Skip to content
Sign up

Updated · published

Traumatic mallet finger: 2026 update

Mallet finger: the Doyle classification, custom against prefabricated splint (0 % failure against 23.8 %), how long to immobilise, and rehabilitation.

The essentials, in 30 seconds

The extension lag does not regress spontaneously: continuous immobilisation in extension, for six to eight weeks, is the first-line treatment.

23.8%of treatment failures with a prefabricated splint

What it is
A deformity in which the distal interphalangeal joint stays flexed and can no longer be extended actively.
What points the way
Distal interphalangeal joint actively flexed, but passively extensible: this is the signature, and the test takes two seconds.
How it is settled
The classification has four types, is read on a lateral radiograph, and separates the fingers that are splinted from those that are operated on.
What is done first
The type of orthosis does not change the final extension lag, but it changes adherence and the failure rate.
How long
Six to eight weeks of continuous wear, then two to six weeks of night-time wear or gradual weaning.

What follows covers each of these points in detail, with sources. It is there if you need it.

This topic is taught in a course: Advance your hand and wrist rehabilitation: assess and empower your patients, on-site with Tessadit Aissaoui.

Chapter by chapter

1 / 11

10 article chapters · 39 min in total

Chapter 1

Understand◔ 2 min

The signature of mallet finger: actively flexed, but passively extensible, in two seconds.

Mechanism of injury
Mallet finger results from a rupture of the terminal extensor, at its insertion or just proximal to it.
Continuity of the tendon
The tendon must heal in maintained continuity; lengthened, it does not regain the right length.
Two forms
The injury is purely tendinous or bony, with a fragment of the dorsal cortex.
Late complication
Later on, watch for the swan neck deformity through transfer of traction proximally.
Chapter 2

Who and how◔ 3 min

The dominant hand is affected in about 74% of cases, which weighs on the occupational impact.

Typical profile
Mostly affects young men (3rd-4th decade); the difference fades with age.
Fingers affected
The middle finger is the most affected, then the ring finger, little finger and index finger; the thumb is rare.
Baseball finger
The direct blow to the finger pulp (ball in basketball, volleyball) defines “baseball finger”.
Innocuous movement
The most frequent mechanism in community practice: a forced flexion during an innocuous movement (sock, sheet).
Chapter 3

Classify◔ 3 min

A palmar subluxation of the phalanx tips the decision towards surgery, whatever the size of the fragment.

Type I predominates
Type I (closed injury) represents the vast majority of cases and is a matter for the orthosis.
Types II and III
An open wound (laceration) requires surgical management of the tendon.
2 mm threshold
The gap between the fragment and its bed has a threshold of 2 mm.
Small flake
A small bony flake (less than a third of the surface) does not change the final result.
Chapter 4

Choose the orthosis◔ 5 min

The orthosis does not change the final lag, it changes the probability of completing the treatment.

Treatment failure
The custom-made thermoplastic orthosis had no failures, against 23.8% for the other two.
Skin complications
Prefabricated orthoses have 3 times more skin complications than the other orthoses.
Robustness required
Worn continuously for weeks, the orthosis must be robust enough for daily use.
Rigid immobilisation
Marked oedema and older age are unfavourable factors on the final lag.
Chapter 5

Duration of wear◔ 4 min

The reference protocol: 6 to 8 weeks of continuous extension of the distal interphalangeal joint.

Free proximal joint
The proximal interphalangeal joint remains free and is mobilised from the first day.
Night-time wear unnecessary
Adding a month of night-time orthosis after the immobilisation changes neither the lag nor satisfaction.
Residual lag
A third of patients (14 out of 41) keep a lag of 20 degrees or more.
Delay without consequence
Treatment succeeds as often when delayed (15 out of 19) as when early (17 out of 21).
Chapter 6

Surgery◔ 4 min

Setting aside a large bone fragment, surgery and non-surgical treatment gave similar results in a review of series and trials.

Compared figures
The complication rate is comparable: 14.5% after surgery against 12.8% without surgery.
Tendinous mallet finger
For tendinous mallet finger, the orthosis and Kirschner wire did not give a significantly different final result.
Large fragment
With a large fragment (20 to 50% in one, more than a third in the other), the trials are conflicting: less lag but more subluxations after pinning in the first, no difference in the second.
Secondary subluxation
Three patients in the orthosis group developed a secondary subluxation.
Chapter 7

Work and sport◔ 3 min

Surgery does not speed anything up: it lengthens the return to work by 9 days, in the only trial that measured it.

Occupational cost
The dominant hand is affected 3 times out of 4, with 6 to 8 weeks of continuous immobilisation.
Sports emergencies
Mallet finger accounts for 2% of sports emergencies, the most frequent closed tendon injury in contact sports.
Return to work
63.2 days to return to work after surgery, against 53.7 days after conservative treatment.
Return to sport
No study has evaluated the modalities of return to sport for this injury.
Chapter 8

Rehabilitate◔ 6 min

After the splint is removed, a loss of extension appears, partly recovered by active exercise.

Mobilising the proximal joint
Actively mobilise the proximal interphalangeal joint from the first day, at every session.
Oedema control
Marked oedema and older age weigh negatively on the final lag.
Custom-made orthosis
Prefer the custom-made thermoplastic orthosis: 0% failure against 23.8% for the prefabricated one.
No night-time orthosis
Do not add a night-time orthosis after the immobilisation: no demonstrated benefit.
Chapter 9

Clinical cases◔ 3 min

The published cases never describe an ordinary mallet finger, which makes them instructive.

Atypical onset
One case describes a mallet deformity without trauma, developing over more than twenty days.
Palpable nodules
Nodules were felt at the distal interphalangeal joint and on the dorsal aspect of the second phalanx.
Chapter 10

In practice◔ 6 min

For this condition, the first consultation is worth more than all the following ones.

Avoiding the trap
Without a clear trauma, with no mass and no child, investigate before splinting.
The choice that matters
The custom-made orthosis gave 0% failure, against 23.8% with the Stack or the dorsal aluminium.
Wearing instruction
The instruction: eight weeks, day and night, one flexion means starting everything again.
Referral to the surgeon
Refer to the hand surgeon for a wound, a large fracture or a subluxation.
11

Train on this

On-siteDPCFIFPL

Upper limb

Advance your hand and wrist rehabilitation: assess and empower your patients

Tessadit Aissaoui

Next comes practice: the course that teaches this topic, with Tessadit Aissaoui.

Our courses on this topic may be covered by DPC or FIFPL, the French continuing-education funding schemes, depending on your profession and situation.

Posted by

Anthony BAILLON

Physiotherapist


The tip of a finger that will no longer straighten after a trivial knock: tucking in a sheet, a ball caught badly, pulling up a sock. The injury is simple, the treatment seems trivial, and that is precisely where the result is decided: between a splint that holds for eight weeks and a splint that gives way, the gap measured in a randomised trial is 23.8 percentage points of treatment failure.

A synthesis written from primary sources verified one by one on PubMed: identifier resolved, journal, year and author list checked, abstract read before citation. Full bibliography at the end of the article.

Mallet finger in three figures

What three independent studies establish, and which shifts the question from “should we operate?” to “which splint, and worn for how long?”

