implementation.

When, and to which other health professionals, should you refer?

One of the key skills of the physiotherapist in direct access is identifying the situations that fall outside their scope of practice. This triage rests on two registers: red flags (suspected serious pathologies) and yellow flags (psychosocial factors predictive of chronicity).

The international framework of Finucane et al. (2020, JOSPT) stresses that red flags taken in isolation have a low positive predictive value : it is their association (constellation) that should alert and prompt rapid referral.1 For the forefoot, the signs to take into account are: dull night pain, firm non-mobile mass, erythema-fever-swelling (suspected infection / diabetic Charcot foot), history of cancer, unexplained weight loss, polyarthritis with prolonged morning stiffness.

Referral should therefore be considered in these scenarios:

  • To a general practitioner, podiatrist, rheumatologist or orthopaedic surgeon : presence of red flags, no progress after 3-6 months of well-conducted conservative treatment, severe deformity (Coughlin stages 3-4), discussion of interventional alternatives (ESWT, surgery).2
  • To an orthotist / specialised podiatrist : design and fitting of a foot orthosis with a quality retrocapital support, the adjustment of which requires expertise.3
  • To a psychologist / CBT approach : predominant yellow flags (marked kinesiophobia, catastrophising, interfering depressive symptoms) that slow recovery.4
  • To a pain specialist / multidisciplinary team : complex chronic pain, suspected central sensitisation, multi-comorbidity.5

The interprofessional collaboration is a recognised factor of quality of care in the guidelines (Lin 2020): clear referral protocols, shared reports, decision shared with the patient.6

How do you measure outcomes and overcome barriers to implementation?

Measuring outcomes objectively is indispensable to justify continuing treatment, adjust management and document progress. The validated PROMs for metatarsalgia are:

  • NPRS (Numeric Pain Rating Scale, 0-10): pain intensity, MCID approximately 2 points;
  • FAAM (Foot and Ankle Ability Measure): 29 items + 8 sport items, valid for foot/ankle function;
  • FFI (Foot Function Index): pain + disability + activity limitation;
  • AOFAS (American Orthopaedic Foot & Ankle Society score): widely used in surgery but criticised for its limited psychometric properties.

Systematic use of these tools allows follow-up over time and shared decision-making. However, their implementation in daily practice runs into several classic obstacles:

  1. Therapist-side obstacles : lack of time, little familiarity with the tools, residual biomedical beliefs, inertia of habits;
  2. Patient-side obstacles : expectations oriented towards passive techniques, low health literacy, socio-economic constraints;
  3. Systemic obstacles : reimbursement of passive modalities rather than education/exercise, lack of organisational support, imperfect interprofessional communication.6

The 11 cross-cutting recommendations identified by Lin et al. (2020) for MSK conditions are applicable without reservation to MTP2: (1) patient-centred care, (2) screening for red flags, (3) assessment of yellow flags, (4) selective imaging, (5) complete physical examination, (6) monitoring of progress, (7) education and information, (8) prescription of exercise, (9) passive modalities as an adjunct only, (10) surgery as a last resort, (11) encouraging continued activity.6

Critique and controversy: beyond the simple application of recommendations

Several nuances must be integrated:

