Skip to content
Sign up

Updated · published

The osteoporotic vertebral compression fracture: 2026 update

Vertebral compression fracture: a quarter to a third are recognised, and 19.2 % recur within a year. Red flags, imaging, vertebroplasty and exercise.

The essentials, in 30 seconds

An osteoporotic vertebral fracture is not rare, it is rarely named: only a quarter to a third are recognised at the time they occur.

19.2%of vertebral recurrence in the year following an incident fracture

What it is
The fracture is not an accident, it is a symptom: it reveals a bone that gives way under ordinary stresses.
What puts you on the trail
No isolated red flag makes the diagnosis: it is their accumulation that really shifts the probability, up to 90% according to one review.
How to decide
The X-ray answers “is there a deformity”, MRI “is it recent”: two different questions, and it is the second that governs the session.
What to do first
Three levers, and none consists in treating the bone: spotting that osteoporosis is untreated, reducing falls, and giving the patient back a spine that holds up.
What to avoid
Loaded flexion is to be avoided in the recent phase, but generic lifelong prohibitions are counterproductive.

What follows covers each of these points in detail, with sources. It is there if you need it.

This topic is taught in a course: Neurology and geriatrics, online with Bryan Littré.

Chapter by chapter

1 / 14

13 article chapters · 56 min in total

Chapter 1

Underdiagnosis◔ 4 min

The vertebral body gives way without an impact, under an ordinary load: carrying a shopping bag, coughing, bending.

Radiology
Only one radiology report in five mentioned the vertebral fracture.
Missed treatment
Only 24% of patients left hospital with anti-osteoporotic treatment.
EPOS incidence
The incidence is 10.7 per 1,000 person-years in women, 5.7 in men.
Men too
Men are not spared: the ratio is about two to one, not ten to one.
Chapter 2

Suspecting◔ 6 min

No isolated red flag is enough; it is their combination that informs.

Trauma
Trauma has a positive likelihood ratio of 6.42 for osteoporotic fracture.
Roman's cluster
Two items or fewer out of five give a sensitivity of 0.95, the fracture becomes unlikely.
Wall-occiput
If the occiput does not touch the wall, the positive likelihood ratio is 4.6.
Weight
A weight under 51 kg gives the highest likelihood ratio of the review.
Chapter 3

Imaging◔ 5 min

The lateral X-ray shows the deformity, not whether it is recent: that is the job of MRI.

Lateral view
The lateral view of the spine is the projection that shows the vertebral height loss.
Genant
Genant's method grades the loss of height: grade 1 for 20 to 25%.
Dating
A grade 2 compression on a film carries no date: it may be six weeks old.
Necessity
It is the imaging that the literature identifies as necessary to recognise silent fractures.
Chapter 4

Differentials◔ 3 min

The real trap is not confusing the compression fracture: it is not thinking of it at all.

False lead
In an older person, finding a vertebral deformity is nothing exceptional: it is expected.
Scar or fracture
An old deformity without oedema on MRI is not an active fracture: it is a scar.
Decisive MRI
It is the bone marrow oedema on MRI that distinguishes the vertebra that is suffering from the one that has suffered.
Chapter 5

Recurrence risk◔ 4 min

A first vertebral fracture multiplies by 5.1 the risk of having another within the year.

Key figure
The incidence of a new fracture in the following year was 19.2%.
Mortality
The standardised mortality rate after clinical vertebral fracture is 1.82 in women.
Men more affected
In men, this mortality rate rises to 2.12, with an excess mortality that persists for five years.
Global marker
Vertebral fracture is a marker of global frailty, not only a bone predictor.
Chapter 6

Prevention◔ 5 min

Three levers, and none consists in treating the bone directly: spotting, reducing falls, strengthening.

Asking the question
Asking “are you taking any treatment for your bones” is the most cost-effective contribution.
Falls
Exercise reduces the rate of falls by 23%, with high certainty, which is rare in this field.
Combined programmes
Programmes combining balance and strengthening reduce falls by 34%.
Spinal extensors
Strengthening of the extensors gave 1.6% of fractures versus 4.3% in controls.
Chapter 7

Vertebroplasty◔ 6 min

Twenty years of vertebroplasty trials give results that contradict one another.

VERTOS II
In VERTOS II, 53% of eligible patients saw their pain resolve spontaneously.
Two readings
Against placebo, across five trials, pain does not move in a clinically important way.
Kyphoplasty
Kyphoplasty restores more height, but the gains do not translate clinically.
Practical consequence
The technique used upstream does not change the rehabilitation conducted afterwards.
Chapter 8

Brace◔ 2 min

The spinal brace is prescribed very widely, but the literature that supports it is thin.

Few studies
Only three studies, involving 153 people, evaluated bracing in the acute phase.
Deformity
There are not enough data to say that bracing modifies vertebral deformity.
Rigid braces at risk
It is with rigid braces that complications were most numerous.
Chapter 9

Rehabilitation◔ 5 min

Physiotherapy after vertebral fracture has not demonstrated much, but remains to be conducted well.

Cochrane 2019
The Timed Up and Go improves by 1.13 seconds (95% CI 0.42 to 1.85).
Gain judged small
The authors themselves judge that a one-second gain is not clinically important.
PROVE
The largest trial in the field, 615 patients, finds no difference between the three arms at 12 months.
At four months
Benefits exist at four months, but do not persist at twelve months.
Chapter 10

Spinal flexion◔ 5 min

Loaded flexion is to be avoided in the recent phase, but lifelong prohibitions are counterproductive.

Founding study
The rule comes from a single study from 1984, in 59 women.
Raw figures
Flexion alone: 89% of new fractures in 9 patients, in the founding 1984 study.
Too Fit consensus
The consensus recommends spine-sparing techniques rather than generic prohibitions.
LIFTMOR
High-intensity training gave +2.9% lumbar bone density versus −1.2%.
Chapter 11

Clinical cases◔ 4 min

Four cases show the possible trajectories, from the good outcome to the missed diagnosis.

Case 1
A 74-year-old man with a wedge fracture of L1 was treated entirely conservatively.
Ordinary mechanism
The pain occurred after lifting an object, without violent trauma.
Chapter 12

In practice◔ 3 min

Four decisions sum it all up: think of the fracture, know when to stop, know how to act, treat the bone.

Date
Pain that started on a specific day, in a person over 65, changes the status of the history.
Corticosteroids
Look for corticosteroids: the most informative red flag in primary care.
Phase 1
In the recent phase, loaded flexion is avoided, as is posteroanterior pressure on the spinous processes.
The letter
A letter with three precise lines does more than one more session.
Chapter 13

Questions◔ 4 min

The useful benchmark is not a fixed duration but a direction: the pain should decrease.

Consolidation
There is no published standard timeframe for the consolidation of a compression fracture.
Increasing pain
Pain that increases over the weeks raises suspicion of pseudarthrosis.
Manipulation
Manipulating the spine is to be avoided until a recent fracture has been ruled out.
14

Train on this

OnlineFIFPL

Neurological rehabilitation

Neurology and geriatrics

Bryan Littré · Lucas Meilhou

Next comes practice: the course that teaches this topic, with Bryan Littré.

Our courses on this topic may be covered by DPC or FIFPL, the French continuing-education funding schemes, depending on your profession and situation.

Posted by

Anthony BAILLON

Physiotherapist


A 76-year-old woman consults for back pain that appeared “just like that”, without a fall, without an awkward movement. It hurts when she gets up from a chair, and is better when she is lying down. The picture resembles ordinary mechanical thoracic spine pain, and when what has just happened is a vertebral fracture, it is recognised at the moment it occurs in only a quarter to a third of cases: the others, no one will name.1

This article treats the vertebral fracture as a reason for consultation: spotting it when nothing signals it, knowing what must interrupt the session, and what can be done afterwards. For the bone disease itself (densitometry, T-score thresholds, anti-osteoporotic treatments, primary prevention), see Osteoporosis and the prevention of fragility fractures.

Three figures that drive management

What the literature establishes on detection, recurrence and mortality.

Three key figures on osteoporotic vertebral fracture Only a quarter to a third of vertebral fractures are recognised clinically when they occur; 19.2% of patients with an incident vertebral fracture have another within the year; the standardised mortality rate after clinical vertebral fracture is 1.82 in women. 1/4-1/3 are only recognised when they occur the others appear only on spine imaging 19.2% fracture the spine again within the following year 95% CI 13.6 to 24.8 after an incident fracture 1.82 standardised mortality in women, 2.12 in men excess mortality measured up to 5 years after the fracture

Sources: clinical recognition, Schousboe 2016, review of the epidemiology of vertebral fractures;1 recurrence at one year, Lindsay 2001, analysis of 2,725 women from the placebo arms of four trials;4 mortality, Bliuc 2009, prospective Dubbo cohort6.

Clinical summary

What to take away in one minute

  • The fracture is often silent. Only a quarter to a third of vertebral fractures are recognised clinically at the time they occur; the others are seen only on lateral spine imaging.1 When a chest CT scan is available in patients hospitalised for hip fracture, 40% have at least one vertebral fracture, and only one radiology report in five mentions it.2
  • No single red flag is decisive. The 2023 Cochrane review concludes that most of the recommended red flags are not useful. Those that inform in primary care are trauma (positive likelihood ratio 6.42) and corticosteroid therapy (2.46); it is their accumulation that makes the decision.89
  • A cluster of five items exists for the physiotherapist. Age > 52 years, no leg pain, BMI ≤ 22, sedentary lifestyle, female sex: two items or fewer make the fracture unlikely (sensitivity 0.95, negative likelihood ratio 0.16); four out of five make it likely (positive ratio 9.6).10
  • One fracture heralds others. 19.2% new vertebral fractures in the year following an incident fracture;4 about four times the risk of subsequent vertebral fracture when a prevalent fracture exists.5 This is where the physiotherapist's role goes beyond pain.
  • Vertebroplasty remains debated, and the debate has shifted. Against placebo, the 2018 Cochrane review finds no clinically important benefit;15 but the VAPOUR trial, restricted to very painful fractures less than six weeks old, is positive.16 The debate is now about who, not about whether.
  • Braces have not proved themselves after an acute fracture, and it is with rigid models that complications are most numerous.22
  • Exercise has not been shown to prevent fractures: the 2019 Cochrane review says so plainly23 and the largest physiotherapy trial in the field, PROVE, is negative at twelve months.24 What it does show is something else: exercise reduces the rate of falls by 23%.30
  • Loaded spinal flexion remains the movement not to teach in the recent phase, on the strength of an old study with tiny numbers but never contradicted;26 and the international consensus asks for spine-sparing techniques rather than generic prohibitions.28

Why are most of these fractures never diagnosed?

Because they have neither the noise nor the scene of a fracture. There is no spectacular fall, no sudden loss of function, no deformity visible under the skin. There is a back that hurts in someone whose back hurting is considered normal.

The word “fracture” evokes an event. This one is not an event. The osteoporotic vertebral body does not break under an impact: it gives way under a load that healthy bone would have borne without flinching. Carrying a shopping bag, pulling a sheet, coughing, bending to tie a shoelace, sitting down a little heavily: the history often reports nothing more. In some patients there is not even that: the fracture is discovered months later on an X-ray taken for something else.