Three key figures on mallet finger Residual extension lag of 5.7 degrees after surgery against 7.6 after orthosis; treatment failure of 23.8% with a prefabricated splint against 0% with a custom-made thermoplastic one; 34% of patients keep a lag of at least 20 degrees. 5.7° / 7.6° mean residual lag surgery against orthosis: a two-degree gap Lin 2018, 44 studies 23.8 / 0% treatment failure prefabricated splint against custom-made thermoplastic O'Brien 2011, randomised trial 34% keep 20° or more of extension lag at the end of treatment Gruber 2014, randomised trial

Sources: Lin JS, Samora JB. J Hand Surg Am 2018;43(2):146-163.e2 (PMID 29174096); O'Brien LJ, Bailey MJ. Arch Phys Med Rehabil 2011;92(2):191-198 (PMID 21272714); Gruber JS, Bot AG, Ring D. Hand (N Y) 2014;9(2):145-150 (PMID 24839414).

Clinical synthesis

What to take away before reading the rest

  • What it is. An interruption of the terminal extensor tendon at its insertion on the distal phalanx, with or without bone avulsion. The distal interphalangeal joint drops into flexion and can no longer be raised actively, although it raises passively without difficulty.
  • What will not happen on its own. The extension lag does not correct itself spontaneously without treatment. Inappropriate management leads to lasting functional loss and stiffness.
  • The real question is not “should we operate”. Setting aside a large bone fragment, surgery and orthotic treatment gave similar results in a review of series and trials: mean residual lag of 5.7° against 7.6°, complications 14.5% against 12.8%. The question is that of the orthosis and how it is worn.
  • The custom-made orthosis changes the result. In a multicentre randomised trial, the Stack splint and the dorsal aluminium splint each gave 23.8% treatment failure, against 0% for the custom-made thermoplastic.
  • Eight weeks of continuous wear, without a single flexion. Any flexion of the distal interphalangeal joint during immobilisation means starting the count again from zero.
  • Arriving late is not losing. Orthotic treatment started more than four weeks after the injury gave results comparable to early treatment.
  • The trap. A mallet finger without trauma is not a mallet finger: it is a sign, and one must look for what is producing it.

What is a mallet finger, and why does it not correct itself?

An injury of a few millimetres, an extensor apparatus that loses its terminal pulley, and a joint that tips over. Understanding the mechanics avoids the two most frequent errors: underestimating the duration of treatment, and overestimating the value of surgery.

The injury, in one sentence and three consequences

Mallet finger denotes a deformity of the tip of the finger in which the distal interphalangeal joint stays flexed and can no longer be extended actively. It results from a traumatic interruption of the terminal extensor mechanism, either at its insertion on the distal phalanx, or slightly more proximally, at the level of the joint2.

The sign that identifies it is also the one that distinguishes it from stiffness: the joint can be extended passively, but this extension is not maintained as soon as it is released2. This is the test to do systematically, and it takes two seconds.

Three consequences follow, and they govern everything else:

  • Healing requires maintained continuity. A ruptured tendon left in a lengthened position does not heal at the right length. That is why immobilisation in extension must be continuous, and why a single flexion during treatment “puts the injury back to zero”1.
  • The lag does not correct itself spontaneously. The reference review states it without ambiguity: the extension lag associated with this deformity does not improve without treatment, and inappropriate management leads to chronic functional loss and stiffness of the finger2.
  • The imbalance can spread proximally. As the extensor apparatus is a chain, the loss of distal traction transfers the force onto the central slip, which can tip the proximal interphalangeal joint into hyperextension: this is the swan neck deformity, a late complication whose correction is a matter for surgery2.

The splint does not “hold” the finger: it holds the two ends of the tendon close enough together, for long enough, for them to join. A single flexion is enough to undo weeks of work.

Two forms, one mechanism

The injury can be purely tendinous (the tendon tears away from its insertion) or bony, the tendon taking with it a fragment of the dorsal cortex of the distal phalanx. Both forms produce the same deformity, but they are not treated in quite the same way when the fragment is large or the joint subluxes: that is the subject of the chapter on classification.

Key points

  • Distal interphalangeal joint actively flexed, passively extensible : this is the signature, and it is tested in two seconds.
  • The lag does not regress spontaneously (withholding treatment is not a treatment option).
  • Immobilisation must be continuous : a flexion during wear restarts the count.
  • Late complication to know about: the swan neck deformity through transfer of traction proximally.

Who is injured, how, and which fingers are affected?

A sportsman's injury, as the saying goes. That is true of only some of the cases, and the most frequent mechanism in community consultations is so ordinary that it surprises the patient themselves.

The profile

The injury is mainly seen in young men, in the third and fourth decades ; after the fifth decade, the difference between the sexes disappears2. The NCBI reference chapter adds a nuance on frequency: the presentations are seen in young to middle-aged men, but also in older women1.

The dominant hand is affected in about 74% of cases2, which is not neutral for the occupational impact: eight weeks of splinting on the dominant index finger of a craftsperson is not managed in the same way as on the non-dominant little finger of an office worker.

As for the fingers affected, the order of frequency is consistent from one source to another: the middle finger first, then the ring finger, little finger and index finger ; involvement of the thumb is rare2. The NCBI chapter, for its part, mentions the little, ring and middle fingers of the dominant hand as the most frequently affected1 (the exact order varies, but it is indeed the last three rays that predominate).

Mechanisms, from the sports field to the sock

The mechanisms classically described are three in number2 :

  • The direct blow to the finger pulp, finger extended: a ball received head-on in basketball, volleyball or handball. This is the mechanism known as baseball finger.
  • Forced flexion against resistance during an innocuous movement: tucking in a sheet, pulling up a sock, putting away a suitcase. It is the most frequent in community practice, and the one that the patient minimises the most.
  • Crushing, finger caught in a door, with or without a wound.

A case published in Journal of Orthopaedic Case Reports also recalls the place of this injury in sports traumatology: according to its authors, it accounts for 2% of sports emergencies and is the most frequent closed tendon injury in contact sports and in the workplace15.

The innocuous nature of the triggering movement is a clinical datum in its own right: it explains late consultations, and it also explains why the injury occurs outside any sporting context. A case published in Anaesthesia Reports thus describes a mallet finger occurring in an anaesthetist during a tracheal intubation, treated without surgery, with a prolonged break from clinical activity before full recovery17.

Four benchmarks from the field

Data from the reference review and the NCBI chapter

Four secondary statistics on mallet finger 74% involvement of the dominant hand; men in their third and fourth decades; the last three rays mainly affected; 2% of sports emergencies. 74% dominant hand hence the occupational stake Khera 2021 30-40 years peak in men beyond age 50, no more difference between the sexes Khera 2021 3, 4, 5 most affected rays middle, ring, little; thumb rare Khera 2021 2% of sports emergencies closed tendon injury the most frequent Benabdallah 2022

Sources: Khera B, Chang C, Bhat W. Acta Biomed 2021;92(5):e2021246 (PMID 34738569); Benabdallah O, Benabdallah R. J Orthop Case Rep 2022;12(11):60-64 (PMID 37013228).

A mallet finger without trauma is not a mallet finger

It is a sign, and it makes a search for the cause necessary. Two published cases demonstrate it. A 35-year-old woman developed the deformity gradually, over more than twenty days, without any trauma, with palpable nodules at the level of the distal interphalangeal joint: it was a pigmented villonodular synovitis, a condition never previously reported in this presentation15. A 4-year-old child presented with a painless deformity that worsened progressively over a year, with a palpable bony mass proximal to the joint: an osteochondroma of the middle phalanx was pushing the terminal tendon back, and the initial radiograph was inconclusive16. Gradual onset, absence of trauma, palpable mass, paediatric age : four reasons to refer rather than to splint.