  • The “tyranny of red flags” is an emerging criticism: an excessive and anxiety-provoking search can paradoxically increase the use of unnecessary imaging, generate iatrogenic anxiety and reinforce negative beliefs about the “fragility” of the body. Competence lies in the ability to reassure as much as to alert.1
  • The theory/practice gap in the biopsychosocial model remains wide: many therapists say they adopt it but in practice remain centred on biomechanical aspects. Addressing yellow flags requires advanced communication skills.5
  • The reduction of the patient to a score via PROMs: improvement in the numbers is not equivalent to the patient's subjective satisfaction; PROMs are a starting point for the conversation, not an end in themselves.
  • Rigid application of recommendations must always leave room for individualisation: goals, sporting and professional context, patient preferences.
  • Identifying red flags (night pain, mass, fever, weight loss, history of cancer) requires prompt medical referral, but their isolated predictive value is low (Finucane 2020).
  • The yellow flags (kinesiophobia, catastrophising) are major predictors of chronicity and justify a biopsychosocial approach or collaboration with a psychologist/CBT.
  • The interprofessional collaboration (podiatrist, sports physician, surgeon, psychologist) is a factor of quality of care.
  • The PROMs (NPRS, FAAM, FFI) are indispensable for measuring progress, but do not replace the patient-centred conversation.
  • The 11 MSK recommendations (Lin 2020 BJSM) are applicable to MTP2: patient-centred care, screening for flags, exercise + education, selective imaging, passive modalities as an adjunct only.
Bibliography, chapter 6: all references verified on PubMed / CrossRef
  1. Finucane LM, Downie A, Mercer C, et al. International Framework for Red Flags for Potential Serious Spinal Pathologies. J Orthop Sports Phys Ther. 2020;50(7):350-372. PMID 32438853.
  2. Kinter CW, Hodgkins CW. Lesser Metatarsophalangeal Instability: Diagnosis and Conservative Management. Sports Health. 2020;12(4):390-394. PMID 32223694.
  3. Espinosa N, Maceira E, Myerson MS. Current concept review: metatarsalgia. Foot Ankle Int. 2008;29(8):871-879. PMID 18752791.
  4. Foster NE, Anema JR, Cherkin D, et al. Prevention and treatment of low back pain: evidence, challenges, and promising directions. Lancet. 2018;391(10137):2368-2383. PMID 29573872.
  5. O'Sullivan PB, Caneiro JP, O'Keeffe M, et al. Cognitive Functional Therapy: An Integrated Behavioral Approach for the Targeted Management of Disabling Low Back Pain. Phys Ther. 2018;98(5):408-423. PMID 29669082.
  6. Lin I, Wiles L, Waller R, et al. What does best practice care for musculoskeletal pain look like? Eleven consistent recommendations from high-quality clinical practice guidelines: systematic review. Br J Sports Med. 2020;54(2):79-86. PMID 30826805.
  7. Ojofeitimi S, Bronner S, Becica L. Conservative Management of Second Metatarsophalangeal Joint Instability in a Professional Dancer: A Case Report. J Orthop Sports Phys Ther. 2016;46(2):114-123. PMID 26755404.
  8. Martin RL, Irrgang JJ, Burdett RG, Conti SF, Van Swearingen JM. Evidence of validity for the Foot and Ankle Ability Measure (FAAM). Foot Ankle Int. 2005;26(11):968-983. PMID 16309613.
  9. Budiman-Mak E, Conrad KJ, Roach KE. The Foot Function Index: a measure of foot pain and disability. J Clin Epidemiol. 1991;44(6):561-570. PMID 2037861.
  10. Hawker GA, Mian S, Kendzerska T, French M. Measures of adult pain: Visual Analog Scale for Pain (VAS Pain), Numeric Rating Scale for Pain (NRS Pain), McGill Pain Questionnaire (MPQ), Short-Form McGill Pain Questionnaire (SF-MPQ), Chronic Pain Grade Scale (CPGS), Short Form-36 Bodily Pain Scale (SF-36 BPS), and Measure of Intermittent and Constant Osteoarthritis Pain (ICOAP). Arthritis Care Res. 2011;63 Suppl 11:S240-252. PMID 22588748.

What next after reading this?

This article is part of a collection of evidence-based clinical syntheses. A question, a comment, a correction to suggest? Contact us directly through the WhatsApp button at the bottom right of the screen.

Behind this article

An author who explains, a reviewer who checks.

How we write and check our content

Anthony Baillon, physiotherapist and co-founder of Physio Learning
✍️ Author

Anthony Baillon

Physiotherapist · co-founder of Physio Learning

Marked for life by his first four-hour lecture without a single image, he took a master’s in instructional design so that it would never happen to anyone again. He hunts down publication bias and unreadable slides with the same intransigence.

PhysiotherapistInstructional designerCare design
Follow on LinkedIn
Robin Vervaeke, head of scientific content at Physio Learning✓ Checked

Robin Vervaeke

Scientific lead

Physiotherapist specialising in neuro-musculoskeletal practice and holder of a master’s in public health. He checks the methodological rigour of every article: primary sources, levels of evidence, no exceptions.

NeuromusculoskeletalMaster's in public health
Follow on LinkedIn

Share