Skip to content
Sign up

Updated · published

The Jones fracture (base of the 5th metatarsal): 2026 update

Jones fracture: zone 2 against styloid avulsion, two neighbouring fractures with opposite prognoses. Non-union, surgery and return to sport, sourced.

The essentials, in 30 seconds

A fracture of the base of the 5th metatarsal is not a single entity: the prognosis depends on whether or not the fracture line reaches the joint between the 4th and 5th metatarsals.

97.3%bone union after screw fixation of a Jones fracture in athletes

What it is
The true Jones fracture, in zone 2, has a poor vascular prognosis.
How to decide
The question that settles it: does the fracture line reach the joint between the 4th and 5th metatarsals?
Who gets it
Two opposing profiles: the woman over 40 who twists her foot, and the pivoting athlete.
What to avoid
Returning to sport before radiological healing produces refractures: a systematic review explicitly advises against it.
How long
13 of 18 refractures occur within six months of the start of rehabilitation.

What follows covers each of these points in detail, with sources. It is there if you need it.

This topic is taught in a course: From injury to return to play: structure every stage of reconditioning, on-site with Maxence Ponthus.

Chapter by chapter

1 / 12

11 article chapters · 41 min in total

Chapter 1

Classify◔ 3 min

The Lawrence and Botte classification distinguishes three zones according to the fracture line, not its appearance.

Zone 1
An avulsion of the tuberosity, at the proximal end of the bone: zone 1.
Zone 2
The true Jones fracture lies at the metaphyseal-diaphyseal junction: this is zone 2.
Zone A
Zone A receives the insertion of the plantar fascia, about 6.6 mm from the inferior border.
Zone B
Zone B corresponds to the insertion of the peroneus brevis, a little more distal.
Chapter 2

Vascular supply◔ 2 min

The proximal diaphysis depends mainly on a nutrient artery, unlike the tuberosity.

Tuberosity
The tuberosity benefits from a rich, redundant network of metaphyseal vessels.
Junction zone
The two vascular networks meet just downstream of the tuberosity.
Limits of the evidence
The vascular explanation has never been directly linked to a measured nonunion rate.
Challenge
The review by Polzer et al. challenges this reading, on prospective data.
Chapter 3

Epidemiology◔ 3 min

Proximal fractures of the 5th metatarsal account for 61 to 78% of all foot fractures.

Most fractured
The fifth metatarsal is, on its own, the most frequently fractured metatarsal.
Dancer's fracture
The dancer's fracture accounts for 25% of cases, 80% of them in women.
Predictive mechanism
The series by Kane et al. (1,275 fractures) shows that the mechanism predicts the location.
Pivoting athlete
The true Jones fracture mostly affects the pivoting athlete: football, basketball, American football.
Chapter 4

Diagnose◔ 4 min

A single question settles it: does the fracture line reach the joint between the 4th and 5th metatarsals?

Serious error
Mistaking a zone 2 for a zone 1 is the serious error: the patient walks on a bone at risk.
Costly error
Mistaking a zone 1 for a zone 2 is the costly error: needless immobilisation and surgery.
Os vesalianum
The os vesalianum is an accessory ossicle close to the base of the 5th metatarsal: a look-alike.
Comparison radiograph
Regular, corticated margins: a radiograph of the contralateral foot settles any persistent doubt.
Chapter 5

Distinguish◔ 3 min

The classic Jones fracture is acute: a weight-bearing step, immediate pain and loss of function.

Stress fracture
The stress fracture shows as prodromal pain growing over weeks.
Zone 3
Zone 3 fractures are described as diaphyseal stress fractures.
Key question
A simple and rarely asked question: “Did you have pain before?”
Vitamin D
A low vitamin D level, below 30 ng/mL, multiplies the odds of stress fracture by 23.
Chapter 6

Surgery◔ 8 min

The Jones fracture is exposed to an increased risk of nonunion despite well-conducted surgery.

Return to sport
Intramedullary screw fixation brings return to sport to 98.8%, against an overall rate of 98.4%.
Dissenting view
According to Polzer, zone 1 avulsions heal well with functional treatment, even when displaced.
Plaster cast boot
The plaster cast boot significantly delays return to the previous level, compared with functional treatment.
Radiological nonunion
A radiological nonunion is not necessarily symptomatic: all remain pain-free at one year.
Chapter 7

Prognosis◔ 5 min

Only midfoot adductus is confirmed as a risk factor in meta-analysis.