Key points

  • Young man, dominant hand in 74% of cases, mainly the last three rays.
  • Most frequent mechanism in community practice: the forced flexion against resistance during an innocuous movement, not sport.
  • The innocuous movement explains the late consultations (and the next chapter shows that this is not a catastrophe).
  • Without trauma, the deformity is a sign to be investigated, never a diagnosis.

How to classify the injury, and why does it govern treatment?

Lateral finger radiograph: mallet finger with a small dorsal bony avulsion fragment at the base of the distal phalanx, red arrow on the lesion.

X-rayLateral finger radiograph: mallet finger with a small dorsal bony avulsion fragment at the base of the distal phalanx, red arrow on the lesion.

Source : Avery et al., Journal of Orthopaedic Surgery and Research, 2016, figure 14 · CC BY

Only one classification is universally used. It has four types, it is read on a lateral radiograph, and it is what separates the fingers that are splinted from those that are operated on.

The Doyle classification

Doyle classification of mallet finger injuries, as stated by the NCBI Bookshelf reference chapter1. A revision was proposed in 2023 to reduce inter-observer variability3.
TypeInjuryUsual orientation
IClosed injury, with or without a small dorsal avulsion fractureOrthotic treatment: this is the vast majority of cases2
IIOpen injury with a clean-cut wound (laceration)Surgical management of the wound and the tendon
IIIOpen injury with deep abrasion, with loss of skin and tendon substanceSurgery, with coverage and reconstruction
IV-ATransphyseal fracture (child and adolescent)According to displacement; surgical opinion
IV-BFragment involving 20-50% of the articular surfaceCase-by-case decision, opinion of the hand surgeon (conflicting trials)
IV-CFragment involving more than 50% of the articular surfaceRisk of palmar subluxation: surgical opinion

The operative indications retained by this same chapter are explicit: subluxation of the distal interphalangeal joint, fragment involving more than a third of the articular surface, joint gap of more than 2 mm, complete rupture or division of the extensor tendon, and complex injuries1.

The four Doyle types, at a glance

What the lateral radiograph shows, and what it implies

Doyle classification of mallet finger Type I closed injury, type II wound, type III loss of substance, type IV fracture with subtypes A transphyseal, B from 20 to 50% of the articular surface and C beyond 50%. Type I Closed injury, ± small dorsal avulsion Orthosis: by far the most frequent case Type II Clean-cut wound of the tendon Surgery Type III Deep abrasion, loss of substance Surgery with coverage Type IV-A Transphyseal fracture Child and adolescent: surgical opinion Type IV-B 20 to 50% of the articular surface Case by case, opinion of the hand surgeon Type IV-C More than 50% of the surface Risk of subluxation: surgical opinion Operative indications retained, whatever the type subluxation of the distal interphalangeal joint · fragment of more than a third of the surface joint gap > 2 mm · complete rupture or division of the tendon · complex injuries

Source: Mallet Finger Injuries, StatPearls, NCBI Bookshelf NBK459373 (PMID 29083648). The original classification is due to Doyle; a modification was proposed by Sivakumar et al. to reduce inter-observer error (PMID 36509592).

What the radiograph must show

A strict lateral view of the finger, centred on the distal interphalangeal joint, is enough. Three things are looked for, in this order:

  1. Joint congruence. A palmar subluxation of the distal phalanx is the sign that tips the decision towards surgery, regardless of the size of the fragment1.
  2. Fragment size, in relation to the articular surface: this is what separates the IV-B from the IV-C.
  3. The gap between the fragment and its bed, for which the threshold retained is 2 mm1.

A useful clarification so as not to over-treat: in a retrospective comparison of early and delayed orthotic treatments, the presence or absence of a fracture of the dorsal rim involving less than a third of the articular surface did not change the final result9. A small bony flake therefore does not change management.

Key points

  • The Doyle classification has four types, of which only one, type I, represents the vast majority of cases and is a matter for the orthosis.
  • The operative thresholds are quantified: subluxation, more than a third of the surface, gap greater than 2 mm.
  • A strict lateral view is enough; it is the congruence that is looked at first, not the size of the fragment.
  • A small dorsal flake (less than a third) does not change the result of the orthotic treatment.

Which orthosis to choose, and why is it the real question?

This is a point of this condition where several randomised trials answer each other. And their message is not the one expected: the orthosis does not change the final extension lag, it changes the probability that the treatment will be carried through to the end.

What the Cochrane review established, and what it could not establish

The Cochrane review devoted to mallet finger interventions included four trials totalling 278 participants and 283 fingers. Its verdict is clear and must be quoted as it stands: the evidence from randomised trials was insufficient to establish the relative effectiveness of the different orthoses, custom-made or prefabricated, and also insufficient to determine when surgery is indicated4.

The authors nevertheless draw two practical lessons from it, and they are the ones that have aged best: an orthosis worn continuously for weeks must be robust enough for daily use, and the adherence of the patient to the wearing instructions has a central place4. One of the included trials reported a splint that was falling apart (deteriorated rubber covering, rusted metal wires) and that was, logically, less liked by the participants.

The trial that shifted the question

A multicentre, single-blind randomised controlled trial compared three orthoses in 64 patients with an acute mallet finger of type 1a or 1b: a prefabricated Stack splint (control), a padded dorsal aluminium splint, and a custom-made thermoplastic orthosis. All were worn continuously for eight weeks, followed by gradual weaning over four weeks with exercises7.

The main result is a non-result: no difference in extension lag between the three groups, at either twelve or twenty weeks. The secondary result, for its part, is spectacular: treatment failure affected 23.8% of patients in the Stack group and 23.8% in the dorsal aluminium group, against none in the custom-made thermoplastic group (p = 0.04)7. The authors also note a moderate negative correlation between adherence and extension lag: the less the patient wears the splint, the greater the lag.

Three orthoses, the same final lag, three different failure rates

Multicentre randomised controlled trial, 64 patients, acute mallet finger of type 1a-1b, 8 weeks of continuous wear

Treatment failure by type of orthosis Stack splint 23.8% failure, dorsal aluminium 23.8%, custom-made thermoplastic 0%. No difference in extension lag between the three groups. Treatment failure at 20 weeks 0%15%30% 23.8% Stack splint prefabricated (control) 23.8% Dorsal aluminium padded 0% Thermoplastic custom-made Extension lag No difference between the three groups, at either 12 or 20 weeks. It is the outcome of the treatment that differs. p = 0.04. The less the patient wears their orthosis, the greater their final extension lag.

Source: O'Brien LJ, Bailey MJ. Single blind, prospective, randomized controlled trial comparing dorsal aluminum and custom thermoplastic splints to stack splint for acute mallet finger. Arch Phys Med Rehabil 2011;92(2):191-198 (PMID 21272714).

Skin complications, quantified by meta-analysis

A systematic review with meta-analysis took seven controlled trials totalling 491 participants to compare types of orthosis on three criteria: complications, extension lag and success rate according to the Abouna and Brown criteria6.

The result is consistent with the previous one, and this time it concerns tolerance:

  • prefabricated orthoses had three times the risk of skin complication compared with all the other orthoses together (relative risk 3.17; 95% confidence interval: 1.19 to 8.43; moderate-quality evidence);
  • and almost seven times this risk compared with custom-made thermoplastic orthoses alone (relative risk 6.72; 1.59 to 28.46);
  • on the other hand, no difference in the success rate (relative risk 0.99; 0.80 to 1.22; very low-quality evidence) or in extension lag (standardised mean difference 0.03; −0.29 to 0.36; moderate-quality evidence)6.