The reference figure comes from the review by Schousboe published in the Journal of Clinical Densitometry: only a quarter to a third of vertebral fractures are recognised clinically at the time they occur, the others requiring lateral imaging of the spine to be detected.1 This wording must be read exactly: it does not say that two thirds of fractures are asymptomatic, it says that they are not recognised. The nuance changes where the responsibility lies. Many of these patients had pain. They consulted. They were told it was age.

The osteoporotic vertebral fracture is not silent: it is inaudible. It speaks the same language as ordinary thoracic spine pain, in a population where ordinary thoracic spine pain is the norm.

What the radiologist sees and what the radiologist writes

Underdiagnosis does not stop at the clinic. It also runs through the imaging chain. An Irish study reviewed the thoracic CT angiograms performed in patients hospitalised for hip fracture between 2010 and 2017: of the 225 patients whose images were available, 40% had at least one vertebral fracture and 20% had several. Only one radiology report in five mentioned it. And only 24% of patients left hospital with anti-osteoporotic treatment, with no difference between those who had a vertebral fracture and those who did not.2

In other words, in patients already hospitalised for a fragility fracture, whose vertebrae had already been imaged, whose fracture was already on the image, the chain did not reach a conclusion. This is the chain that the physiotherapist can interrupt, because they are often the professional who sees these patients for the longest and most often.

Four measures of the gap between what happens and what is treated

Each stage of the chain loses patients: the fracture occurs, the image exists, the report is silent, the treatment does not start.

Four statistics on the underdiagnosis of vertebral fracture Among patients hospitalised for hip fracture, 40% have at least one vertebral fracture on CT, 20% have several, only 20% of radiology reports flag it and 24% leave with anti-osteoporotic treatment. 40% have at least one vertebral fracture 90 of 225 patients on thoracic CT 20% have more than one on the same examination 46 of 225 patients risk further increased 1 in 5 reports flags the fracture blind re-reading by an MSK radiologist 24% leave with bone treatment and with no difference depending on the presence of fracture

Source: Kelly et al. 2021, Journal of Clinical Densitometry, retrospective cohort of 2,122 hip fractures, 225 CT angiograms re-read blind and graded according to Genant.2

How often does this really happen?

The European prospective EPOS study remains the reference measurement on this continent: 14,011 men and women aged 50 and over, recruited in 29 centres, X-rayed and then X-rayed again 3.8 years later on average. The age-standardised incidence of morphometric fractures was 10.7 per 1,000 person-years in women and 5.7 in men, with a marked rise with age in both sexes.3

Two practical lessons are hidden in it. The first is that men are not spared: the ratio is about two to one, not ten to one. A 78-year-old man who complains of back pain deserves exactly the same vigilance as a woman of the same age. The second is that incidence rises steeply with age, which shifts the pre-test probability with each decade: the same clinical picture does not mean the same thing at 60 and at 82.

Incidence of vertebral fractures in Europe

Two methods of reading the same radiographs, two sexes: the order of magnitude is stable.

Age-standardised incidence of vertebral fractures in the EPOS study Incidence per thousand person-years: morphometric reading 10.7 in women and 5.7 in men; qualitative reading by the radiologist 12.1 in women and 6.8 in men. 0 3 6 9 12 15 incidence per 1,000 person-years, age-standardised Women, morphometry 10.7 Women, reading by the radiologist 12.1 Men, morphometry 5.7 Men, reading by the radiologist 6.8

Source: European Prospective Osteoporosis Study Group 2002, Journal of Bone and Mineral Research; 14,011 subjects aged 50 and over, 29 European centres, paired radiographs 3.8 years apart on average, fracture defined by a height loss of 20% and 4 mm.3

Key points

  • Osteoporotic vertebral fracture is not rare, it is rarely named: only a quarter to a third are recognised at the time they occur.1
  • Underdiagnosis is collective: it also plays out in imaging reports and in the discharge prescription after hospitalisation.2
  • Men account for about one case in three on a European scale, not a clinical exception.3

How can a compression fracture be suspected behind ordinary thoracic or low back pain?

The honest answer is: not with a single sign. Research over the past twenty years has demolished the idea that an isolated red flag is enough. What remains, and is usable in the clinic, is a way of counting.

The 2023 Cochrane review led by Han and Hancock reviewed fourteen diagnostic studies comparing the history and physical examination with reference-standard imaging. Its conclusion is frank: most red flags are not useful for screening for vertebral fracture in a patient with low back pain. Those that inform, in primary care, are trauma (positive likelihood ratio of 6.42; 95% CI 2.94 to 14.02 for osteoporotic fracture specifically) and corticosteroid therapy (2.46; 1.13 to 5.34). Advanced age informs mainly for unspecified vertebral fracture. And above all: combinations of red flags perform better than individual items.8

The Downie review published in the BMJ in 2013 had already given the measure in post-test probabilities, which are more telling than likelihood ratios: in a patient with low back pain, prolonged corticosteroid therapy raises the probability of fracture to 33% (CI 10 to 67), advanced age to 9% (3 to 25), severe trauma to 11% (8 to 16). And when several red flags are present simultaneously, the probability of spinal fracture rises to 90% (34-99).9 The intervals are wide (these are small studies) but the direction is consistent.

Roman's cluster: five questions the physiotherapist can ask

One tool is worth knowing because it was built for and by manual therapists, and because the 2023 Cochrane review retained it as the most informative combination of its review. Roman and Cook analysed more than 1,400 patients from a spine surgery centre and isolated a cluster of five characteristics:10

  1. age over 52 years;
  2. no pain radiating into the leg;
  3. body mass index less than or equal to 22;
  4. no regular physical activity;
  5. female sex.

Two positive items or fewer give a sensitivity of 0.95 (CI 0.83 to 0.99) and a negative likelihood ratio of 0.16 (0.04 to 0.51): the fracture becomes unlikely, which is the most useful function in daily practice. Four items out of five give a positive likelihood ratio of 9.6 (3.7 to 14.9), recalculated as 9.62 (5.88 to 15.73) by the Cochrane review from the raw data.810

It must be said what this tool is not. It was derived in a specialised surgical centre population, where the prevalence of fracture is far higher than in a community practice, and the authors themselves write that prospective validation in a separate sample remains necessary. It has not taken place. The cluster is therefore a structured aide-memoire, not an approved test: it organises doubt, it does not replace it.

What the signs available in the clinic are really worth

Positive likelihood ratios. Above 5, the sign usefully shifts the probability; between 1 and 2, it changes almost nothing.

Positive likelihood ratios of the signs of vertebral fracture Roman's cluster with four items out of five 9.6; weight under 51 kilos 7.3; trauma 6.42; wall-occiput distance greater than zero 4.6; rib-pelvis distance less than two fingerbreadths 3.8; height loss of four centimetres 2.89; corticosteroid therapy 2.46. 1 2 4 6 8 10 positive likelihood ratio Roman's cluster, 4 items out of 5 9.6 Weight under 51 kg 7.3 Trauma, osteoporotic fracture 6.42 Wall-occiput distance > 0 cm 4.6 Rib-pelvis < 2 fingerbreadths 3.8 Height loss of 4 cm 2.89 Corticosteroid therapy 2.46

Sources: Roman's cluster, Roman et al. 2010;10 weight, wall-occiput and rib-pelvis, Green et al. 2004, JAMA, review of the clinical examination;11 trauma and corticosteroid therapy for osteoporotic fracture, 2023 Cochrane review;8 height loss, Mikula et al. 2017, 66,021 patients.12 The confidence intervals appear in the body text; they are wide for several of these signs.

The three measurements that cost thirty seconds

The review of the clinical examination published in JAMA by Green and colleagues evaluated physical manoeuvres for the diagnosis of osteoporosis and occult spinal fracture. Three of them are performed without equipment:11

  • The wall-occiput distance. The patient stands with heels and back against the wall, gaze horizontal. If the occiput does not touch the wall, the distance is greater than zero: positive likelihood ratio of 4.6 (CI 2.9 to 7.3) for an occult spinal fracture.11
  • The rib-pelvis distance. With the patient standing, arms abducted, the space between the lower costal margin and the iliac crest is measured laterally. Less than two fingerbreadths: positive likelihood ratio of 3.8 (2.9 to 5.1).11
  • Weight. Under 51 kg gives the highest ratio of the review, 7.3 (5.0 to 10.8)11 (for osteoporosis, not for fracture). It is not a sign of fracture, it is a sign of the patient's background, and it is worth noting.

Documented height loss deserves a separate mention, because it is often quoted without its figures. The Mikula study of 66,021 patients shows a specificity that climbs quickly but a sensitivity that collapses: at 1, 2, 3 and 4 cm of height loss, the sensitivity for detecting a vertebral fracture is 42, 32, 19 and 14% and the specificity 70, 82, 92 and 95%.12 Clinical translation: a documented height loss of 3 or 4 cm justifies investigation, but the absence of height loss rules out nothing at all: even at the most sensitive threshold, 1 cm, nearly six fractures in ten escape detection.

Red flags: what should stop or change the session

None of these items requires “doing nothing any more”. Each requires not doing what was planned and obtaining a medical opinion before resuming.

  • Spinal pain of recent onset in a person over 65, without a proportionate injury mechanism. This is the basic picture of a compression fracture. The session becomes an assessment session, not a treatment session.
  • Pain elicited by percussion of a specific spinous process, reproducible from one session to the next. A painful point that does not move is not a point of muscle tension.
  • Prolonged oral corticosteroid therapy, ongoing or recent. This is the red flag that carries the highest post-test probability of spinal fracture in the Downie review, apart from direct trauma: 33% (CI 10 to 67).9 It remains informative for osteoporotic fracture specifically in the 2023 Cochrane review.8
  • Pain that increases over time whereas a recent vertebral fracture usually improves over a few weeks. Pain that worsens raises suspicion of progressive collapse, pseudarthrosis, or something other than an osteoporotic fracture.
  • Non-positional night pain, deterioration of general condition, history of cancer, fever. Here the question is no longer benign compression fracture but metastasis, myeloma or spondylodiscitis: referral is urgent.
  • Any neurological sign: motor deficit, sphincter disturbance, saddle anaesthesia, sensory level. Rare in osteoporotic fracture, but described, notably in late collapses.3334 This is an emergency, not a reassessment.
  • Documented height loss of 3 cm or more, or recent-onset kyphosis with a worsening wall-occiput distance.1112

⚠️ The safety rule fits in one sentence: as long as a recent fracture has not been ruled out, we do not manipulate, we do not mobilise forcefully, we do not apply posteroanterior pressure to the spinous processes, and we do not load the spine in flexion.

Key points

  • No isolated red flag makes the diagnosis; it is their accumulation that really shifts the probability, up to 90% in the Downie review.9
  • As for Roman's cluster, it serves first to rule out: two items or fewer, negative likelihood ratio 0.16.10 It has never been validated prospectively.
  • The loss of height is specific but poorly sensitive: its absence rules nothing out.12

Which imaging to request, and to whom should the patient be referred?

Sagittal T2-weighted MRI of the lumbar spine: L1 compression fracture indicated by an arrow, with associated stenosis at L4-L5.

MRISagittal T2-weighted MRI of the lumbar spine: L1 compression fracture indicated by an arrow, with associated stenosis at L4-L5.

Source : Hatgis et al., Cureus, 2017, figure 1 · CC BY

The physiotherapist does not prescribe imaging, but is often the one who triggers the request. Knowing which examination answers which question avoids sending a patient away with an X-ray that will not say what we wanted to know.