Radiographic varus
In operated patients, 18 hindfeet out of 21 showed a radiographic varus.
Tempered hypothesis
A recent meta-analysis clearly tempers this hypothesis of a predictive varus.
Chronology
All the refractures occurred after a new trauma, once healing was established.
Plantar gap
A plantar gap of 1 mm or more markedly lengthens healing, in incomplete fractures.
Chapter 8

Rehabilitate◔ 4 min

No source describes a validated rehabilitation protocol: caution takes precedence over protocol.

Zone 1
In zone 1, weight-bearing is allowed from the outset; pain-free walking is expected at around six weeks.
Loading signal
Pain on weight-bearing at the lateral border is the signal; progression follows the bone, not the timetable.
Ankle mobility
Immobilisation costs ankle mobility and triceps surae strength.
Early work
Dorsiflexion, midfoot work and open-chain strengthening can start early, without loading the bone.
Chapter 9

Case studies◔ 2 min

The authors report three Jones fractures in sumo wrestlers.

Treatment interrupted
All three patients interrupted their treatment on their own initiative.
Outcome
The non-operated cases progressed to nonunion or delayed union; the operated case, to screw breakage.
Return to sport
Despite these complications, all three continued wrestling, with few consequences for their careers.
Chapter 10

In practice◔ 4 min

It all starts from one question: does the fracture line reach the joint between the 4th and 5th metatarsals?

Decision tree
If the line does not reach the joint, it is a zone 1 avulsion: functional treatment with weight-bearing.
Zone 1 explanation
In zone 1, the fracture heals well, even when displaced, and can be walked on.
Zone 2 explanation
In zone 2, the fracture heals more slowly, sometimes not at all.
Common error
Labelling “ankle sprain” without palpating the base of the 5th delays the diagnosis.
Chapter 11

FAQ◔ 3 min

Every Jones fracture is a fracture of the base of the 5th metatarsal, but the reverse is not true.

Strict zone 2
Only zone 2 is a Jones fracture in the strict sense of the term.
Common confusion
The confusion is frequent: all three zones sit within a few centimetres of the same bone.
Vascular crossroads
Zone 2 heals poorly because it is a vascular crossroads, not a simple question of site.
12

Train on this

On-siteDPCFIFPL

Sports physiotherapy

From injury to return to play: structure every stage of reconditioning

Maxence Ponthus

Next comes practice: the course that teaches this topic, with Maxence Ponthus.

Our courses on this topic may be covered by DPC or FIFPL, the French continuing-education funding schemes, depending on your profession and situation.

Posted by

Anthony BAILLON

Physiotherapist


Two fractures a few millimetres apart, on the same bone, after the same misstep. One heals on its own in six weeks and calls for little more than a rigid shoe. The other lies in a zone where two vascular networks meet without overlapping, fails to heal in nearly three cases in ten without surgery, and refractures one time in ten even when operated on. Telling them apart on the radiograph is the central task of this article.

A synthesis written from primary sources verified one by one on PubMed: identifier resolved, journal, year and author list checked, abstract read before citation. Full bibliography at the end of the article.

The Jones fracture in three figures

Three independent studies that explain why this fracture is not an ankle sprain that turned out badly

Three key figures for the Jones fracture Union rate of 71.4 per cent without surgery versus 97.3 per cent after intramedullary screw fixation; odds ratio for nonunion of 5.74 with non-operative treatment; refracture rate of 10.2 per cent despite surgery. 71 % / 97 % union rate without surgery versus screw fixation, in athletes ATTIA 2021 OR 5.74 for nonunion without surgery 95% CI 2.65 to 12.40 YATES 2015 10.2 % of refractures despite surgery: the bone stays fragile afterwards ATTIA 2021

Sources: Attia AK et al., Am J Sports Med 2021, meta-analysis of 22 studies and 646 Jones fractures in athletes (PMID 33740393); Yates J et al., Foot (Edinb) 2015, meta-analysis of 6 studies and 237 patients (PMID 26481787). These figures concern athletic populations: they cannot be transposed as they stand to the sedentary patient.