Skin complications: prefabricated against custom-made orthosis

Meta-analysis of 7 controlled trials, 491 participants: relative risk and 95% confidence interval

Relative risk of skin complication by type of orthosis Relative risk 3.17 against all other orthoses and 6.72 against custom-made thermoplastics alone; no difference in success or in extension lag. 1251030 relative risk (logarithmic scale), to the right of 1: more complications with the prefabricated one vs all other orthoses 3.17 (1.19-8.43) vs thermoplastic custom-made 6.72 (1.59-28.46) No difference, however, in the success rate (RR 0.99) or in extension lag (SMD 0.03).

Source: Witherow EJ, Peiris CL. Custom-made finger orthoses have fewer skin complications than prefabricated finger orthoses in the management of mallet injury: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Arch Phys Med Rehabil 2015;96(10):1913-1923.e1 (PMID 26163944).

And what about non-removable immobilisation?

Two trials studied non-removable immobilisation, with convergent but nuanced results; a third compared another continuous immobilisation with a cast.

The first compared, in 57 subjects, immobilisation by a thermoformable cast (Quickcast) with a removable lever-type thermoplastic orthosis. The removable group had an extension lag greater by 5° on average at twelve weeks (p = 0.05), and two factors proved unfavourable: marked oedema and older age14.

The second, in 58 patients, compared the same Quickcast with a custom-made thermoplastic orthosis. This time no difference in final lag or in recourse to surgery, but fewer skin complications (33% against 64%) and less pain in the cast group13.

The third, single-centre, in 70 patients, compared a prefabricated three-point orthosis held by an elastic tape with a cast, for six weeks of continuous immobilisation: no difference at six months in extension lag, flexion deficit, function or pain. This orthosis was not compared with the custom-made one19.

The combined reading of these studies is clear enough to guide practice: what matters is that the finger never flexes. A well-tolerated removable orthosis that is actually worn is worth a cast; a removable orthosis that is taken off for washing loses its advantage.

The instruction to give, word for word

“The splint stays in place day and night, without exception, for eight weeks. For washing, keep the finger straight: take the splint off only while holding the last phalanx in extension with the other hand, clean, dry, and put it back on. If the finger bends even once, the count starts again from zero.” This last sentence is not a teaching device: the reference chapter states it as such1, and the O'Brien trial shows that adherence correlates directly with the result7.

Key points

  • The type of orthosis does not change the final extension lag (three trials agree).
  • It changes treatment failure : 23.8% with a prefabricated splint, 0% with a custom-made thermoplastic.
  • It also changes the skin tolerance : relative risk 3.17 against the other orthoses, 6.72 against the custom-made one.
  • The real determinant is adherence, and the best orthosis is the one that this patient will wear for eight weeks.

How long to immobilise, and what to do if the patient arrives late?

Two questions that the patient always asks, and to which the literature gives an unusually clear answer for this condition.

The timetable

The reference protocol is stable from one source to another: continuous immobilisation of the distal interphalangeal joint in full extension for six to eight weeks, followed by night-time wear for a further two to six weeks1. The synthesis review retains six to eight weeks of permanent wear and then gradual weaning over the following two weeks2, and the O'Brien trial applied eight weeks of continuous wear followed by graded weaning over four weeks with exercises7.

A point of functional anatomy deserves to be explained to the patient: only the distal interphalangeal joint must be immobilised. The proximal interphalangeal joint remains free and must be mobilised from the first day: this is what prevents the stiffness in flexion that is the most disabling in the long term.

The timetable of orthotic treatment

Protocol from the reference chapter and the O'Brien randomised trial

Timetable of orthotic treatment of mallet finger Six to eight weeks of continuous wear, then two to six weeks of night-time wear or gradual weaning with exercises; the proximal interphalangeal joint is mobilised from the first day. CONTINUOUS wear, day and night 6 to 8 weeks: no flexion tolerated Gradual weaning 2 to 6 weeks, night-time wear Resumption S0S4S8S12 PROXIMAL interphalangeal joint mobilised from the first day, throughout A single flexion of the distal interphalangeal joint = the count starts again from zero Including during washing: the phalanx is held in extension with the other hand to change the splint.

Sources: Mallet Finger Injuries, StatPearls, NCBI Bookshelf NBK459373 (PMID 29083648); Khera B et al. Acta Biomed 2021 (PMID 34738569); O'Brien LJ, Bailey MJ. Arch Phys Med Rehabil 2011 (PMID 21272714).

Is the additional night-time wear of any use?

The question was put to a randomised trial. Fifty-one patients who had completed six to eight weeks of continuous immobilisation were allocated between one additional month of night-time orthosis and no orthosis. No difference was found in final extension lag, in disability, or in satisfaction8.

This same trial provides two figures that must be borne in mind before promising a result to the patient: the mean final extension lag was 14°, and 34% of patients (14 out of 41 assessed on-site) kept a lag of 20° or more. The authors put it bluntly: residual lags of 20° and more are commonplace. The initial lag and the initial flexion also predicted the final lag, explaining 28% of its variability8.

A well-treated mallet finger leaves fourteen degrees of lag on average. Saying so from the first consultation spares the patient from experiencing a normal result as a failure.

The patient who arrives late

This is the most frequent situation in the practice, since the triggering movement is innocuous and the pain is modest. The answer is reassuring, and it is an old one.

A comparison of two groups of 40 patients (treatment started within two weeks of the injury on one side, more than four weeks after it on the other) measured the success of orthotic treatment, defined as active extension with at most 10° of residual lag. Success in 17 patients out of 21 in the early group, and in 15 out of 19 in the delayed group. Neither the presence of a fracture of the dorsal rim involving less than a third of the articular surface, nor the type of splint used, changed the final result. The authors conclude that the splint was as effective in the late-treated population as in the early-treated population9.

What this changes in consultation

A patient who presents six weeks after the injury has not “missed their chance”. The full orthotic treatment should be offered, with the same requirement for continuous wear, without letting the patient believe that the delay makes surgery necessary. The finding dates from 1994 and has never been contradicted since; it does not remove the need for a surgical opinion when the injury goes beyond type I, but it avoids giving up on principle.

Key points

  • Six to eight weeks of continuous wear, then two to six weeks of night-time wear or gradual weaning.
  • The additional night-time wear after a complete immobilisation brings no measurable benefit.
  • Expected result to announce: 14° of residual lag on average, and 34% of patients at 20° or more.
  • Treatment started more than four weeks after the injury gives results comparable to early treatment.

Should a mallet finger be operated on?

Lateral finger radiographs before (a) and after (b) treatment: dorsal avulsion fracture at the base of the distal phalanx, anatomical reduction achieved and fixed with a screw.

X-rayLateral finger radiographs before (a) and after (b) treatment: dorsal avulsion fracture at the base of the distal phalanx, anatomical reduction achieved and fixed with a screw.

Source : Shimura et al., Journal of orthopaedic science : official journal of the Japanese Orthopaedic Association, 2014, figure 3 · CC BY

The question seems decisive, but it is far less so than the choice of orthosis, and the trials that put it directly all give the same answer.

What the systematic review establishes

A systematic review gathered 44 studies reporting clinical results: 22 on surgical treatments, 17 on non-surgical treatments. The two figures to remember are remarkably close5 :

  • mean extension lag of 5.7° after surgery, against 7.6° after non-surgical treatment ;
  • complication rate of 14.5% after surgery, against 12.8% after non-surgical treatment.