Three questions, three examinations

“Is there a vertebral deformity?” The thoracic and lumbar spine X-ray in lateral view answers that one. The lateral view is not a detail: it is the projection on which loss of vertebral body height is read, and it is precisely the imaging that the literature identifies as necessary to recognise the fractures that escape clinical detection.1 Grading uses Genant's semi-quantitative method, which remains the reference thirty years after its publication and whose founding article mainly establishes inter- and intra-observer reproducibility.13 In its usual formulation, it grades the loss of vertebral body height: grade 1 for about 20 to 25%, grade 2 for 25 to 40%, grade 3 beyond 40%.

“Is this fracture recent?” The X-ray does not say. A grade 2 compression on a film carries no date: it may be six weeks old or six years old. It is MRI that answers, by the presence of bone marrow oedema (hyperintense signal on STIR or fat-saturated T2 sequences, hypointense on T1). It is the examination that distinguishes the vertebra that has just given way from the one that gave way long ago, and this distinction governs the whole management: the first requires caution, the second allows progressive loading.

CT can settle some cases when MRI is unavailable or contraindicated. A German study of 192 fractures measured the ability of multidetector CT alone to separate recent or subacute fractures from old ones: the area under the curve reaches 0.854 and 0.861 depending on the readers, with a sensitivity of 97.2 and 94.5% but a specificity of only 58.1 and 65.1% when doubtful cases are classified as recent.14 In other words, CT misses few recent fractures but overdiagnoses many: it is poorly reassuring. One sign is an exception, double trabecular compaction, present in about half of recent fractures but highly specific (93.2 and 88.6%).14

“Does this patient have untreated osteoporosis?” That is bone densitometry, and it is the general practitioner or the rheumatologist who requests it. The point to know for the physiotherapist is that in France, the updated recommendations of the French Society of Rheumatology and the GRIO recommend drug treatment in women with a severe fracture, vertebral fracture being in this category, without requiring a prior densitometric threshold.35 A patient who comes out of a vertebral fracture with no bone treatment at all is not a borderline case: it is a departure from the recommendation, and flagging it is part of the job.

What each examination says and does not say. The distinction recent / old is the one that changes the physiotherapy management.
ExaminationAnswersDoes not answerWhat it changes in the session
Lateral X-ray, thoracic and lumbar spine Is there a deformity? Which Genant grade13? Since when. An old compression and yesterday's compression look the same on the image. Confirms the background and the number of levels affected; cannot on its own authorise loading.
MRI with a STIR or fat-saturated T2 sequence Is the fracture recent? Is there bone marrow oedema? Is there posterior wall retropulsion, neurological compression? Bone mineral density. It is the examination that does or does not authorise progressive loading and the resumption of resisted exercises.
CT Cortex, geometry, posterior wall; approximate dating. Reliable dating: specificity of 58 and 65% depending on the reader for “recent”.14 Useful as a second-line examination; does not remove the need for MRI when the question is the freshness of the fracture.
Bone densitometry The T-score, hence the bone background and the drug indication. The existence of a fracture, which it does not see outside a dedicated spine analysis module. Nothing directly, but its absence in a fractured patient is a signal to pass on.35

Decision tree for spinal pain in the older person

The question is not “should everyone be imaged”, it is “does this particular patient cross a threshold”.

Decision tree for spinal pain in the older person In the face of recent spinal pain after 65: any neurological or general sign requires urgent referral; otherwise, the red flags and the items of Roman's cluster are counted. Two items or fewer and no red flag allow conservative treatment with reassessment at three weeks. One or more red flags, or four items out of five, require a lateral X-ray, supplemented by an MRI if it must be known whether the fracture is recent. Recent spinal pain, patient over 65 without a proportionate injury mechanism Neurological sign, fever, known cancer, general deterioration? If yes: urgent medical referral, the session stops here Count: red flags, then Roman's cluster age, no leg pain, low BMI, sedentary lifestyle, female sex 0 red flags and 2 items or fewer Fracture unlikely: negative likelihood ratio 0.16 Conservative treatment, reassessment at 3 weeks 1 red flag or more, or 4 items out of 5 Fracture probable: positive likelihood ratio 9.6 Lateral X-ray requested from the doctor Deformity confirmed MRI if the question is: is it recent? Marrow oedema on STIR = active fracture, no loading or forceful mobilisation A reassessment that shows no improvement at 3 weeks, or that worsens, shifts into the right-hand column: the pain of a recent fracture usually decreases, that of a progressive collapse increases.

Editorial construction from published thresholds: red flags and combinations, 2023 Cochrane review8 and Downie 2013;9 five-item cluster, Roman 2010;10 Genant grading13. This algorithm has not been prospectively validated as such.

Key points

  • The X-ray answers “is there a deformity”, MRI answers “is it recent”. These are two different questions and the second governs the session.
  • CT dates poorly: high sensitivity but specificity of 58 to 60% for recent fracture.14
  • A fractured patient with no anti-osteoporotic treatment is a departure from the French recommendation, to be reported to the doctor.35

What looks like an osteoporotic compression fracture without being one?

The differential diagnosis works in both directions. One must know how to recognise the compression fracture beneath thoracic spine pain that would have been called mechanical, and also know that a compression fracture visible on imaging does not necessarily explain the pain of the day.

The most common trap is not to confuse the compression fracture with another disease: it is not thinking of it at all, because the picture fits perfectly with something ordinary. Three entities of the spine, each dealt with in detail elsewhere on this site, present in the same patient and sometimes on the same day.

Four pictures that resemble one another in the older person. The “what points towards it” columns are not diagnostic criteria: they are shifts in probability.
EntityWhat points towards itWhat points against itManagement
Vertebral compression fracture Clear, dated onset even without trauma; segmental pain on percussion; pain on moving from sitting to standing; relief when lying down; height loss; corticosteroid therapy. Long-standing fluctuating pain over years; exclusively posterolateral pain reproduced by combined movements. Lateral imaging; suspension of forceful techniques until the result.
Thoracic spine pain Interscapular or paravertebral pain, often postural, aggravated by prolonged holding and improved by movement. A dated sudden onset; pain that worsens week after week. Active management; imaging not systematic.
Non-specific low back pain Long history, repeated episodes, examination without a fixed painful point. A first episode of life after 70 should prompt reflection before being labelled non-specific. Classic biopsychosocial model; reassess if the trajectory departs from it.
Lumbar facet joint arthropathy Pain on extension and rotation, relieved by flexion; non-radicular gluteal radiation. Pain relieved by strict lying down and reproduced by spinous percussion. Conservative treatment; lateral imaging remains useful if the background is osteoporotic.
Pathological fracture: metastasis, myeloma Non-positional night pain, deterioration of general condition, history of neoplasia, involvement of the posterior wall or pedicle on imaging. Strictly mechanical pain in an otherwise healthy patient. Medical referral without delay. This is not a physiotherapist's diagnosis, it is a reason for referral.

The compression fracture that does not explain the pain

The reverse reasoning deserves as much attention. In a person of 80, finding a vertebral deformity on an X-ray is nothing exceptional: it is even expected. Automatically attributing the day's pain to this image is reproducing on the thoracic spine the error that physiotherapy took twenty years to unlearn on the lumbar spine. An old deformity, without marrow oedema on MRI, is not an active fracture: it is a scar.

A compression fracture on an X-ray has no date. It is the bone marrow oedema on MRI that distinguishes the vertebra that is suffering from the one that has suffered.

This distinction has a direct consequence on what we allow ourselves. With a recent fracture, caution is called for regarding loading and flexion. With an old, painless deformity in a patient whose pain comes from elsewhere, the same caution becomes an unjustified brake, and the international recommendations insist precisely on this point: not turning a history of fracture into a list of lifelong prohibitions.28

On the same spine, elsewhere on this site

Key points

  • The trap is not confusing, it is not thinking of it: the compression fracture presents as ordinary thoracic spine pain.
  • The first lumbar episode of a lifetime after 70 should not be labelled “non-specific” without reflection.
  • An old deformity without marrow oedema does not explain the pain of the day and does not justify lifelong prohibitions.28

Why does a first vertebral fracture herald others?

Sagittal MRI of the lumbar spine: severely collapsed vertebra with marked kyphotic angulation, a sequela of an untreated fracture.

MRISagittal MRI of the lumbar spine: severely collapsed vertebra with marked kyphotic angulation, a sequela of an untreated fracture.

Source : Jacobson et al., Cureus, 2017, figure 1 · CC BY

Because the fracture is not an accident, it is a symptom. It reveals a bone that gives way under ordinary stresses, and that bone does not become normal again because the pain has settled.

This is the figure to know by heart. Lindsay and colleagues analysed the 2,725 postmenopausal women randomised to the placebo arms of four large osteoporosis trials. Among the 381 participants who developed an incident vertebral fracture during the study, the incidence of a new vertebral fracture in the following year was 19.2% (95% CI 13.6 to 24.8). And the presence of at least one vertebral fracture at baseline multiplied the risk of fracturing during the first year of the study by 5.1.4

One woman in five. Within the year. This figure circulates a lot in distorted forms (“20%”, “one in five”, sometimes “25%”) without the primary source being cited. Here it is, with its population: postmenopausal women with a mean age of 74, on placebo, in trials where fractures were detected radiographically, including those that had never manifested clinically.4

The statistical synthesis by Klotzbuecher, published in the Journal of Bone and Mineral Research, gives the overall picture across all fracture sites. Its most striking result: the strongest association in the whole literature is that between prior vertebral fracture and subsequent vertebral fracture, with a risk about four times higher, which rises further with the number of fractures already present. For the other combinations of sites (hip, wrist, spine) the relative risk is around 2.5

The fracture cascade, in measured risks

The spine predicts the spine better than any other site predicts anything.

Risks of subsequent fracture after a vertebral fracture After an incident vertebral fracture, 19.2% new vertebral fractures within the year. The risk of subsequent vertebral fracture is multiplied by about four in the presence of a prevalent vertebral fracture, and by five during the first year of observation. The other combinations of sites give a relative risk of about two. No fracture vertebral reference baseline risk of the population Vertebral fracture already present × 4 approximately and more if multiple Vertebral fracture occurring this year 19.2% of refracture within 12 months Comparison of measured relative risks Vertebra after vertebra ≈ 4.0 Any site after any site, women 2.0 Any site after any site, all 2.2

Sources: refracture at one year, Lindsay et al. 2001, JAMA, 381 patients who fractured out of 2,725 on placebo;4 relative risks, Klotzbuecher et al. 2000, JBMR, statistical synthesis of the literature: 2.0 (CI 1.8 to 2.1) in peri- and postmenopausal women, 2.2 (1.9 to 2.6) in the other studies.5

What is at stake beyond the next vertebra

Vertebral fracture is not only a predictor of fracture. It is a marker of global frailty. The prospective Dubbo cohort, published in JAMA, followed women and men aged 60 and over for nearly twenty years: the standardised mortality rate after a clinical vertebral fracture is 1.82 in women (CI 1.52 to 2.17) and 2.12 in men (1.66 to 2.72), with an excess mortality that persists five years after the event.6

This figure must be read with the caution appropriate to an association: vertebral fracture does not directly kill in most cases. It occurs in people who are more frail, more undernourished, with more comorbidities, and it then aggravates what made it likely, through pain, immobilisation, loss of function, kyphosis, reduction of abdominal and thoracic volume. The chain is plausible and documented in its links, but overall causality is not demonstrated by this type of study, and the article will not claim that it is.