Clinical summary

What to keep in mind

  • Everything hinges on a few millimetres. The Lawrence and Botte classification divides the base of the fifth metatarsal into three zones: avulsion of the tuberosity (zone 1), the metaphyseal-diaphyseal junction extending to the joint between the 4th and 5th metatarsals (zone 2, the true Jones fracture), and the proximal diaphysis (zone 3)12.
  • Zone 2 is a vascular crossroads, and this is demonstrated anatomically. In ten injected cadaveric specimens, Smith showed that the arterial supply of the tuberosity meets that of the proximal diaphysis exactly in the region of poor prognosis: a relative vascular deficit that explains delayed union and nonunion3.
  • Zone 1 is benign, and its abundance feeds the confusion. Avulsions of the tuberosity heal well with functional treatment, even when they are comminuted, displaced or intra-articular4. Mistaking a zone 2 for a zone 1 amounts to treating by walking a fracture that, without surgery, fails to heal in nearly three cases in ten.
  • In athletes, upfront surgery is justified. Attia's meta-analysis measures union of 97.3% after screw fixation versus 71.4% without, a return to sport of 98.8% versus 71.6%, and a time to return of 9.6 versus 13.1 weeks5. In the review attached to the IFASC 2025 expert consensus, all athletes with a traumatic fracture return to sport, faster after surgery and with fewer failures than with conservative treatment28.
  • But not everyone is a high-level athlete, and a serious systematic review challenges the three-zone reading: Polzer argues that zone 2 fractures heal well with functional treatment, and that the real problem is zone 34. This tension is set out as it stands in the corresponding chapter.
  • Failure does not stop at healing. The refracture rate reaches 10.2% after surgery5, and 13 of the 18 refractures in a series of 168 stress fractures in athletes occurred within the six months after the start of rehabilitation11. The timetable for resumption is therefore a clinical subject in its own right.

Three red flags in lateral foot border pain

  • Prodromal pain for several weeks before the “fracture” : this is not an acute fracture but a decompensated stress fracture, whose healing prognosis is worse and which requires a search for an energy or vitamin deficiency10.
  • Pain that persists beyond three months with a fracture line still visible: delayed union, not to be left to progress to established nonunion6.
  • Return to sport before radiological healing : this is the situation that produces refractures, and a systematic review explicitly advises against it6.

At the base of the fifth metatarsal, prognosis is read not from the appearance of the fracture line but from its position. A few millimetres separate a fracture that is treated in a shoe from one that is screwed.

Exactly where does the fracture line run, and why does that decide everything?

Anteroposterior and lateral X-rays of the foot: transverse Jones fracture, about 2 cm distal to the base of the fifth metatarsal, arrows on the fracture line.

X-rayAnteroposterior and lateral X-rays of the foot: transverse Jones fracture, about 2 cm distal to the base of the fifth metatarsal, arrows on the fracture line.

Source : Wong et al., International journal of emergency medicine, 2015, figure 6 · CC BY

The classification is not an academic exercise here: it is the only thing that distinguishes two opposing forms of management.

The three zones of Lawrence and Botte

The most widely accepted classification is that of Lawrence and Botte, which divides the proximal portion of the fifth metatarsal according to the location of the fracture line, and not according to its appearance. Bušková et al., in their critical review published in JBJS Reviews, recall that it was indeed healing potential that guided this division1 :

  • Zone 1: avulsion of the tuberosity. The fracture line involves the tuberosity (styloid), at the proximal end of the bone. Healing is usually excellent, and non-operative treatment is usually recommended1.
  • Zone 2: metaphyseal-diaphyseal junction. This is the Jones fracture proper. The fracture line lies at the junction between metaphysis and diaphysis and extends as far as the joint between the fourth and fifth metatarsals2. This is the zone of the vascular problem.
  • Zone 3: proximal diaphysis. Downstream of the intermetatarsal joint. This is the favoured site of stress fractures and, according to Polzer, the zone in which treatment failure is best documented4.

The three zones of the base of the fifth metatarsal

The decisive landmark is the joint between the fourth and fifth metatarsals: zone 2 extends as far as it, zone 3 lies beyond

Diagram of the three zones of the base of the fifth metatarsal Dorsal view of the base of the fifth metatarsal. Zone 1 corresponds to the tuberosity, where the peroneus brevis and the lateral band of the plantar fascia insert, and it heals well. Zone 2, at the metaphyseal-diaphyseal junction, extends as far as the joint between the fourth and fifth metatarsals: this is the Jones fracture, at high risk of nonunion. Zone 3 is the proximal diaphysis, the site of stress fractures. Dorsal view: right foot, lateral border width of zone 2 4th-5th metatarsal joint the landmark that separates zone 2 from zone 3 peroneus brevis and lateral plantar fascia ZONE 1 avulsion: heals well ZONE 2 Jones: nonunion ZONE 3 diaphysis: stress fractures towards the forefoot

Diagram constructed from the description of the Lawrence and Botte classification given by Bušková K, Bartoníček J, Rammelt S, JBJS Rev 2021 (PMID 34673663) and Cheung CN, Lui TH, Arch Trauma Res 2016 (PMID 28144601). The insertions of the peroneus brevis and of the lateral band of the plantar fascia are shown after the anatomical study by DeVries JG et al. on 10 cadaveric specimens, J Foot Ankle Surg 2015 (PMID 25441854). The proportions are schematic and are not a measurement template.