Five studies compared the two strategies directly, with divergent results and recommendations. The authors' conclusion is explicit: both treatments give excellent clinical results, the available evidence does not allow determining when surgical intervention is indicated, and these treatments appear equivalent and should be individualised5. This is the same conclusion that the Cochrane review had drawn fourteen years earlier4.

The randomised trials that put the question head-on

On tendinous mallet finger. One trial allocated 48 patients between a thermoplastic orthosis and Kirschner wire fixation. At sixteen weeks, no significant difference in final extension or in extension lag. Both groups showed the same profile of early extension loss after removal of the immobilisation, partially recovered by regular active exercise11.

On bony mallet finger with a fragment greater than a third, without initial subluxation. A level I randomised trial compared the orthosis with extension-block pinning in 32 randomised patients, 28 analysed. At six months, no difference in active extension lag or in function and pain scores. Better still: flexion, active range and pulp-to-palm distance were better in the orthosis group. But three patients of this group developed a secondary subluxation, which leads the authors to a nuanced conclusion: the orthosis is safe and effective for restoring mobility, it does not sufficiently prevent secondary subluxation, and radiographic follow-up during the immobilisation appears necessary10.

On bony mallet finger whose fragment covers 20 to 50% of the articular surface (Doyle IV-B). A single-centre trial of 62 patients compared a variant of extension-block pinning, combined with an orthosis, with a Stack orthosis fixed with plaster. At twelve months, the extension lag is smaller after pinning (4.5° against 12.2°) and excellent results according to the Crawford criteria are more numerous; but subluxation of the distal interphalangeal joint is more frequent in the operated group (42% against 17%), without a significant difference in the overall complication rate. The allocation was not fully random: four patients who refused surgery were placed in the orthosis group, the following ones in the operated group, and the groups differ in age (29.8 against 38.8 years)18. These results conflict with those of the previous trial: for a large fragment, the decision is taken case by case, with the opinion of the hand surgeon.

On the comparison with an anchor. A level Ib randomised trial compared an anchor technique with conservative treatment in 29 patients. Extension lag of 8.1° after surgery against 6.1° with conservative treatment, return to work at 63.2 days against 53.7, final flexion of the distal interphalangeal joint of 54.5° against 58.3°. And a result that is not trivial: radiographic joint degeneration was observed in four patients of the surgical group and in none of the conservative group at one year12.

Surgery against orthotic treatment: what the comparative data show

Systematic review of 44 studies, supplemented by three randomised trials

Comparison of surgery and orthotic treatment of mallet finger Extension lag 5.7 degrees after surgery against 7.6 after orthosis; complications 14.5% against 12.8%; return to work 63 days against 54; joint degeneration in 4 operated patients against 0. surgery orthosis Residual extension lag 5.7° 7.6° Complications 14.5% 12.8% Systematic review of 44 studies (Lin 2018). Below: direct randomised trial in 29 patients (Batıbay 2018). Return to work (days) 63.2 53.7 Joint degeneration at 1 year 4 patients none The authors of the systematic review conclude that the two treatments are equivalent and should be individualised.

Sources: Lin JS, Samora JB. J Hand Surg Am 2018;43(2):146-163.e2 (PMID 29174096); Batıbay SG, Akgül T, Bayram S, Ayık Ö, Durmaz H. J Hand Ther 2018;31(4):429-436 (PMID 28966061).

Key points

  • Setting aside a large bone fragment, surgery and orthosis gave similar results in a review of series and trials: 5.7° against 7.6° of lag, 14.5% against 12.8% of complications.
  • Three randomised trials found no difference : in tendinous mallet finger, in bony mallet finger and against an anchor technique; a fourth, on a fragment of 20 to 50%, finds less lag after pinning but more subluxations.
  • One trial observed joint degeneration in 4 operated patients against 0 conservatively treated at one year.
  • The orthosis for a large bony mallet finger requires radiographic follow-up : three secondary subluxations in the level I trial.

What changes with a hand that works, or that plays?

The cost of this injury is almost never medical: it is an occupational and sporting cost, and it falls on the dominant hand three times out of four.

An injury that affects the hand that is used

Two pieces of data frame the problem. The dominant hand is affected in about 74% of cases2, and the treatment requires six to eight weeks of continuous immobilisation1. For a craftsperson, a cook, a healthcare worker, a musician or a hairdresser, this cannot be settled by a prescription: it has to be prepared.

The sporting side is also documented. Mallet finger is said to account for 2% of sports emergencies and to be the most frequent closed tendon injury in contact sports as in the workplace15. The classic mechanism (the ball received on the finger pulp, finger extended) mainly concerns ball sports where the ball is received bare-handed.

What the trials actually measure about resumption

Only one quantified datum on resumption exists in the randomised literature, and it comes from a level Ib trial comparing an anchor technique with conservative treatment in 29 patients: return to work in 63.2 days on average after surgery, against 53.7 days after conservative treatment12. Nine days' difference in favour of non-surgical treatment: one more argument, if one were needed, for not operating by default on a closed injury.

For return to sport, we must be frank: no study has evaluated the modalities or timing of return to sport in this injury. What is practised is a matter of reasoning (gradual resumption once active extension is achieved and stable, protection during activities exposing the finger to a direct blow) and must be presented as such to the patient and to the coach.

The anaesthetist's case published in Anaesthesia Reports illustrates the order of magnitude of the impact when the hand is the tool of work: the injury, managed without surgery, required a significant break from clinical activity before good recovery and return to work17. The authors devote part of their discussion to contributing factors and prevention strategies, which, for an injury reputed to be benign, says enough about its real cost.

Impact according to context. The column “what the literature says” cites only measured data; the “adaptation” column is a matter of clinical reasoning, no study having evaluated these adjustments.
ContextWhat the literature saysAdaptation to discuss
Heavy manual workReturn to work at 53.7 days on average after conservative treatment12Protective glove over the orthosis, workstation adjustment or change of role for the duration of the treatment
Care professions and fine movementsA published case of prolonged break from clinical activity after an injury occurring in the operating theatre17Thinnest possible orthosis, trial of technical movements before resumption
Ball sportsClassic mechanism of the direct blow to the finger pulp; 2% of sports emergencies15No catching situations during immobilisation; no data on the timing of resumption
Keyboard workNo specific dataCompatible with wearing the orthosis in most cases; check that there is no forced flexion when typing
Elderly person, marked oedemaMarked oedema and older age associated with a greater final extension lag14Close monitoring of the orthosis and of the swelling, non-removable immobilisation to be considered

What to say from the first consultation

Three messages, and it is better to give them together:

  • The duration is incompressible. Six to eight weeks of continuous wear, plus weaning. This is not negotiable according to the professional diary, because an interruption restarts the count1.
  • The expected result is not perfection. Fourteen degrees of residual lag on average, one third of patients at 20° or more8. On a long finger, this lag is most often well tolerated functionally.
  • Surgery does not shorten anything. It even lengthens the return to work by nine days in the only trial that measured it12, for a similar final lag5.

Key points

  • 74% dominant hands and six to eight weeks of splinting: the impact is first of all occupational.
  • Only randomised datum on resumption: 53.7 days conservatively against 63.2 after surgery.
  • No study has evaluated return to sport: what is practised is reasoning, to be presented as such.
  • Anticipate the workstation adjustment from the first consultation, not at the sixth week.

What is rehabilitated after the immobilisation?

This is the part of the treatment that falls to the physiotherapist, and paradoxically the least studied. A recent trial nevertheless provides an element that we did not have, and it concerns exactly that moment.