What this figure does not say

A standardised mortality rate of 1.82 means that people who have had a clinical vertebral fracture die 1.82 times more than the general population of the same age and sex.6 It does not mean that the fracture causes these extra deaths, nor that preventing the fracture would avoid them. It is a signal of severity, to be treated as such: a patient who has just had a vertebral fracture deserves to have their overall condition looked at, not just their back.

Red flags: recognising the next fracture

A refracture does not present like the first: the patient is already known, already followed, and their back pain no longer surprises anyone. These are the signals that must reopen the file, in the middle of a course of care that was going well.

  • A new pain at a different level in a patient whose first fracture was improving. One patient in five refractures within the year.4
  • A sudden resumption of pain after a phase of improvement, even without a new reported event: the mechanism of the first fracture was already minimal, that of the second may be even more so.
  • An additional height loss between two measurements a few months apart, or a kyphosis that is visibly increasing.12
  • A pain that does not decrease over the weeks but increases: this is the profile of progressive collapse and pseudarthrosis, not of a fracture that is consolidating.33
  • A patient still without anti-osteoporotic treatment although they have already fractured. This is not a clinical sign, it is an organisational flag, and it conditions everything else.735

⚠️ In the face of one of these signals, forceful techniques and loading are suspended, and the patient is referred for imaging before resuming the programme where it had left off.

Key points

  • 19.2% vertebral refracture within the year following an incident vertebral fracture: the figure to remember and to be able to source.4
  • Vertebral fracture is the best predictor of vertebral fracture: about four times the risk, increasing with the number of levels affected.5
  • It marks a global frailty (standardised mortality 1.82 in women, 2.12 in men), without causality being established.6

What can the physiotherapist do against the fracture cascade?

Three things, and none of them consists in treating the bone. Spotting that osteoporosis is untreated, reducing falls, and giving the patient back a spine that holds up. The first two are the least spectacular and the best demonstrated.

First: check that someone is treating the bone

It is the simplest and most cost-effective contribution. It requires no new skill: it requires asking a question. After your fracture, have you had a densitometry? Are you taking any treatment for your bones?

The probability that the answer is no is high. In the Irish cohort already cited, only 24% of patients hospitalised for hip fracture left with anti-osteoporotic treatment, with no difference between those who had a vertebral fracture on CT and those who did not.2 And the French recommendations of the French Society of Rheumatology and the GRIO are explicit: in women with a severe fracture (a category that includes vertebral fracture), drug treatment is recommended, all available molecules being usable.35

What this detection produces is not hypothetical. Post-fracture care pathways, or fracture liaison services, have been the subject of a systematic review with meta-analysis covering 37 studies, 34 of them at low risk of bias: the risk of secondary fragility fracture is reduced, relative risk 0.68 (CI 0.55 to 0.83) beyond two years, with moderate certainty of evidence according to GRADE.7 A reduction of one third in the risk of refracture, obtained through organisation and not through a technical procedure.

The physiotherapist does not prescribe a bisphosphonate. But they are often the only caregiver to see this patient twenty times in three months, and the only one in a position to notice that no one has prescribed anything.

Second: reduce falls

This is the domain where the evidence is the strongest in this whole article, and it does not specifically concern vertebral fracture. The Cochrane review by Sherrington, in its abridged version published in the British Journal of Sports Medicine, establishes, on 59 studies and 12,981 participants, that exercise reduces the rate of falls by 23% (rate ratio 0.77; CI 0.71 to 0.83), with high certainty (this mention is rare and deserves to be emphasised).30

The detail of the modalities matters as much as the overall result:

  • Balance and functional exercises: 24% reduction in the rate of falls (0.76; 0.70 to 0.81), high certainty, across 39 studies.30
  • Combined programmes, most often balance and functional plus strengthening: 34% reduction (0.66; 0.50 to 0.88), moderate certainty.30
  • Tai chi: 19% reduction (0.81; 0.67 to 0.99), low certainty.30
  • Programmes focused on strengthening alone, dance or walking: the authors declare themselves uncertain.

And a piece of data directly useful to the profession: the subgroup analysis shows a greater effect in trials where the intervention was delivered by a health professional, most often a physiotherapist.30

The logic of this argument must be named, because it is indirect. The evidence concerns falls, not vertebral fractures, and a significant share of vertebral fractures occur without a fall. Reducing falls by 23% therefore does not reduce vertebral fractures by 23%. But in a patient who has already fractured, falls prevention protects the hip, wrist and pelvis, whose risk is also doubled.5 It is a real benefit, on neighbouring targets, and it is better to present it as such than to over-interpret it.

Third: maintain the spinal extensors

This is the most specific lead, and the most fragile in evidence. It rests on a prospective study by Sinaki conducted at the Mayo Clinic: 50 postmenopausal women followed for ten years after a two-year randomised trial, 27 of whom had carried out progressive resistive strengthening of the spinal extensors. At ten years, the incidence of vertebral fracture was 1.6% of the vertebral bodies examined in the exercise group versus 4.3% in controls, a relative risk of 2.7 against the controls (p = 0.029). Extensor strength remained significantly higher eight years after the programme stopped.27

It is an encouraging result and it must be given its exact weight: fifty women, a single team, an endpoint measured per vertebral body and not per patient, and observational follow-up after the randomised phase. It is not the demonstration that strengthening prevents fractures; it is the best signal available in favour of this hypothesis, and it has never been replicated on a large scale.

What each lever reduces, and with what certainty

Three levers accessible to the physiotherapist, three different targets. None directly reduces vertebral fractures.

Three levers against the fracture cascade and their level of evidence The post-fracture pathway reduces secondary fractures by 32 per cent with moderate certainty. Exercise reduces the rate of falls by 23 per cent with high certainty. Extensor strengthening showed a relative risk of 2.7 against the controls in a single study of fifty women. Falls prevention through exercise Rate of falls reduced by 23 per cent, 59 trials, 12,981 participants Target: the fall, hence the hip and the wrist, not directly the vertebra high certainty of evidence Referral to a post-fracture pathway Secondary fractures reduced by a third, relative risk 0.68 beyond 2 years Target: all fragility fractures, vertebra included moderate certainty of evidence Strengthening of the spinal extensors 1.6 versus 4.3 per cent of vertebral bodies fractured at 10 years Target: the vertebra, but a single study, 50 women, never replicated low certainty of evidence

Sources: falls, Sherrington et al. 2020, abridged Cochrane review;30 post-fracture pathway, Danazumi et al. 2024, 37 studies, authors' GRADE assessment;7 extensors, Sinaki et al. 2002, 10-year follow-up of 50 women.27 The certainty ratings reproduce those of the authors for the first two rows; the third is an editorial judgement, no GRADE assessment having been published on this study.

What the physiotherapist does not do

The physiotherapist does not set the indication for an anti-osteoporotic treatment, does not interrupt it, and does not comment on it in terms of the choice of molecule. The role described here is a role of detection and transmission: noting the absence of a work-up or treatment, writing it in a letter, and continuing one's own work. A patient sent back to their doctor with a precise, dated observation obtains more than a patient to whom the pharmacology of bone is explained.

Key points

  • The question “is your osteoporosis treated?” is probably the most effective act of the session: three quarters of fractured patients have no treatment.2
  • The prevention of falls is the only domain here where the certainty of evidence is high: 23% fewer falls.30
  • The strengthening of the extensors has the best specific signal, but in fifty women and without replication.27

What are vertebroplasty and kyphoplasty really worth?

This is the subject on which it is most tempting to give a verdict, and the one on which giving a verdict would be dishonest. Twenty years of trials have produced results that contradict one another, and the way they contradict one another is instructive.

The principle is simple: injecting acrylic cement into the fractured vertebral body to stabilise it and relieve pain. Kyphoplasty adds a balloon inflated before the injection, supposed to restore part of the lost height. Both techniques are widely practised. Their evidence base is one of the most disputed in musculoskeletal medicine.

The story in five trials

2010: VERTOS II. Dutch and Belgian open-label trial, 202 patients randomised, fractures less than six weeks old with oedema on MRI and pain of at least 5 out of 10. Vertebroplasty clearly outperforms conservative treatment: difference of 2.6 points on the visual analogue scale at one month and 2.0 at one year, with no serious complication.18

But the trial contains a piece of data that its conclusions do not put forward and that deserves to be read: of the 431 eligible patients identified, 229, or 53%, saw their pain resolve spontaneously during the assessment phase, before randomisation.18 More than one patient in two got better on their own, within a few days. No open trial can distinguish the effect of the cement from this natural course plus waiting.

2016: VAPOUR. Australian double-blind trial against a placebo procedure, 120 patients, restricted to fractures less than six weeks old with pain of at least 7 out of 10 and an optimised vertebral filling technique. Positive result: 44% of treated patients versus 21% of controls had pain below 4 out of 10 at fourteen days (difference 23 percentage points, CI 6 to 39; p = 0.011).16

2018: VERTOS IV. Dutch double-blind trial against a sham procedure, 180 patients, acute fractures. Negative result: no statistically significant difference over twelve months of follow-up, neither in pain, nor in quality of life, nor in disability, nor in analgesic consumption, both groups improving significantly.17

2018: The Cochrane review. Twenty-one trials, five of them against placebo. Verdict: evidence of high to moderate quality that there is no important benefit on pain, disability, quality of life or therapeutic success. Mean pain was 5 out of 10 under placebo and improved by 0.7 points with vertebroplasty, for a minimal clinically important difference set at 15%. The authors specify that subgroup analyses show no different effect according to the duration of the pain, acute or subacute, and that open trials comparing with usual care have probably overestimated the benefit.15

2023: VERTOS V. Change of terrain: this time the fractures are chronic, pain of more than three months with persistent oedema on MRI, and the comparator is not a placebo but an anaesthetic infiltration. 80 patients. Positive but modest result: difference of 1.3 points on the visual analogue scale at twelve months (CI 0.1 to 2.6), a significant difference also on quality of life, but not on disability.19

Twenty years of vertebroplasty trials

The result depends closely on the comparator and the population included. This is what makes the synthesis difficult, and the debate legitimate.

Results of the main vertebroplasty trials according to the comparator VERTOS II, open-label against conservative treatment, is positive. VAPOUR, double-blind against placebo, limited to very painful fractures of less than six weeks, is positive. VERTOS IV, double-blind against a sham procedure, is negative. The 2018 Cochrane review concludes there is no important benefit. VERTOS V on chronic fractures against anaesthetic infiltration is weakly positive. TRIAL AND YEAR COMPARATOR POPULATION VERDICT VERTOS II, 2010 n = 202 Conservative treatment, open-label trial Less than 6 weeks, oedema on MRI positive VAPOUR, 2016 n = 120 Placebo, double-blind optimised filling Less than 6 weeks, pain 7 out of 10 or more positive VERTOS IV, 2018 n = 180 Sham procedure, double-blind Acute painful fractures negative Cochrane, 2018 21 trials Placebo for the main comparison Acute and subacute, no subgroup effect no benefit VERTOS V, 2023 n = 80 Anaesthetic infiltration and not a placebo Pain of more than 3 months, persistent oedema weakly positive

Sources: Klazen 201018, Clark 201616, Firanescu 201817, Buchbinder 201815, Carli 202319. The “positive” and “negative” labels summarise the primary endpoint of each trial as published by its authors.