The tendon insertions, and what they say about the mechanism

The anatomical study by DeVries et al., carried out on ten frozen cadaveric specimens, precisely measured the insertions within the proximal 1.5 cm of the bone. From it they derive a subdivision into three zones, A, B and C, whose value is to link each site to a mechanism :

  • Zone A, the most proximal: it is the lateral band of the plantar fascia that inserts there, at 6.6 ± 2.2 mm from the inferior border. The authors propose that fractures at this site result from traction by this fascia, and can be treated by immobilisation with weight-bearing.
  • Zone B : this is the peroneus brevis, inserted 12.0 ± 2.2 mm from the inferior border. The authors see here fractures caused by traumatic tension of the tendon, justifying strict immobilisation without weight-bearing, or even fixation.
  • Zone C : the articular portion with the cuboid14.

This mechanism-based reading sheds light on an everyday clinical observation: the fracture most often occurs on a foot in forced inversion, a movement that simultaneously tensions the peroneus brevis, which opposes inversion, and the lateral plantar fascia. It is the same movement that produces the lateral ankle sprain, which is why the two injuries are so often confused in practice.

Key points

  • The decisive anatomical landmark is the joint between the 4th and 5th metatarsals : zone 2 extends as far as it, zone 3 lies downstream2.
  • Zone 1: avulsion of the tuberosity, good prognosis. Zone 2: the true Jones fracture, poor vascular prognosis. Zone 3: diaphysis, site of stress fractures1.
  • The usual mechanism, forced inversion, is that of the lateral ankle sprain : it is the main source of missed diagnoses.

Why does zone 2 heal so poorly?

It is one of the rare times in foot trauma that an anatomical explanation was demonstrated experimentally before being invoked clinically.

Smith's study, and exactly what it establishes

The founding work is that of Smith, Arnoczky and Hersh, published in 1992 in Foot & Ankle. Ten cadaveric specimens, either fresh or from amputations, were studied after arterial injection of India ink or barium sulphate. The result comes down to three observations, which should be read in order3 :

  1. The tuberosity receives its blood from numerous metaphyseal vessels that penetrate the non-articular surfaces in a radial and random arrangement. This is a rich, redundant network.
  2. The proximal diaphysis is vascularised mainly by the nutrient artery, which gives off longitudinal intramedullary branches. This is a single network, in series.
  3. The two supplies meet in the region just downstream of the tuberosity, and this region corresponds exactly to the one with a poor healing prognosis.

The authors conclude that a relative vascular deficit following a proximal diaphyseal fracture may contribute to delayed union and nonunion. The term is not in their abstract, but it is the very definition of a watershed zone: a territory served by the ends of two networks, where each is at the limit of its reach.

The vascular watershed of the base of the fifth metatarsal

Two networks, one junction, and a fracture line that falls precisely on it

Intraosseous vascularisation of the base of the fifth metatarsal The tuberosity receives numerous metaphyseal vessels arranged in a fan. The proximal diaphysis is vascularised by a single nutrient artery giving off longitudinal branches. The two territories meet just downstream of the tuberosity, at the exact spot where the Jones fracture lies. Metaphyseal network numerous vessels, fan-shaped, redundant: the tuberosity heals Nutrient artery single supply, longitudinal branches: no back-up route if the fracture line cuts it ZONE 2 where the two networks meet “the region of poor prognosis”

Constructed from Smith JW, Arnoczky SP, Hersh A. The intraosseous blood supply of the fifth metatarsal: implications for proximal fracture healing. Foot Ankle 1992;13(3):143-52 (PMID 1601342), study on 10 cadaveric specimens after arterial injection. The diagram illustrates the authors' description; it does not reproduce a plate from their article.

What this explanation does not explain

It would be convenient to stop the reasoning here. Honesty obliges us to point out that the vascular argument has never been directly linked to a measured nonunion rate : Smith describes an anatomy, the clinic observes failures, and the correspondence between the two remains a hypothesis, solid and coherent, but untested as such.