The phenomenon that everyone observes, finally described

A level II randomised trial compared, in 48 patients with a tendinous mallet finger, the thermoplastic orthosis with Kirschner wire fixation. Beyond its main result (no difference at sixteen weeks), it documents a clinical observation that every practitioner knows and that nobody had quantified: a loss of extension occurs in the days following removal of the immobilisation, whatever it is, and it is partially recovered by routine active exercise11.

The authors conclude that sustained active exercise appears to promote recovery of extension of the distal interphalangeal joint11. The wording is cautious (it is a secondary result of a trial that was not testing this question), but it finally gives support to what practice has always done.

The trial provides a second element, useful for prediction: the final extension of the joint was correlated with the extension obtained under immobilisation (r = 0.60) and with the maximum extension of the contralateral finger (rho = 0.54)11. In other words, one must look at the healthy finger opposite before setting a goal: a patient whose contralateral distal interphalangeal joint does not go beyond 0° will not achieve better on the injured side.

The programme, session by session

During the immobilisation (weeks 0 to 8). The physiotherapist's role is not nil, it is preventive:

  • Active mobilisation of the proximal interphalangeal joint, from the first day and at every session. It is stiffness in flexion of this joint that leaves the most troublesome functional sequelae.
  • Mobilisation of the metacarpophalangeal joints and of the wrist, and maintenance of the overall grasp on the affected side.
  • Oedema control. This is not an aesthetic concern: in the Tocco trial, marked oedema and older age had a negative influence on the final extension lag14. Elevation, gentle drainage proximal to the splint, checking that the orthosis does not act as a tourniquet.
  • Checking the orthosis at every session : fit, skin condition, absence of any possibility of flexion. Reminder of the changing protocol, with the phalanx held in extension.

At weaning (weeks 8 to 12). The trial protocols provide for gradual withdrawal over two to four weeks with exercises27. In practice:

  • gradual daytime withdrawal, orthosis kept at night and for at-risk activities;
  • active extension of the distal interphalangeal joint, repeated in short, frequent sets rather than long sessions: this is the movement that the Zhu trial associates with recovery11 ;
  • active flexion gradual and not forced : regaining the curl of the finger is done without passive stretching in flexion, which would lengthen the fresh tendon scar;
  • monitoring of the extension lag at every session: a return of the lag means putting the orthosis back on continuously for a few days and slowing the weaning.

What not to do. Adding a night-time orthosis after a correctly conducted complete immobilisation brings nothing: the randomised trial that tested it found no difference in lag, disability or satisfaction8. And forcing flexion of the distal interphalangeal joint in the first weeks of weaning has no basis, whereas the risk of recreating a tendon lengthening is mechanically real.

The table of modalities, with the available level of evidence

Editorial judgement applying GRADE principles to the question of treatment of traumatic mallet finger. No formal GRADE assessment or recommendation from a learned society exists for this condition (the Cochrane review explicitly stopped at a finding of insufficient evidence)4.

Moderate

Custom-made thermoplastic orthosis rather than prefabricated. Multicentre randomised trial: 23.8% treatment failure against 0%7. Meta-analysis of 7 trials: risk of skin complication multiplied by 3.17 with the prefabricated one, by 6.72 against the custom-made thermoplastic6. Downgraded from “high” because the final extension lag, for its part, does not differ.

Moderate

Do NOT add a night-time orthosis after a complete immobilisation. Randomised trial in 51 patients: no difference in lag, disability or satisfaction8. Direct evidence of absence of benefit, on a relevant outcome.

Moderate

Orthotic treatment rather than surgery as first line for closed injuries without subluxation or large bone fragment. Systematic review of 44 studies: lag 5.7° against 7.6°, complications 14.5% against 12.8%5 ; three randomised trials without difference101112, one of them with more joint degeneration on the surgical side12.

Low

Fragment of 20 to 50% of the articular surface: case-by-case decision, with the hand surgeon. A single-centre trial of 62 patients finds less extension lag after pinning, but more subluxations, with an allocation that was not fully random18 ; the trial on the fragment of more than a third found no difference10. Conflicting trials.

Low

Continuous immobilisation in extension for 6 to 8 weeks. No trial has compared immobilisation with no treatment (it would hardly be ethical). It is the foundation of all trial protocols711 and the synthesis review recalls that the lag does not regress spontaneously2.

Low

Regular active exercise after the immobilisation is removed. Secondary result of a randomised trial: the early loss of extension after removal was partially recovered by routine active exercise, and sustained exercise appears to promote recovery11. That was not the question tested.

Low

Oedema control during the immobilisation. In a randomised trial, marked oedema and older age had a negative influence on the final extension lag14. Observed association, not the effect of a tested intervention.

Very low

Mobilisation of the proximal interphalangeal joint from the first day. No study has evaluated it for this indication. Consistent with the mechanics and without risk for the injury, which does not involve this joint.

Very low

Gradual weaning over 2 to 4 weeks. Protocol applied by the trials7, never compared with abrupt withdrawal. Reasoned practice, not demonstrated.

No evidence

Passive mobilisation or massage of the distal interphalangeal joint during the immobilisation. Contrary to the very principle of the treatment: any flexion restarts the count1. Unfavourable benefit/risk ratio by construction.

No evidence

Instrumental physiotherapy (ultrasound, laser, currents) for mallet finger: no study identified for this indication.

What should prompt a return to surgical opinion

  • Palmar subluxation of the distal phalanx appearing under the orthosis: three cases in 14 patients in the level I trial on large bony mallet fingers10. A radiographic check during the immobilisation is necessary in these forms.
  • Hyperextension of the proximal interphalangeal joint that sets in: swan neck deformity, the correction of which is surgical2.
  • Skin distress under the orthosis (maceration, blister, dorsal necrosis): three times more frequent with prefabricated orthoses6. Change the orthosis, do not interrupt the treatment.
  • Lag that worsens during weaning despite resuming continuous wear.

Key points

  • An early loss of extension after removal is expected, and regular active exercise partially recovers it.
  • Look at the contralateral finger before setting a goal: the final extension is correlated with it.
  • During the immobilisation, the work focuses on the proximal interphalangeal joint, the oedema and the orthosis (never on the injured joint).
  • Night-time wear after a complete immobilisation adds nothing: the trial that tested it is negative.

What do concrete clinical cases teach us?

Three published cases, with their identifiers. None describes an ordinary mallet finger: these are precisely the ones that teach something.

Case 1: A mallet finger that develops over three weeks, without trauma

Benabdallah O, Benabdallah R. Journal of Orthopaedic Case Reports 2022;12(11):60-6415 (free full text: PMC10066668).

A 35-year-old woman consults for a mallet deformity of the right second finger. On questioning, she reports no trauma : the deformity developed gradually over more than twenty days, preceded by moderate pain and burning sensations at the level of the third phalanx. On palpation, nodules are felt at the level of the distal interphalangeal joint and on the dorsal aspect of the second phalanx. The radiograph shows the classic deformity, with no associated bone lesion.

The diagnosis of pigmented villonodular synovitis was suspected intra-operatively, given the presence of haemosiderin in the tendon sheath and in the distal joint. Treatment combined excision of the mass, a tenosynovectomy and tendon reinsertion.

What this case teaches. The authors stress that mallet finger occurs “always after a traumatic aetiology” and that this cause had never been reported. For practice, the rule is simple and requires no expertise: gradual onset plus absence of trauma plus palpable nodules equals investigation, not orthosis.