How to read this contradiction

Two readings clash, and neither is absurd.

The first: vertebroplasty does not work, the positive trials are positive for methodological reasons. This is the position of the Cochrane review. VERTOS II is open-label, hence inflated by waiting; VAPOUR is small, single-centre in its main recruitment, and its endpoint is a dichotomised threshold rather than a mean. Against placebo, across five trials, pain does not move in a clinically important way.15

The second: vertebroplasty works, but for a population that the negative trials diluted. This is the reading of the VAPOUR authors: fractures of less than six weeks in very painful patients, treated with sufficient filling, would be the target, and the negative trials would have included too many old or barely painful fractures, in whom spontaneous evolution erases the difference.16 To which the Cochrane review replies that its subgroup analyses according to the duration of pain do not find this differential effect.15

A third element has recently been added, and it concerns the survival argument. Several observational studies had reported lower mortality after kyphoplasty. An analysis of 235,317 Medicare beneficiaries took up the question with increasingly rigorous matching: the apparent advantage (hazard ratio 0.84) disappears then reverses when matching on medical complications and on age and comorbidities: hazard ratio 1.32 then 1.81 against kyphoplasty.20 The “survival gain” was an artefact of indication: the least ill patients were being operated on.

What the physiotherapist can say to a patient who asks

That an operation exists, that it consists of injecting cement, that it is sometimes useful in a specific situation (a recent, very painful fracture resistant to analgesics), and that the literature is divided on its benefit in the other cases. That the decision belongs to the doctor, and that the patient has the right to ask why it is being proposed to them in particular. What must not be said: neither “it's no use”, nor “it has to be done”.

Key points

  • Against placebo, the 2018 Cochrane review finds no clinically important benefit, with evidence of high to moderate quality.15
  • The VAPOUR trial, positive, concerns a very restricted population: less than six weeks, pain of at least 7 out of 10.16
  • More than one eligible patient in two in VERTOS II improved spontaneously even before randomisation.18
  • The argument of a survival gain from kyphoplasty does not withstand rigorous matching.20

And is kyphoplasty any better?

The direct comparison exists. A meta-analysis of sixteen studies compared balloon kyphoplasty and percutaneous vertebroplasty: kyphoplasty reduces the wedging angle (standardised mean difference 0.98; CI 0.40 to 1.57), restores more vertebral height and reduces the risk of cement leakage (relative risk 0.62; 0.47 to 0.80). But these radiographic gains do not translate clinically: no significant difference on the visual analogue pain scale or on the Oswestry Disability Index.21

This is a textbook case of the gap between an intermediate endpoint and the endpoint that counts. The vertebra is straighter, cement leakage is less frequent, and the patient has neither less pain nor fewer difficulties. For the physiotherapist, the practical consequence is simple: the technique used upstream does not change the rehabilitation they then conduct.

Should a brace be prescribed after a vertebral fracture?

The spinal brace is one of the most intuitive and least demonstrated measures of this management. It is prescribed very widely; the literature that supports it would fit in a pocket.

The systematic review by Newman, Minns Lowe and Barker gathered twelve studies (eight randomised or randomised pilot trials, four non-randomised studies) totalling 626 participants. Its result deserves to be quoted as it stands: only three studies, involving 153 people, evaluated bracing after acute vertebral fracture, and none was of high quality. There are not enough data to say that bracing modifies vertebral deformity, and it is with rigid braces that complications were most numerous.22

The review does, however, find more favourable signals in the subacute phase and in prolonged rehabilitation, across nine studies and 473 participants: three of them suggest that a semi-rigid thoracolumbar brace of the backpack type can improve strength, pain, posture and quality of life; one study finds a balance benefit with a weighted kyphosis-correcting brace. The authors conclude that these leads “should be explored in studies of sufficient size and quality, including men”.22

The useful question is not “is a brace needed”, it is “what is this one for, for how long, and what will replace its effect once it is removed”.

This formulation is the one that makes the debate operational. A brace worn for a few weeks to allow a patient to get upright and walk during the most painful phase does a job that nothing else does. A brace worn for six months “to hold the back” creates dependence and deprives the extensors of the stimulus they need, at the very moment when the literature suggests their strength matters.27

What the Newman review establishes according to the phase. The evidence columns reproduce the authors' conclusions, without hardening them.
PhaseWhat was studiedWhat can be concludedReasonable management
Acute fracture 3 studies, 153 participants, none of high quality. Inconclusive. No data showing an effect on the deformity. Maximum complications with rigid braces. If a brace, the lightest one that allows getting upright, for a duration announced from the outset and short.
Subacute phase and prolonged rehabilitation 9 studies, 473 participants, variable quality. Favourable signal for the semi-rigid backpack-type thoracolumbar brace on strength, pain, posture, quality of life (3 studies). Can be considered as a complement to an active programme, never in its place.
Balance and established kyphosis 1 study on the weighted kyphosis-correcting brace. Improvement in balance reported, in a single study. A lead, not a recommendation. To be reassessed when trials of sufficient size are published.

Key points

  • After an acute fracture, the evidence is inconclusive and rigid braces concentrate the complications.22
  • The least bad signal concerns the semi-rigid backpack-type brace in the secondary phase, on three studies.22
  • Every brace must have a duration announced from the prescription and an active programme that takes over.

Which rehabilitation, and what does the evidence say for each modality?

We must start with the bad news, because it is structuring: physiotherapy after vertebral fracture has not demonstrated much. The evidence has grown since, without becoming solid. Knowing this changes the way it is conducted, not the decision to conduct it.

What the Cochrane review says

The 2019 update of the Cochrane review, by Gibbs and Giangregorio, gathered nine trials and 749 participants, 68 of them men. Its conclusions, in order:23

  • Incident fractures: a single trial, no difference, very low quality evidence (relative risk 0.54; CI 0.17 to 1.71).23
  • Falls: a single trial, no difference, very low quality evidence (1.06; 0.53 to 2.10).23
  • Physical performance: this is the only result of moderate quality. The Timed Up and Go improves by 1.13 seconds (0.42 to 1.85), and the authors themselves write that a one-second gain is not a clinically important improvement.23
  • Pain, self-reported function, quality of life: uncertainty, very low quality evidence, differences not clinically important.
  • Adverse effects: three trials report four events related to exercise: a costal cartilage fracture, a rib fracture, knee pain, skin irritation under adhesive.23

The authors conclude that a high-quality trial remains necessary, and give the required sample size calculation: about 2,500 untreated participants, or 4,400 on anti-osteoporotic treatment.23 No trial of this size has been conducted since.

PROVE, the largest trial in the field

The PROVE trial, conducted in Oxford, is the largest ever carried out in physiotherapy for vertebral fracture: 615 adults with back pain, osteoporosis and at least one vertebral fracture, randomised into three arms: seven individual manual therapy sessions over twelve weeks, seven home exercise sessions, or a single education session.24

At twelve months, on the two primary endpoints (quality of life measured by the QUALEFFO-41 and extensor endurance measured by the timed loaded standing), no statistically significant difference between the three groups. The endurance gain was 9.8 seconds in the exercise arm, 13.6 seconds in the manual therapy arm and 4.2 seconds in the single-session arm, with confidence intervals that cross zero for exercise.24

Two secondary results deserve attention. At four months, significant differences existed: endurance and balance in the manual therapy arm; endurance in those under 70, balance, mobility and walking in the exercise arm. And the authors write in black and white: “adherence was a problem”, and “the benefits at four months did not persist”, while concluding that “short-term benefits are probably valuable”.24

At the other end of the size spectrum, the Bennell pilot trial, conducted in Melbourne on twenty participants, is clearly positive: compared with a no-treatment group, ten weeks of individual physiotherapy and daily exercises reduce pain on movement by 1.8 points (CI 0.1 to 3.5) and at rest by 2.0 points, improve QUALEFFO function by 4.8 points and endurance measured by the timed loaded standing by 46.7 seconds (16.1 to 77.3). Nine participants out of eleven in the treated group rated their pain “much better” versus one out of nine in the controls.25

Twenty patients, a no-intervention comparator, no possibility of blinding on the experience of pain: this pilot does not demonstrate, it suggests. But the juxtaposition with PROVE is illuminating. Bennell compares physiotherapy to nothing; PROVE compares seven sessions to an education session. This is not the same question, and the fact that PROVE is negative means that seven sessions do no better than one well-done session, not that physiotherapy is useless.

PROVE does not say that rehabilitation is useless. It says that a well-conducted education session does almost as well as seven sessions, which is information about dosage, not about principle.

The table of modalities

Moderate

Exercise for falls prevention. Reduction of the rate of falls by 23% in the general older population, high certainty in the Cochrane review, downgraded here to moderate because the population studied is not that of people with vertebral fracture and because the target is the fall, not the vertebral fracture.30

Moderate

Improvement in physical performance. The Timed Up and Go improves by 1.13 seconds, the only result of moderate quality in the 2019 Cochrane review, and judged by its authors to be not clinically important.23

Low

Strengthening of the spinal extensors to reduce fractures. One study, 50 women, 1.6% versus 4.3% of vertebral bodies fractured at ten years, relative risk 2.7. Never replicated.27

Low

Manual therapy and exercise for short-term pain and function. Real benefits at four months in PROVE, which do not persist at twelve months; positive Bennell pilot but on twenty patients and without an active comparator.2425 More recent syntheses strengthen the evidence without making it solid, and diverge on quality of life: a small benefit of exercise on pain, of low certainty, with no demonstrated gain in quality of life or activity, in a review of twenty trials of non-surgical and non-drug management (Bolton 2022);36 benefits on functional capacity, balance, trunk strength, pain and quality of life in a meta-analysis of nineteen exercise studies published in 2026, but without grading of certainty, including two quasi-experimental studies and a pilot, and with high heterogeneity on pain (I² of 72%).37

Low

Avoiding loaded spinal flexion in the recent phase. A single comparative study, very small numbers, but a massive result consistent with biomechanics, never contradicted since 1984.26

Very low

Semi-rigid thoracolumbar brace in the secondary phase. Three studies out of twelve in the Newman review suggest a benefit on strength, pain, posture and quality of life; variable methodological quality, men almost absent.22

Very low

Exercise to reduce fractures or falls in people with vertebral fracture. A single trial for each outcome, no difference, very low quality evidence according to the Cochrane review itself.23

Not demonstrated

Rigid brace after acute fracture. Three studies, 153 participants, none of high quality, no demonstrated effect on the deformity, and the highest complication rate of the review.22

The levels in this table are an editorial judgement applying GRADE principles, and not a published GRADE assessment. Two rows reproduce certainty judgements formulated by the authors of the cited reviews (exercise and falls; physical performance), and the short-term pain row is consistent with the Bolton 2022 judgement (low certainty); the others are derived from the number of studies, their size, their risk of bias and the consistency of the results. Apart from these ratings of isolated outcomes, no GRADE assessment covers the whole of rehabilitation of osteoporotic vertebral fracture.

Key points

  • The 2019 Cochrane review concludes there is insufficient evidence on fractures, falls and adverse effects in people with vertebral fracture.23
  • PROVE is negative at twelve months but positive at four months: on endurance, balance, mobility and walking.24
  • The comparator changes everything: seven sessions versus one education session is not physiotherapy versus nothing.