This matters all the more because the systematic review by Polzer et al. challenges, on prospective data, the clinical description usually drawn from this anatomy. We come to it in the treatment chapter.

Key points

  • The tuberosity has a network that is rich and redundant ; the proximal diaphysis depends on a single nutrient artery3.
  • The two territories meet just downstream of the tuberosity, in the region of poor prognosis3.
  • It is an anatomical explanation that is demonstrated, but whose causal link with failure rates remains a hypothesis.

Who fractures the base of the fifth metatarsal, and how?

Two very different populations share the same bone: the woman over forty who twists her foot, and the pivoting athlete.

Four figures that place fifth metatarsal fractures in context

Data from two population series and a critical review

Four epidemiological statistics for fifth metatarsal fractures Proximal fractures of the fifth metatarsal represent 61 to 78 per cent of all foot fractures. The fifth metatarsal is the most frequently fractured metatarsal. Women sustain 75 per cent of zone 1 injuries. The dancer's fracture represents 25 per cent of fifth metatarsal fractures, 80 per cent of them in women. 61-78 % of all foot fractures for proximal 5th MT fractures only #1 the most frequently fractured metatarsal of 411 metatarsal fractures, mean age 42 years 75 % of zone 1 injuries in women of 1,275 fractures; torsion = predictor of zone 1 25 % of dancer's fractures 80% women, 80% over 40

Sources: Bušková K et al., JBJS Rev 2021, for the proportion of foot fractures (PMID 34673663), Petrisor BA, Ekrol I, Court-Brown C, Foot Ankle Int 2006, 411 metatarsal fractures (PMID 16539897), Kane JM et al., Foot Ankle Spec 2015, 1,275 fractures of the 5th metatarsal (PMID 25666689); Schwagten K et al., Foot Ankle Surg 2021 (PMID 33229215).

The mechanism predicts the zone

A preliminary point: among 411 metatarsal fractures recorded over one year in a Scottish series, with a mean age of 42 years, the fifth metatarsal is the most frequently fractured of all, with a growing proportion of women in the older age bands20. This is the bone we see, and it is at its base that the prognostic distinction is decided.

The series by Kane et al., which reviewed 1,275 fractures of the fifth metatarsal in a multicentre orthopaedic practice, provides a result directly usable in consultation: the mechanism of injury predicts the location. Torsional injuries are a statistically significant predictor of zone 1 injuries. Women sustain 75% of zone 1 injuries and 84% of dancer's fractures. In young patients, men predominate; in older patients, women do19.

This age-related shift is not trivial. Schwagten et al., who specifically studied the dancer's fracture (a spiral fracture of the distal diaphysis, distinct from the three proximal zones) found that in the over-40 group, all the patients had a low-energy mechanism, against only 27% of those under 40. They draw a strong clinical conclusion: treat this fracture as a fragility fracture17.

A low-energy fracture of the 5th metatarsal after 50 is a skeletal signal

A trivial twist that breaks a bone in a patient over fifty warrants questioning bone quality, as for any fragility fracture. This reasoning is developed in our article on osteoporosis and the prevention of fragility fractures. The physiotherapist who sees the patient for the return to weight-bearing is often the first clinician to have the time needed to ask the question.

The athlete, the other population

The true Jones fracture, that of zone 2, preferentially affects the pivoting athlete: football, basketball, American football. Attia's meta-analysis, which includes only studies of exclusively athletic populations, gathered 646 Jones fractures from 22 studies, with return-to-sport rates detailed by discipline: 99.0% in American football, 96.6% in football, 91.1% in basketball5.

This gap between disciplines, modest but consistent, outlines the logic of the injury: basketball, with its pivoting on a foot fixed to the ground and its jump landings, loads the lateral border of the foot more severely than running in a straight line.

Key points

  • Proximal fractures of the 5th metatarsal represent 61 to 78% of foot fractures1.
  • The mechanism predicts the zone : torsion points towards zone 1, which is benign19.
  • After the age of 40, a low-energy fracture of the 5th metatarsal should be treated as a fragility fracture17.

How to tell a zone 1 avulsion from a true Jones fracture?

This is the central point of this article. The two fractures look alike on a poorly read radiograph, and the appropriate management differs completely.

The question to ask in front of the radiograph

A single question settles it: does the fracture line extend as far as the joint between the fourth and fifth metatarsals? If so, it is a zone 2: a Jones fracture. If the line stays upstream, confined to the tuberosity, it is a zone 12.