Case 2: A 4-year-old child, a painless deformity, an inconclusive radiograph

Aprilya D, Satria O, Vianney MM. International Journal of Surgery Case Reports 2025;129:11110516 (free full text: PMC11932670).

The parents consult for a “crooked” left little finger in a 4-year-old child. The deformity, painless, progressed over a year, with no identifiable injury. Examination finds a palpable bony mass proximal to the angulated distal interphalangeal joint. The radiograph was inconclusive and suggested an old fracture of the middle phalanx.

Intra-operatively, a sessile exostosis of the epi-metaphysis of the middle phalanx was pushing the terminal extensor tendon towards the ulnar border. Biopsy confirmed an osteochondroma. Reconstruction of the terminal tendon and of the skin followed the resection; at two years of follow-up, there was no infection, no recurrence of the deformity and no tumour recurrence.

What this case teaches. Two flags accumulated (age and absence of trauma), and a third element could have falsely reassured: a radiograph interpreted as a fracture sequela. In a child, a progressive and painless mallet deformity is not a traumatic mallet finger, and an inconclusive radiograph is not a normal radiograph.

Case 3: A work accident, non-surgical management, a long break from work

de Vena Franks PL, Lightfoot NJ. Anaesthesia Reports 2020;8(2):127-13017 (free full text: PMC7656317).

An anaesthetist is injured at the time of induction, during a tracheal intubation. The authors note that injuries to healthcare workers are frequent but rarely published, and that this mechanism had never been described. The injury was treated without surgery ; after a significant break from clinical activity, the practitioner recovered well and returned to work. The article discusses the contributing factors and prevention strategies.

What this case teaches. It illustrates the most frequent and most banal mechanism (forced flexion against resistance during an ordinary movement), and it recalls the real cost of this injury, which is not medical but occupational. Eight weeks of splinting on a finger that works must be anticipated with the patient from the first consultation: workstation adjustment, gloves, adapted equipment, and informing the employer.

Key points

  • The three most instructive published cases are mallet fingers that were not mallet fingers, or whose stake was not the finger.
  • No trauma, gradual onset, palpable mass, child : four reasons to investigate before splinting.
  • A radiograph that is inconclusive is not a normal radiograph.
  • The real cost of the injury is occupational : to be anticipated from the first consultation.

How do you apply all this from Monday morning?

A frequent injury, a long treatment, a result that depends almost entirely on what the patient does between two sessions: this is a condition where the first consultation is worth more than all the following ones.

The first session, in six points

  1. Confirm. Active extension impossible, passive extension free and not maintained on release2. Two seconds, and that is the diagnosis.
  2. Rule out what is not a traumatic mallet finger. Trauma found? Sudden onset? No palpable mass? Not a child? Without these four answers, we investigate before splinting1516.
  3. Demand the lateral radiograph if it has not been done: it is joint congruence that is being looked for, not only the fragment1.
  4. Make, or have made, a custom-made orthosis. In a randomised trial, it gave 0% failure against 23.8% with the Stack or the dorsal aluminium7, and the prefabricated one multiplies the risk of skin complication by almost seven compared with the custom-made one6. Failing that, a prefabricated three-point orthosis held by an elastic tape did no worse than a cast in a trial of 70 patients, without having been compared with the custom-made one19.
  5. Give the wearing instruction, word for word, and have it repeated back. Eight weeks, day and night, changing while maintaining extension, one flexion equals starting again.
  6. Announce the expected result. Fourteen degrees of residual lag on average, one patient in three at 20° or more8. A patient who has been warned does not experience a normal result as a failure.

What is followed, and at what rhythm

Suggested follow-up. The indicators are those used by the cited trials; the intervals are a matter of common-sense organisation and not of a published recommendation.
What is measuredWhyRhythm
Active extension lag in degreesPrimary outcome of all the cited trials; comparable with the literature78At baseline, then at each assessment after weaning
Skin condition under the orthosisMost frequent complication, up to three times more likely with a prefabricated model6At every session
Reported adherenceCorrelated with the final lag in the multicentre trial7 ; it is the main leverAt every session
Range of motion of the proximal interphalangeal jointIts stiffness is the most troublesome functional sequela, and it is avoidableAt every session
OedemaUnfavourable factor measured on the final lag14Weekly at the start
Extension of the contralateral distal interphalangeal jointCorrelated with the final extension on the injured side11 : sets the realistic goalOnce, at baseline
Control radiograph for large bony mallet fingersThree secondary subluxations under the orthosis in the level I trial10As prescribed, during the immobilisation

Who to refer to, and when

  • Hand surgeon for a wound (types II and III), a fracture involving more than a third of the articular surface, a subluxation, a joint gap greater than 2 mm, a complex injury1, or a subluxation appearing under the orthosis10.
  • Hand surgeon also for an established swan neck deformity, the correction of which is surgical2.
  • Medical opinion before any orthosis for a non-traumatic mallet finger, of gradual onset, with a palpable mass, or in a child1516.
  • Occupational physician since the occupational impact is the real cost of this injury, which affects the dominant hand in about three quarters of cases2 and requires eight weeks of splinting.

Frequently asked questions

Will my finger be completely straight at the end?

Not always, and it is better to know this from the start. In the most informative randomised trial on this point, the mean final extension lag was 14°, and 34% of patients kept a lag of 20° or more8. The systematic review gives more favourable means, 7.6° after orthotic treatment5 but a moderate residual lag is the rule rather than the exception, and it is most often well tolerated.

What happens if I take the splint off once?

The count starts again from zero. This is not a teaching device: the reference chapter states that any flexion of the joint during the process of immobilisation requires starting again1. The tendon, which is healing, is brought back into a lengthened position, and the work of the weeks that have passed is lost.

Can I take the splint off to wash my hands?

Yes, provided that you hold the last phalanx in extension with the other hand throughout the manoeuvre: slide the splint off, clean, dry, put it back on, without ever letting the finger drop. If the patient is not sure of being able to do this, non-removable immobilisation is an alternative: in a randomised trial, it gave 5° less lag than a removable orthosis at twelve weeks14.

Should I be operated on for a better result?

No, for closed injuries without subluxation or large bone fragment. The systematic review of 44 studies finds 5.7° of lag after surgery against 7.6° after orthosis, with comparable complication rates (14.5% against 12.8%), and concludes that the two treatments are equivalent and should be individualised5. A randomised trial even observed radiographic joint degeneration in four operated patients against none of the conservatively treated patients at one year12. For a fragment of 20 to 50% of the articular surface, a trial from 2026 finds less lag after pinning but more subluxations: the decision is taken with the hand surgeon18.

I waited six weeks before consulting, is it too late?

No. A comparison of two groups of 40 patients (treatment started within two weeks against more than four weeks after the injury) found success in 17 patients out of 21 in the early group and 15 out of 19 in the delayed group9. The full orthotic treatment remains indicated, with the same requirement for wear.

Which splint should I buy at the pharmacy?

The question deserves to be turned around: the commercial prefabricated splint, Stack type, showed 23.8% treatment failure against 0% for a custom-made thermoplastic orthosis in a multicentre randomised trial7, and a risk of skin complication multiplied by almost seven in meta-analysis6. The custom-made one, made by a trained physiotherapist or occupational therapist, is not a luxury: it is what makes the difference between a treatment carried through and a treatment abandoned.

Can I go back to sport?

Not during the eight weeks of continuous wear, except for activities without risk to the finger and with the orthosis in place. No study has evaluated the modalities of return to sport in this injury; the practical benchmark is that of weaning: gradual resumption once active extension is achieved and stable, with protection during activities at risk of a direct blow.