Should spinal flexion really be banned?

This is the most frequently asked question and the worst handled. The answer comes in two parts that seem to contradict each other and do not: loaded flexion is to be avoided in the recent phase, and generic lifelong prohibitions are counterproductive.

Where the rule comes from

From a single study, published in 1984 in the Archives of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation. Sinaki and Mikkelsen followed 59 women with postmenopausal spinal osteoporosis and back pain, divided into four exercise programmes. After one to six years of follow-up with radiographs before and after, the new fractures or wedgings were distributed as follows:26

New fractures according to the type of exercise prescribed

The founding 1984 study: massive result, tiny numbers. Both deserve to be read together.

New vertebral fractures according to the exercise programme, Sinaki 1984 study Extension alone 16 per cent of 25 patients; extension and flexion combined 53 per cent of 19 patients; no exercise 67 per cent of 6 patients; flexion alone 89 per cent of 9 patients. 0% 25% 50% 75% 100% proportion of patients who developed a new fracture or wedging Extension alone 25 patients 16% Extension and flexion 19 patients 53% No exercise 6 patients 67% Flexion alone 9 patients 89%

Source: Sinaki and Mikkelsen 1984, Archives of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation; 59 postmenopausal osteoporotic women with back pain, follow-up of one to six years, radiographs before and after. Significant difference in favour of extension versus flexion (p < 0.001) and versus the combined programme (p < 0.01). The numbers per group range from 6 to 25 patients: the 89% in the flexion group represents eight patients out of nine.26

This graph must be looked at with both eyes. On one side, the gap is spectacular and the statistical significance is there: 16% versus 89%, p < 0.001.26 On the other, the flexion group comprised nine patients. A study of nine people does not normally establish anything. It nevertheless underpins a rule taught throughout the world for forty years, for three reasons: the effect is very large, it is consistent with the mechanics of the vertebral body (flexion transfers the load onto the anterior column, precisely where wedge compression occurs), and above all no study has ever contradicted it, for the obvious reason that no ethics committee would today authorise randomising osteoporotic patients to a flexion programme.

This is a case where the strongest evidence we will ever have is weak evidence, and where waiting for more would be unreasonable. The practical conclusion is therefore: in the recent phase, loaded spinal flexion is not taught, and is not used as an exercise. This does not mean the patient is immobilised in extension.

Where the rule becomes harmful

The international consensus Too Fit To Fracture, arising from a two-round Delphi process bringing together researchers and clinicians, is explicit on this point. Its key conclusions:28

  • the physical activity recommendations for the general population are suitable for people with osteoporosis without vertebral fracture, but not for those who have one;
  • after a vertebral fracture, moderate intensity is preferred to vigorous intensity;
  • daily balance training and spinal extensor endurance are recommended for everyone;
  • and above all: one must teach spine-sparing techniques (the hip hinge, i.e. hinging at the hip, is the example given by the authors) rather than delivering generic restrictions such as “do not carry anything over five kilos” or “never twist”;
  • with one important reservation: in patients with vertebral fracture, a fortiori in the presence of pain, multiple fractures or hyperkyphosis, the risks of many activities may exceed the benefits, and physiotherapy advice is then recommended.

The central argument of the consensus is that a list of prohibitions produces a patient who no longer moves, and that a patient who no longer moves loses strength, balance and bone mass, that is, the three things that were protecting them. The right answer is not to ban flexion: it is to learn to pick up an object by bending the hips and knees rather than the spine, and to repeat it until it becomes the default movement.

A prohibition protects today's vertebra. A technique protects all the vertebrae of the next ten years, because the patient takes it with them.

And what about high-intensity exercise?

The question has arisen since the LIFTMOR trial, conducted in Australia in 101 postmenopausal women with low bone mass (T-score below −1.0), randomised between eight months of high-intensity resistance and impact training (five sets of five repetitions at more than 85% of the maximum, twice a week for thirty minutes, supervised) and a low-intensity home programme. The results are clearly in favour of high intensity: lumbar spine bone mineral density +2.9% versus −1.2%, femoral neck +0.3% versus −1.9%, cortical thickness, height, and all functional tests. Only one adverse event was reported.29

This trial has been widely circulated as proof that “you can lift heavy even with osteoporosis”. It has to be read for what it is. LIFTMOR included women with low bone mass, selected and screened for conditions and treatments interfering with bone and physical function; it was not a population of people with recent vertebral fracture. The training was supervised in the gym by professionals, not prescribed for independent practice. Nothing in this trial allows heavy loading of a vertebra that still has marrow oedema on MRI.

What LIFTMOR does establish, however, is worth retaining: in a well-supervised osteopenic and osteoporotic population, high intensity did not produce the wave of fractures that traditional caution led people to fear. This shifts the cursor of what is reasonable, not the management in the acute phase.

The rule of conduct in one line per phase

  • Recent fracture, oedema on MRI or uncertain dating: no loaded flexion, no manipulation, no posteroanterior pressure on the spinous processes, no added axial load. Getting upright, walking, breathing, gentle isometrics of the extensors in the pain-free range.
  • Consolidation phase: progressive resumption of extensor endurance, daily balance work, systematic teaching of the hip hinge for the movements of daily life.
  • Maintenance phase, old painless fracture: general recommendations adapted to the individual, moderate intensity preferred, progressive strengthening, and above all the end of the prohibitions that no longer serve any purpose.28

Key points

  • The “no loaded flexion” rule rests on a 1984 study with tiny numbers, never contradicted and not replicable for ethical reasons.26
  • The international consensus asks for spine-sparing techniques, not generic restrictions.28
  • LIFTMOR does not concern recent fractures: it shifts what is believed possible in the maintenance phase, not the management in the acute phase.29

What do published clinical cases teach us?

Four observations, chosen because they show the four trajectories this diagnosis can take: the one that goes well, the one discovered too late, the one that turns around, and the one that begins as ordinary low back pain.

Case 1: The ordinary trajectory, and it is a good one

Papa 2012, Journal of the Canadian Chiropractic Association 56(1):29-39: PMID 22457539

A 74-year-old man consults for acute pain in the thoracolumbar region that occurred after lifting an object. The X-ray shows generalised demineralisation and a moderate wedge fracture of L1.

Management is entirely conservative: postural education, adaptation of activities, interferential currents, taping in extension, instrument-assisted soft tissue technique, and prescription of rehabilitation exercises. The follow-up criteria are a verbal pain scale, medication consumption and return to activities of daily living. Lasting resolution of symptoms, with no painful recurrence at the twelve-month check.

What this case teaches. The most frequent scenario is this one: a moderate-grade fracture in an independent patient, which progresses well without invasive intervention. It is the reminder that is often missing when one has only complications in mind. What this case does not teach: it is a single observation, without a comparator, and the improvement at twelve months is also what natural history does; VERTOS II showed that more than one eligible patient in two improved spontaneously within a few days.1831

Case 2: The one that went unseen for two years

Massoud and Alashkar 2026, Cureus 18(3):e104527: PMID 41783551

A 78-year-old woman presents after a fall. The work-up finds an acute vertebral fracture, and, alongside it, a chronic vertebral fracture and a chronic diaphragmatic hernia that had gone unnoticed for more than two years.

The authors draw from their observation a conclusion that also holds for the physiotherapy clinic: falls are frequent in older people, the prevalence of osteoporosis is high there, and the resulting lesions can be subtle and overlooked by the patient as well as by the doctor. Discovering them makes it possible not only to treat them early, but to put in place appropriate preventive measures.

What this case teaches. It is the clinical illustration of Schousboe's figure.1 Two years of unnamed fracture in a patient who certainly crossed paths with caregivers during that period. The physiotherapist who sees an older patient for back pain is, statistically, seeing this kind of situation.32

Case 3: The low back pain that becomes an emergency, Kümmell's disease

Kuppan et al. 2022, Journal of Orthopaedic Case Reports 12(10):34-38: PMID 36874888

A 65-year-old woman consults for low back pain evolving for four weeks. Then progressive weakness and bladder and sphincter disturbances appear. The X-rays show a compression fracture of T12 with an intravertebral vacuum sign. MRI finds intravertebral fluid and significant spinal cord compression. Posterior decompression, stabilisation and transpedicular graft; histology confirms Kümmell's disease. The patient recovers her strength, bladder control and independent walking.

The authors recall the mechanism: Kümmell's disease is an osteoporotic vertebral fracture progressing towards avascular necrosis of the vertebral body, with an initially asymptomatic period then progressive pain, kyphosis and neurological deficit after trivial trauma. They emphasise that osteoporotic fractures are more exposed to pseudarthrosis because of poor vascular and mechanical support.

What this case teaches. Spinal pain that worsens over the weeks in an osteoporotic patient is not a fracture that is consolidating poorly: it is a signal. The physiotherapist is the professional best placed to spot this reversal of trajectory, because they are the one who sees the patient again.33

Case 4: Late collapse in the very old

Picazo et al. 2014, European Spine Journal 23(12):2696-2702: PMID 23778750

The authors report the case of an older man with an osteoporotic fracture progressing towards a severe late collapse with neurological involvement. Treatment consisted of bilateral posterior transpedicular decompression and instrumented arthrodesis with cemented pedicle screws; the course was uncomplicated and the patient recovered his deficit and his walking capacity.

The text frames it in a sentence that can be taken up as it stands: vertebral fracture is common in people with osteoporosis and does not cause clinical problems in the majority of cases; only a small number of patients suffer serious neurological complications related to late collapse.

What this case teaches. The proportion matters as much as the event. The aim is not to make every compression fracture a neurological threat (that would be false and anxiety-provoking) but to know that the complication exists, that it is late, and that its first signs pass through the physiotherapy appointment before passing through the emergency department.34

Why these four

These are real published observations, with their PubMed identifier, and not reconstructed vignettes. They have the drawback of their kind: a clinical case demonstrates nothing, it illustrates. Three of them describe situations that went badly, which is the natural bias of case publication (what surprises is published). Case 1 is there to restore the proportion: the most frequent trajectory is the one that goes well.

Key points

  • Most compression fractures progress favourably without invasive intervention.3134
  • The warning sign is not the intensity of the pain, it is its trajectory: a pain that increases over the weeks changes its meaning.33
  • A missed fracture can remain so for years, in a patient who has nevertheless seen caregivers.32

How to apply this concretely in practice?

Everything above comes down to four decisions: thinking of the fracture, knowing when to stop, knowing what to do next, and not letting a patient leave whose bone is being treated by no one.

The first appointment of an older patient with back pain

Nothing spectacular is asked. Three minutes added to the history and two measurements are enough to change the probability.

  1. Date the onset. Pain that started on a specific day, in a person over 65, does not have the same status as pain that has dragged on for ten years. “It started when I carried the shopping, three weeks ago” is information.
  2. Look for corticosteroids. This is the most informative red flag in primary care, and the patient almost never mentions it spontaneously because they do not make the connection.89
  3. Count the items of Roman's cluster. Age, no leg pain, BMI, sedentary lifestyle, sex. Five questions, no equipment.10
  4. Measure the wall-occiput distance, and if doubt persists the rib-pelvis distance. Thirty seconds, one wall.11
  5. Ask for the height (the one on the driving licence, the one in the health record, the one the patient states) and compare it with the measured height. A documented loss of 3 cm or more justifies investigation; its absence rules out nothing.12
  6. Percuss the spinous processes and note the exact level of a reproducible pain.