Two errors are made in opposite directions, and both need to be named:

  • Mistaking a zone 2 for a zone 1 : the serious error. The patient goes home in a rigid shoe with permission to walk, for a fracture that, in athletes, fails to heal without surgery in nearly three cases in ten5.
  • Mistaking a zone 1 for a zone 2 : the costly error. The patient is immobilised without weight-bearing, return is delayed, and surgery is proposed for a fracture that would have healed on its own4.
Elements for telling the three zones apart. The failure rates come from the series cited and concern different populations, which rules out comparing them term for term.
CriterionZone 1: avulsionZone 2: Jones fractureZone 3: diaphyseal
Site of the fracture lineTuberosity (styloid)Metaphyseal-diaphyseal junction, extends to the 4th-5th jointProximal diaphysis, beyond the joint
Dominant mechanismTorsion, inversion: statistical predictor19Adduction load on a fixed forefootRepeated stress: stress fracture
Typical patient75% women19, all agesPivoting athlete, young manEndurance or high-load athlete
Prodromal painAbsentSometimesFrequent, suggestive
Prognosis without surgeryExcellent, even if displaced or articular4Union 71.4% in athletes5 ; 76% in systematic review6The worst: significantly higher failure without surgery4
Usual managementFunctional treatment, weight-bearing allowed4Functional possible; upfront screw fixation in athletes15Early screw fixation recommended4

Radiographic look-alikes

Three images can be mistaken for a fracture, and a fourth for a zone 1 when it is something else:

The os vesalianum

This is an accessory ossicle located at the lateral border of the foot, in the immediate vicinity of the base of the fifth metatarsal. The most recent meta-analysis of it, covering 21,312 feet from 22 studies, puts the pooled prevalence at 0.6 % (95% CI 0.4-0.9), with a comparable distribution between the sexes and a prevalence of 0.6% on radiographic examinations. The authors explicitly conclude that it must be differentiated from fractures of the fifth metatarsal and from Iselin's disease15.

What distinguishes it: regular, corticated margins, a constant position, and above all, when doubt persists, its usual presence on the contralateral foot, which a comparison radiograph reveals.

Iselin's apophysis in children and adolescents

In adolescents, the secondary ossification centre of the tuberosity appears on the radiograph as a separate fragment. It is oriented parallel to the axis of the metatarsal, whereas a zone 1 fracture line is usually transverse, that is, perpendicular to this axis. This difference in orientation is the simplest criterion for reading it. The subject is developed in our article on growth-related conditions of the lower limb in children and adolescents.

The dancer's fracture

This is not an interpretation trap but a neighbouring entity, often confused with it in everyday language. It is an oblique spiral fracture of the distal diaphysis, therefore much further downstream than the three proximal zones. O'Malley, Hamilton and Munyak described the original series, in 35 dancers from two national ballet companies: the fracture line starts distal-lateral and runs proximal-medial. Treatment was mostly non-operative, including for displaced fractures, with pain-free walking at 6.1 weeks on average, a return to the barre at 11.6 weeks and a return to performance at 19 weeks. All the dancers resumed their professional activity without limitation18.

The distinction matters because the prognosis is the opposite of that of zone 2: the dancer's fracture is a fracture with a good prognosis, whatever its displacement.

The error that costs the most

Pain on the lateral border of the foot after an inversion is labelled “ankle sprain” in a large number of cases. The mechanism is the same, the pain is sometimes in the same place, and the examination concentrates on the anterior talofibular ligament. Palpation of the base of the fifth metatarsal is part of the Ottawa rules for the foot, and it is precisely by this route that the clinical case published in the JOSPT led a physiotherapist in direct access to request imaging that revealed a fracture27. Our article on lateral ankle sprain sets out this approach.

Key points

  • The question that settles it: does the fracture line reach the joint between the 4th and 5th metatarsals?2
  • Os vesalianum: 0.6% of feet, corticated margins, often bilateral15.
  • In adolescents, the apophysis is parallel to the axis of the bone; a zone 1 fracture is transverse.
  • The dancer's fracture is distal diaphyseal and has a good prognosis, even when displaced18.

Acute fracture or stress fracture: what does the distinction change?

Two different clinical histories can produce the same image, and they do not call for the same strategy.