My middle finger goes into hyperextension, is that normal?

No, and this warrants an opinion. It is the swan neck deformity : the loss of distal traction transfers the force onto the central slip and tips the proximal interphalangeal joint into hyperextension. Its correction is a matter for surgery2, and it is detected by monitoring this joint at every session.

On the same subject

Bibliography

Each reference was verified individually in PubMed: identifier resolved, journal, year, volume and author list checked, abstract read to make sure that the source establishes what is attributed to it.

  1. Beutel BG, Waseem M. Mallet Finger Injuries. StatPearls, NCBI Bookshelf, NBK459373, updated 6 July 2025. Read the chapter · PMID 29083648. Source used for the Doyle classification, the quantified operative indications and the immobilisation protocol.
  2. Khera B, Chang C, Bhat W. An overview of mallet finger injuries. Acta Biomed 2021;92(5):e2021246. DOI 10.23750/abm.v92i5.11731 · PMID 34738569
  3. Sivakumar BS, Graham DJ, Ledgard JP, Lawson RD. Acute mallet finger injuries: a review. J Hand Surg Am 2023;48(3):283-291. DOI 10.1016/j.jhsa.2022.10.013 · PMID 36509592
  4. Handoll HH, Vaghela MV. Interventions for treating mallet finger injuries. Cochrane Database Syst Rev 2004;2004(3):CD004574. DOI 10.1002/14651858.CD004574.pub2 · PMID 15266538
  5. Lin JS, Samora JB. Surgical and nonsurgical management of mallet finger: a systematic review. J Hand Surg Am 2018;43(2):146-163.e2. DOI 10.1016/j.jhsa.2017.10.004 · PMID 29174096
  6. Witherow EJ, Peiris CL. Custom-made finger orthoses have fewer skin complications than prefabricated finger orthoses in the management of mallet injury: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Arch Phys Med Rehabil 2015;96(10):1913-1923.e1. DOI 10.1016/j.apmr.2015.04.026 · PMID 26163944
  7. O'Brien LJ, Bailey MJ. Single blind, prospective, randomized controlled trial comparing dorsal aluminum and custom thermoplastic splints to stack splint for acute mallet finger. Arch Phys Med Rehabil 2011;92(2):191-198. DOI 10.1016/j.apmr.2010.10.035 · PMID 21272714
  8. Gruber JS, Bot AG, Ring D. A prospective randomized controlled trial comparing night splinting with no splinting after treatment of mallet finger. Hand (N Y) 2014;9(2):145-150. DOI 10.1007/s11552-013-9600-z · PMID 24839414
  9. Garberman SF, Diao E, Peimer CA. Mallet finger: results of early versus delayed closed treatment. J Hand Surg Am 1994;19(5):850-852. DOI 10.1016/0363-5023(94)90200-3 · PMID 7806817
  10. Thillemann JK, Thillemann TM, Kristensen PK, Foldager-Jensen AD, Munk B. Splinting versus extension-block pinning of bony mallet finger: a randomized clinical trial. J Hand Surg Eur Vol 2020;45(6):574-581. DOI 10.1177/1753193420917567 · PMID 32338190
  11. Zhu X, Chen X, Lv Y, Chen Y, Gao W, Yan H. The importance of active exercise in treatment of tendinous mallet finger: insights from a randomized controlled clinical trial. J Hand Surg Am 2025;50(11):1404.e1-1404.e10. DOI 10.1016/j.jhsa.2024.12.011 · PMID 39918530
  12. Batıbay SG, Akgül T, Bayram S, Ayık Ö, Durmaz H. Conservative management equally effective to new suture anchor technique for acute mallet finger deformity: a prospective randomized clinical trial. J Hand Ther 2018;31(4):429-436. DOI 10.1016/j.jht.2017.07.006 · PMID 28966061
  13. Cavanaugh PK, Watkins C, Jones C, Maltenfort MG, Beredjiklian PK, Rivlin M. Effectiveness of Quickcast versus custom-fabricated thermoplastic orthosis immobilization for the treatment of mallet fingers: a randomized clinical trial. Hand (N Y) 2022;17(6):1090-1097. DOI 10.1177/1558944720988136 · PMID 33511868
  14. Tocco S, Boccolari P, Landi A et al. Effectiveness of cast immobilization in comparison to the gold-standard self-removal orthotic intervention for closed mallet fingers: a randomized clinical trial. J Hand Ther 2013;26(3):191-200. DOI 10.1016/j.jht.2013.01.004 · PMID 23453367
  15. Benabdallah O, Benabdallah R. Mallet finger caused by a villonodular synovitis: a case report and literature review. J Orthop Case Rep 2022;12(11):60-64. DOI 10.13107/jocr.2022.v12.i11.3416 · PMID 37013228
  16. Aprilya D, Satria O, Vianney MM. Finger osteochondroma presenting as non-traumatic mallet finger in pediatric: a case report. Int J Surg Case Rep 2025;129:111105. DOI 10.1016/j.ijscr.2025.111105 · PMID 40073800
  17. de Vena Franks PL, Lightfoot NJ. Mallet finger in an anaesthetist following tracheal intubation. Anaesth Rep 2020;8(2):127-130. DOI 10.1002/anr3.12073 · PMID 33210089
  18. Col KA, Demirsu O, Aydın M, Surucu S, Yilmaz M, Atlihan D. Pin orthosis extension block pinning versus conservative treatment for Doyle type 4B mallet fractures. Arch Orthop Trauma Surg 2026;146(1):232. DOI 10.1007/s00402-026-06342-z · PMID 42337168
  19. Algar L, Backe H, Richer R, Andruskiwec S, Zalenski P, Lengyel A, Svogun C. Prospective randomized clinical trial comparing 3-point prefabricated orthosis and elastic tape versus cast immobilization for the nonsurgical management of mallet finger. J Hand Surg Am 2023;48(9):951.e1-951.e9. DOI 10.1016/j.jhsa.2022.02.012 · PMID 35466009

Methods and limitations

Sources searched in PubMed via the NCBI E-utilities services, crossing mallet finger with classification, orthoses, duration of immobilisation, surgery, rehabilitation and case reports. Each identifier was resolved and each abstract read before citation. Strength of this dossier, rare in the field: nine randomised trials and a Cochrane review ; mallet finger is by far the best studied of the three topics in this series. Main limitation : these trials compare orthoses with each other or the orthosis with surgery, never treatment with no treatment, and none has evaluated a rehabilitation protocol as such. The levels of evidence in the table of modalities are an editorial judgement applying GRADE principles, and not a published GRADE assessment: the Cochrane review explicitly stopped at a finding of insufficient evidence. Article written on 14 August 2026.

Behind this article

An author who explains, a reviewer who checks.

How we write and check our content

Anthony Baillon, physiotherapist and co-founder of Physio Learning
✍️ Author

Anthony Baillon

Physiotherapist · co-founder of Physio Learning

Marked for life by his first four-hour lecture without a single image, he took a master’s in instructional design so that it would never happen to anyone again. He hunts down publication bias and unreadable slides with the same intransigence.

PhysiotherapistInstructional designerCare design
Follow on LinkedIn
Robin Vervaeke, head of scientific content at Physio Learning✓ Verified

Robin Vervaeke

Head of scientific content

Physiotherapist specialising in neuro-musculoskeletal practice and holder of a master’s in public health. He checks the methodological rigour of every article: primary sources, levels of evidence, no exceptions.

Neuro-musculoskeletalMSc Public health
Follow on LinkedIn

Share