What is done, and when

A progression by phase. The durations are indicative: the benchmark that matters is the trajectory of the pain and, when it has been done, the presence or absence of bone marrow oedema on MRI.
PhaseMain objectiveWhat is doneWhat is not done
Phase 1: recent fracture or suspicion not ruled out
weeks 0 to 4 approximately
Avoid aggravating; maintain getting upright and walking; do not allow bed rest to set in. Education and explanation of the diagnosis; transfers without spinal flexion (log-roll technique); daily walking split into bouts; breathing work; gentle isometrics of the extensors in the pain-free range; adaptation of the home. Manipulation. Forceful mobilisation. Posteroanterior pressure on the spinous processes. Loaded flexion. Added axial load. Stretching into global flexion.
Phase 2: consolidation
weeks 4 to 12 approximately
Restore extensor endurance and balance; establish spine-sparing techniques. Progressive strengthening of the spinal extensors;27 daily balance training;2830 systematic teaching of the hip hinge applied to real everyday movements; gradual weaning from the brace if one has been prescribed. Going straight to heavy loading. Prolonging the brace with no end date. Settling for unloaded exercises.
Phase 3: maintenance
beyond 3 months
Reduce the risk of falls and of new fracture; make the patient independent. Programme combining balance, functional exercises and strengthening: it is the combination that reduces falls the most;30 moderate intensity preferred after vertebral fracture;28 periodic reassessment of height and posture. Maintaining generic prohibitions that no longer serve a purpose. Stopping follow-up without having checked that bone treatment is in place.

The letter that changes something

This is the least technical part and the most useful. A letter to the general practitioner containing three precise lines does more than one more session. What it must contain:

  • What was observed, dated and measured: “sudden-onset thoracic back pain on 12 March without trauma, painful percussion at the level of T11, wall-occiput distance 4 cm, reported height loss of 5 cm over 60 years”.
  • The question asked: “does a lateral X-ray of the thoracolumbar spine seem indicated to you?”
  • The point on osteoporosis: “the patient reports never having had a densitometry or any treatment for her bones.”

It is this third point that matters most in the long run. Three quarters of patients hospitalised for fragility fracture leave without bone treatment2, whereas the French recommendations provide for treating severe fractures35, and the organisation of post-fracture pathways reduces the risk of refracture by about a third.7 The physiotherapist prescribes nothing. They can point out that something is missing.

Key points

  • Six actions added to the first appointment are enough: date, look for corticosteroids, count, measure wall-occiput, compare heights, percuss.
  • The progression is set by the trajectory of the pain, not by a calendar.
  • The letter to the doctor is an act of care: it is often what triggers bone treatment.7

Frequently asked questions

How long does a vertebral compression fracture take to consolidate?

There is no published standard timeframe, and the round figures that circulate should be treated with caution. What can be said from the data: in VERTOS II, 53% of eligible patients saw their pain resolve spontaneously during the assessment phase, that is, within a few days to a few weeks.18 The useful benchmark is therefore not a duration but a direction: the pain of a recent fracture should decrease. Pain that increases over the weeks raises suspicion of pseudarthrosis or progressive collapse and requires an opinion.33

Can the spine of an osteoporotic patient be manipulated?

Not until a recent fracture has been ruled out: that is the position of caution this article supports. We must, however, be honest about the nature of this recommendation: it does not rest on comparative trials, which do not exist and never will, but on mechanics and on potential severity. The reasoning is asymmetric: the expected benefit of manipulation in this setting is modest, the cost of an error is one more vertebra.

My patient tells me their doctor has suggested vertebroplasty. What do I say about it?

That the decision rests with the doctor, and that the literature is divided. Against placebo, the 2018 Cochrane review finds no clinically important benefit;15 the VAPOUR trial, for its part, is positive, but in very specific patients: a fracture less than six weeks old and pain of at least 7 out of 10.16 The question the patient can legitimately put to their doctor is: “am I in that situation?”

Should a corset be worn?

The evidence after an acute fracture is inconclusive, and it is with rigid braces that complications are most numerous.22 When a brace is prescribed, two questions must have an answer from the first day: for how long, and what will take over. A brace that accompanies the return to an upright position for three weeks is nothing like a brace worn for six months.

My patient is afraid to move. How should I answer?

By distinguishing what is risky from what is not, rather than by giving a list of prohibitions. That is exactly the position of the Too Fit To Fracture international consensus: providing spine-sparing techniques (the hip hinge for picking things up, the log roll for getting up) rather than generic restrictions such as “do not carry anything over five kilos”.28 The patient who knows how to do it keeps moving; the patient who has been given a list stops.

Is height loss a good warning sign?

Good for confirming, poor for excluding. In 66,021 patients, a height loss of 3 cm has a specificity of 92% but a sensitivity of 19%; at 4 cm, specificity rises to 95% and sensitivity falls to 14%.12 In other words: marked height loss justifies looking further, but the absence of height loss lets the great majority of fractures through.

Are men affected?

Yes, to a degree that is often surprising. The European EPOS study measures an incidence of 5.7 per 1,000 person-years in men versus 10.7 in women: the ratio is about two to one.3 And the excess mortality after clinical vertebral fracture is higher in men (standardised rate 2.12) than in women (1.82).6 An older man with back pain must not be given less vigilance.

Can exercise cause a fracture?

The available data are reassuring without being definitive. The 2019 Cochrane review reports four adverse effects related to exercise across nine trials and 749 participants: a costal cartilage fracture, a rib fracture, knee pain, skin irritation, and rates the certainty of this information as very low.23 A 2026 meta-analysis estimates the probability of a minor adverse event during exercise at about 6.3% (pain or discomfort that does not require stopping) and that of a major event at about 1.65% (an injury or accident leading to discontinuation of the programme), with no statistically significant excess compared with control groups (usual care or daily life; 2 points more on the exercise side, p = 0.07); these percentages do not measure a risk of fracture.37 The LIFTMOR trial, with training at more than 85% of the maximum, reports only one adverse event among 101 women with low bone mass, but in a supervised setting and with no recent fracture.29

What is the place of walking in this picture?

It is essential for everything else (independence, mood, bowel transit, prevention of deconditioning) but it must not be credited with what it does not have. In the Cochrane review on falls prevention, the authors explicitly declare themselves uncertain about the effect of programmes based mainly on walking, on dancing or on strengthening alone; it is the balance and functional programmes, and the combined programmes, that carry the effect.30

Should imaging be repeated later on?

The question arises mainly if the pain does not follow the expected course, or if a new episode occurs: the risk of a new vertebral fracture in the following year is 19.2%4, which makes a new painful episode anything but trivial. It is a medical decision, but the physiotherapist is often the one who notices the change in course and who must report it.

References

Thirty-eight references, each resolved by its PubMed identifier, and whose abstract was read before citation. The figures in the text refer to the source that establishes them, at the place where they are written.