Two entities that coexist on the same bone

The classic Jones fracture is acute: a weight-bearing step, immediate pain, loss of function. The stress fracture of the fifth metatarsal is something else entirely: prodromal pain on the lateral border of the foot, growing over weeks, which ends up completing, sometimes abruptly, on an ordinary step that gives the illusion of a trauma.

This is the distinction made by Polzer: zone 3 fractures are explicitly described as “diaphyseal stress fractures”, at the distal limit of the intermetatarsal joint or just downstream, and it is they that show a significantly higher failure rate when treated without surgery in a non-weight-bearing boot4.

In elite athletes, an expert consensus (IFASC 2025, level of evidence V) unanimously chooses MRI for an undisplaced fracture and CT for a comminuted or displaced fracture28.

Our article devoted to stress fracture in the athlete covers the general mechanism, the imbalance between microdamage and bone repair under cyclic loading, imaging and relative energy deficiency. The present article does not repeat it : it deals with one particular site, where acute fracture and stress fracture coexist and merge, and where the site of the fracture line governs the prognosis more than the mechanism does.

What the history should look for

The question to ask is simple and rarely asked: “Did you have pain at this spot before?” A positive answer changes three things:

  • The healing prognosis : a bone already in distress, with a periosteal reaction or sclerosis of the fracture line, heals less well than a healthy bone with a clean fracture.
  • Looking for a systemic cause. The case-control study by Shimasaki et al., of 37 athletes of whom 18 had a history of stress fracture of the fifth metatarsal in zone 2 or 3, measured a striking association: a serum 25-hydroxyvitamin D level below 30 ng/mL multiplies by 23.3 the odds of stress fracture of the 5th metatarsal, after adjustment for multiple confounding factors. A level of 10 ng/mL corresponded to odds 5.1 times higher, and 20 ng/mL to 2.9 times10.
  • Training load, which must be reconstructed over the preceding weeks, exactly as for any bone overload injury.

Reading the odds ratio of 23.3 with caution

This is a case-control study of 37 athletes in total, with level of evidence III. An odds ratio of this size in so small a sample necessarily has a wide confidence interval, and the association measured does not establish causality: an athlete with an energy deficit readily accumulates vitamin D deficiency, excessive load and low bone density. What the result justifies: measuring vitamin D in the face of a stress fracture of the fifth metatarsal. What it does not justify: promising that supplementation will prevent recurrence.

Key points

  • Any prodromal pain turns the diagnosis of acute fracture into that of decompensated stress fracture, with a more guarded prognosis4.
  • A 25-OHD level below 30 ng/mL is associated with odds of stress fracture of the 5th MT multiplied by 23.3, in a sample of 37 athletes10.
  • The general mechanism of stress fractures is covered in the dedicated article ; here, it is the site that governs.

Should one operate upfront, and on whom?

This is the question on which the literature frankly contradicts itself, and where the contradiction is itself instructive.

The dominant position: operate on the athlete

Three studies converge, with different methodologies. The state-of-the-art review published in the Journal of the American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons summarises the current position: the Jones fracture, located at the metaphyseal-diaphyseal junction, is exposed to an increased risk of nonunion and persistent pain, and delayed union as well as refracture may occur despite excellent surgical technique and postoperative care16.

Attia 2021, American Journal of Sports Medicine. Meta-analysis conducted according to PRISMA, 22 eligible studies, 646 Jones fractures exclusively in athletes. The results:

  • Overall return to sport 98.4 % (95% CI 97.3-99.4); 98.8% after intramedullary screw fixation versus 71.6% with non-operative treatment (95% CI 45.6-97.6, a very wide interval).
  • Three studies compared the two strategies directly: significant superiority of surgery (odds ratio 0.033; 95% CI 0.005-0.215; p < 0.001).
  • Time to return to sport 9.6 weeks after screw fixation versus 13.1 weeks without surgery.
  • Union rate 97.3 % with surgery versus 71.4 % without surgery.
  • Delayed union 2.5%, refracture 10.2%.

Balboni 2026, IFASC 2025 consensus. An expert committee (International Foot and Ankle Sports Consensus, Delphi method, level of evidence V) formulated 37 statements on the Jones fracture in the elite athlete. Its attached systematic review (27 studies, 1,056 patients, traumatic and stress fractures combined) reports that the athletes with a traumatic fracture in the included studies all returned to sport, at 11.6 ± 2.2 weeks on average whatever the treatment; treatment failure is most frequent there with conservative treatment (16.1% of traumatic fractures, 8.2% of stress fractures), and return to sport is faster after surgery, whatever the origin of the fracture28. Set against these figures, Attia's 71.6%, drawn from few non-operative studies (95% CI 45.6-97.6), should be read with caution as a prognosis without surgery5.