  1. Schousboe JT. Epidemiology of vertebral fractures. J Clin Densitom 2016;19(1):8-22. DOI 10.1016/j.jocd.2015.08.004: PMID 26349789
  2. Kelly MA, McCabe E, Bergin D, Kearns SR, McCabe JP, Armstrong C, Heaney F, Carey JJ. Osteoporotic vertebral fractures are common in hip fracture patients and are under-recognized. J Clin Densitom 2021;24(2):183-189. DOI 10.1016/j.jocd.2020.05.007: PMID 32546345
  3. European Prospective Osteoporosis Study (EPOS) Group; Felsenberg D, Silman AJ, Lunt M et al. Incidence of vertebral fracture in Europe: results from the European Prospective Osteoporosis Study (EPOS). J Bone Miner Res 2002;17(4):716-724. DOI 10.1359/jbmr.2002.17.4.716: PMID 11918229
  4. Lindsay R, Silverman SL, Cooper C, Hanley DA, Barton I, Broy SB, Licata A, Benhamou L, Geusens P, Flowers K, Stracke H, Seeman E. Risk of new vertebral fracture in the year following a fracture. JAMA 2001;285(3):320-323. DOI 10.1001/jama.285.3.320: PMID 11176842
  5. Klotzbuecher CM, Ross PD, Landsman PB, Abbott TA 3rd, Berger M. Patients with prior fractures have an increased risk of future fractures: a summary of the literature and statistical synthesis. J Bone Miner Res 2000;15(4):721-739. DOI 10.1359/jbmr.2000.15.4.721: PMID 10780864
  6. Bliuc D, Nguyen ND, Milch VE, Nguyen TV, Eisman JA, Center JR. Mortality risk associated with low-trauma osteoporotic fracture and subsequent fracture in men and women. JAMA 2009;301(5):513-521. DOI 10.1001/jama.2009.50: PMID 19190316
  7. Danazumi MS, Lightbody N, Dermody G. Effectiveness of fracture liaison service in reducing the risk of secondary fragility fractures in adults aged 50 and older: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Osteoporos Int 2024;35(7):1133-1151. DOI 10.1007/s00198-024-07052-1: PMID 38536447
  8. Han CS, Hancock MJ, Downie A, Jarvik JG, Koes BW, Machado GC, Verhagen AP, Williams CM, Chen Q, Maher CG. Red flags to screen for vertebral fracture in people presenting with low back pain. Cochrane Database Syst Rev 2023;8(8):CD014461. DOI 10.1002/14651858.CD014461.pub2: PMID 37615643
  9. Downie A, Williams CM, Henschke N, Hancock MJ, Ostelo RW, de Vet HC, Macaskill P, Irwig L, van Tulder MW, Koes BW, Maher CG. Red flags to screen for malignancy and fracture in patients with low back pain: systematic review. BMJ 2013;347:f7095. DOI 10.1136/bmj.f7095: PMID 24335669
  10. Roman M, Brown C, Richardson W, Isaacs R, Howes C, Cook C. The development of a clinical decision making algorithm for detection of osteoporotic vertebral compression fracture or wedge deformity. J Man Manip Ther 2010;18(1):44-49. DOI 10.1179/106698110X12595770849641: PMID 21655423
  11. Green AD, Colón-Emeric CS, Bastian L, Drake MT, Lyles KW. Does this woman have osteoporosis? JAMA 2004;292(23):2890-2900. DOI 10.1001/jama.292.23.2890: PMID 15598921
  12. Mikula AL, Hetzel SJ, Binkley N, Anderson PA. Validity of height loss as a predictor for prevalent vertebral fractures, low bone mineral density, and vitamin D deficiency. Osteoporos Int 2017;28(5):1659-1665. DOI 10.1007/s00198-017-3937-z: PMID 28154943
  13. Genant HK, Wu CY, van Kuijk C, Nevitt MC. Vertebral fracture assessment using a semiquantitative technique. J Bone Miner Res 1993;8(9):1137-1148. DOI 10.1002/jbmr.5650080915: PMID 8237484
  14. Hedderich DM, Maegerlein C, Baum T, Hapfelmeier A, Ryang YM, Zimmer C, Kirschke JS. Differentiation of acute/subacute versus old vertebral fractures in multislice detector computed tomography: is magnetic resonance imaging always needed? World Neurosurg 2019;122:e676-e683. DOI 10.1016/j.wneu.2018.10.121: PMID 30385360
  15. Buchbinder R, Johnston RV, Rischin KJ, Homik J, Jones CA, Golmohammadi K, Kallmes DF. Percutaneous vertebroplasty for osteoporotic vertebral compression fracture. Cochrane Database Syst Rev 2018;11(11):CD006349. DOI 10.1002/14651858.CD006349.pub4: PMID 30399208
  16. Clark W, Bird P, Gonski P, Diamond TH, Smerdely P, McNeil HP, Schlaphoff G, Bryant C, Barnes E, Gebski V. Safety and efficacy of vertebroplasty for acute painful osteoporotic fractures (VAPOUR): a multicentre, randomised, double-blind, placebo-controlled trial. Lancet 2016;388(10052):1408-1416. DOI 10.1016/S0140-6736(16)31341-1: PMID 27544377
  17. Firanescu CE, de Vries J, Lodder P, Venmans A, Schoemaker MC, Smeets AJ, Donga E, Juttmann JR, Klazen CAH, Elgersma OEH, Jansen FH, Tielbeek AV, Boukrab I, Schonenberg K, van Rooij WJJ, Hirsch JA, Lohle PNM. Vertebroplasty versus sham procedure for painful acute osteoporotic vertebral compression fractures (VERTOS IV): randomised sham controlled clinical trial. BMJ 2018;361:k1551. DOI 10.1136/bmj.k1551: PMID 29743284
  18. Klazen CA, Lohle PN, de Vries J, Jansen FH, Tielbeek AV, Blonk MC, Venmans A, van Rooij WJ, Schoemaker MC, Juttmann JR, Lo TH, Verhaar HJ, van der Graaf Y, van Everdingen KJ, Muller AF, Elgersma OE, Halkema DR, Fransen H, Janssens X, Buskens E, Mali WP. Vertebroplasty versus conservative treatment in acute osteoporotic vertebral compression fractures (Vertos II): an open-label randomised trial. Lancet 2010;376(9746):1085-1092. DOI 10.1016/S0140-6736(10)60954-3: PMID 20701962
  19. Carli D, Venmans A, Lodder P, Donga E, van Oudheusden T, Boukrab I, Schoemaker K, Smeets A, Schonenberg C, Hirsch J, de Vries J, Lohle P. Vertebroplasty versus active control intervention for chronic osteoporotic vertebral compression fractures: the VERTOS V randomized controlled trial. Radiology 2023;308(1):e222535. DOI 10.1148/radiol.222535: PMID 37462495
  20. Gold LS, Suri P, O'Reilly MK, Kallmes DF, Heagerty PJ, Jarvik JG. Mortality among older adults with osteoporotic vertebral fracture. Osteoporos Int 2023;34(9):1561-1575. DOI 10.1007/s00198-023-06796-6: PMID 37233794
  21. Wang B, Zhao CP, Song LX, Zhu L. Balloon kyphoplasty versus percutaneous vertebroplasty for osteoporotic vertebral compression fracture: a meta-analysis and systematic review. J Orthop Surg Res 2018;13(1):264. DOI 10.1186/s13018-018-0952-5: PMID 30348192
  22. Newman M, Minns Lowe C, Barker K. Spinal orthoses for vertebral osteoporosis and osteoporotic vertebral fracture: a systematic review. Arch Phys Med Rehabil 2016;97(6):1013-1025. DOI 10.1016/j.apmr.2015.10.108: PMID 26615791
  23. Gibbs JC, MacIntyre NJ, Ponzano M, Templeton JA, Thabane L, Papaioannou A, Giangregorio LM. Exercise for improving outcomes after osteoporotic vertebral fracture. Cochrane Database Syst Rev 2019;7(7):CD008618. DOI 10.1002/14651858.CD008618.pub3: PMID 31273764
  24. Barker KL, Newman M, Stallard N, Leal J, Lowe CM, Javaid MK, Noufaily A, Hughes T, Smith D, Gandhi V, Cooper C, Lamb SE; PROVE trial group. Physiotherapy rehabilitation for osteoporotic vertebral fracture: a randomised controlled trial and economic evaluation (PROVE trial). Osteoporos Int 2020;31(2):277-289. DOI 10.1007/s00198-019-05133-0: PMID 31720722
  25. Bennell KL, Matthews B, Greig A, Briggs A, Kelly A, Sherburn M, Larsen J, Wark J. Effects of an exercise and manual therapy program on physical impairments, function and quality-of-life in people with osteoporotic vertebral fracture: a randomised, single-blind controlled pilot trial. BMC Musculoskelet Disord 2010;11:36. DOI 10.1186/1471-2474-11-36: PMID 20163739
  26. Sinaki M, Mikkelsen BA. Postmenopausal spinal osteoporosis: flexion versus extension exercises. Arch Phys Med Rehabil 1984;65(10):593-596. PMID 6487063 (prior to the assignment of DOIs)
  27. Sinaki M, Itoi E, Wahner HW, Wollan P, Gelzcer R, Mullan BP, Collins DA, Hodgson SF. Stronger back muscles reduce the incidence of vertebral fractures: a prospective 10 year follow-up of postmenopausal women. Bone 2002;30(6):836-841. DOI 10.1016/s8756-3282(02)00739-1: PMID 12052450
  28. Giangregorio LM, McGill S, Wark JD, Laprade J, Heinonen A, Ashe MC, MacIntyre NJ, Cheung AM, Shipp K, Keller H, Jain R, Papaioannou A. Too Fit To Fracture: outcomes of a Delphi consensus process on physical activity and exercise recommendations for adults with osteoporosis with or without vertebral fractures. Osteoporos Int 2015;26(3):891-910. DOI 10.1007/s00198-014-2881-4: PMID 25510579
  29. Watson SL, Weeks BK, Weis LJ, Harding AT, Horan SA, Beck BR. High-intensity resistance and impact training improves bone mineral density and physical function in postmenopausal women with osteopenia and osteoporosis: the LIFTMOR randomized controlled trial. J Bone Miner Res 2018;33(2):211-220. DOI 10.1002/jbmr.3284: PMID 28975661
  30. Sherrington C, Fairhall N, Wallbank G, Tiedemann A, Michaleff ZA, Howard K, Clemson L, Hopewell S, Lamb S. Exercise for preventing falls in older people living in the community: an abridged Cochrane systematic review. Br J Sports Med 2020;54(15):885-891. DOI 10.1136/bjsports-2019-101512: PMID 31792067
  31. Papa JA. Conservative management of a lumbar compression fracture in an osteoporotic patient: a case report. J Can Chiropr Assoc 2012;56(1):29-39., PMID 22457539, PMC3280116
  32. Massoud NA, Alashkar AH. When minor falls are overlooked in the elderly: a case report of vertebral compression fractures and chronic diaphragmatic hernia. Cureus 2026;18(3):e104527. DOI 10.7759/cureus.104527: PMID 41783551
  33. Kuppan N, Muthu S, Parthasarathy S, Mohanen P. Strategies in the management of osteoporotic Kummell's disease. J Orthop Case Rep 2022;12(10):34-38. DOI 10.13107/jocr.2022.v12.i10.3356: PMID 36874888
  34. Picazo DR, Villaescusa JR, Martínez EP, Pérez FD. Late collapse osteoporotic vertebral fracture in an elderly patient with neurological compromise. Eur Spine J 2014;23(12):2696-2702. DOI 10.1007/s00586-013-2751-3: PMID 23778750
  35. Briot K, Roux C, Thomas T, Blain H, Buchon D, Chapurlat R, Debiais F, Feron JM, Gauvain JB, Guggenbuhl P, Legrand E, Lehr-Drylewicz AM, Lespessailles E, Tremollieres F, Weryha G, Cortet B. 2018 update of French recommendations on the management of postmenopausal osteoporosis. Joint Bone Spine 2018;85(5):519-530. DOI 10.1016/j.jbspin.2018.02.009: PMID 29654947
  36. Bolton K, Wallis JA, Taylor NF. Benefits and harms of non-surgical and non-pharmacological management of osteoporotic vertebral fractures: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Braz J Phys Ther 2022;26(1):100383. DOI 10.1016/j.bjpt.2021.100383 · PMID 35063701
  37. Fernández-González M, Mora-Traverso M, Molina-Garcia P, Prieto-Moreno R, Ortiz-Piña M, Contreras-Gutiérrez J, Ariza-Vega P. Effectiveness and safety of physical exercise and health education for the management of osteoporotic vertebral fractures: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Osteoporos Int 2026;37(8):1929-1944. DOI 10.1007/s00198-026-07994-8 · PMID 42101660
  38. Ponzano M, Tibert N, Brien S, Funnell L, Gibbs JC, Keller H, Laprade J, Morin SN, Papaioannou A, Weston Z, Wideman TH, Giangregorio LM. International consensus on the non-pharmacological and non-surgical management of osteoporotic vertebral fractures. Osteoporos Int 2023;34(6):1065-1074. DOI 10.1007/s00198-023-06688-9 · PMID 36799981

Method and limitations

Sources searched in PubMed via the NCBI E-utilities services, crossing osteoporotic vertebral fracture with epidemiology, underdiagnosis, red flags, imaging, vertebroplasty and kyphoplasty, braces, exercise, falls prevention and reported cases. Each identifier was resolved and each abstract read before citation; the four clinical cases are real published observations, cited with their identifier.

Main limitation of this article: the strongest evidence it contains does not concern the question asked. Certainty is high for exercise against falls30, high to moderate for the absence of benefit of vertebroplasty against placebo,15 but it is low or very low for almost everything that directly concerns rehabilitation after vertebral fracture, the 2019 Cochrane review stopping explicitly at a finding of insufficient evidence.23 Two central claims of practice rest on tiny studies that have never been replicated: the protective effect of extensor strengthening (50 women)27 and the danger of loaded flexion (9 patients in the group concerned)26. They are retained here because they are consistent with mechanics and because no data contradict them, not because they are demonstrated.

Second limitation: the levels in the table of modalities are an editorial judgement applying GRADE principles, and not a published GRADE assessment; apart from the ratings of isolated outcomes (Cochrane 2019, Bolton 2022), no assessment of this type covers the whole of rehabilitation of osteoporotic vertebral fracture. Finally, Roman's diagnostic cluster has never undergone the prospective validation its authors called for.10

The 2023 international consensus on the non-drug and non-surgical management of osteoporotic vertebral fracture (Delphi method) concerns pain, early satiety, weight loss, bracing, safe movement and exercise; its full text was not read, and this article draws no statement from it.38

Article written on 15 August 2026.

Behind this article

An author who explains, a reviewer who checks.

How we write and check our content

Anthony Baillon, physiotherapist and co-founder of Physio Learning
✍️ Author

Anthony Baillon

Physiotherapist · co-founder of Physio Learning

Marked for life by his first four-hour lecture without a single image, he took a master’s in instructional design so that it would never happen to anyone again. He hunts down publication bias and unreadable slides with the same intransigence.

PhysiotherapistInstructional designerCare design
Follow on LinkedIn
Robin Vervaeke, head of scientific content at Physio Learning✓ Verified

Robin Vervaeke

Head of scientific content

Physiotherapist specialising in neuro-musculoskeletal practice and holder of a master’s in public health. He checks the methodological rigour of every article: primary sources, levels of evidence, no exceptions.

Neuro-musculoskeletalMSc Public health
Follow on LinkedIn

Share