The authors recommend surgical fixation for all Jones fractures in athletes5.

Roche and Calder 2013, KSSTA. Systematic review of 26 studies, 22 of them level 4 and only one randomised trial. Union of acute fractures: 76% non-operatively, 96% after screw fixation. For delayed unions: 44% versus 97%. For nonunions fixed with a screw: 97%. Return to sport after screw fixation of an acute fracture: 4 to 18 weeks. The authors explicitly advise against resumption before complete radiological healing, because of the risk of refracture6.

Yates 2015, The Foot. Meta-analysis of 6 studies and 237 patients: the non-operative group had a significantly higher odds of nonunion, OR 5.74 (95% CI 2.65-12.40; p < 0.001), with a prolonged time to union and to return to sport7.

The dissenting position, and why it should be read

Polzer et al. published in Injury a systematic review whose conclusion directly contradicts the three-zone reading. Their method is explicit: to retain only prospective trials comparing either the same treatment for different fractures, or different treatments for the same fracture. Six prospective trials met this criterion. Their conclusions4 :

  • All avulsions of the tuberosity (zone 1) heal well with functional treatment, including multifragmentary, displaced and articular ones. The plaster cast boot significantly delays return to the previous level compared with functional treatment.
  • Jones fractures (zone 2) also give good to excellent results and complete union with functional treatment.
  • By contrast, the diaphyseal stress fractures (zone 3) show a significantly higher failure rate with non-operative treatment; early intramedullary screw fixation significantly shortens the time to union and to return to sport.

The authors therefore propose to reduce the classification to two entities : metaphyseal fractures not extending beyond the distal end of the intermetatarsal joint, to be treated functionally whatever the number of fragments, the displacement and the articular involvement; and meta-diaphyseal fractures located at that limit or just downstream, which require early screw fixation.

How to hold the two together without choosing a side

The contradiction is less radical than it looks, and it is resolved by the population and by the outcome measure.

Attia speaks only of athletes, and its main outcome is return to sport and its timing. Polzer speaks of the general population treated in prospective trials, and its outcome is union. A sedentary patient who heals in fourteen weeks instead of nine has been well treated; a professional footballer in the same situation has missed half a season, with, in Attia's meta-analysis, a probability of return to play lower by twenty-seven points, a very imprecise estimate that the review of the IFASC consensus does not find for traumatic fractures.

A second factor separates them: surgical series often involve fractures that are complete and displaced, whereas prospective trials of functional treatment readily include incomplete fracture lines. It is not the same fracture.

Outside sport, a single-centre retrospective cohort (Kingery 2024, level III) of 121 so-called true Jones fractures, defined as lying downstream of the joint between the fourth and fifth metatarsals (zone 3 in this article), in adults with a mean age of 46 years, reports 96% union with or without surgery and comparable times; the surgical indications there were not randomised, and this result, discordant with Wang's meta-analysis, comes from a population not selected on sport: it does not allow a conclusion for the athlete29.

The honest reading is therefore not “Attia is right and Polzer is wrong”, but: the more demanding the time requirement, the more surgery is justified; the more distal the fracture line, the more it is needed whatever the patient.

Union and return to sport, surgery versus non-operative treatment

Figures from two syntheses of athletic populations, not transposable to the sedentary patient

Comparison of results between surgery and non-operative treatment The union rate reaches 97.3 per cent after screw fixation versus 71.4 per cent without surgery. The return-to-sport rate reaches 98.8 per cent versus 71.6 per cent. The time to return to sport is 9.6 weeks versus 13.1 weeks. The refracture rate after surgery remains 10.2 per cent. Union rate Screw fixation 97.3 % Non-operated 71.4 % Return-to-sport rate Screw fixation 98.8 % Non-operated 71.6 % 95% CI 45.6-97.6: very wide interval, few non-operative studies Time to return to sport, in weeks Screw fixation 9.6 wk Non-operated 13.1 wk What surgery does not settle: 10.2% of refractures, and 2.5% of delayed unions.

Source: Attia AK, Taha T, Kong G, Alhammoud A, Mahmoud K, Myerson M. Am J Sports Med 2021;49(12):3422-3436, meta-analysis of 22 studies and 646 Jones fractures in athletes (PMID 33740393). Exclusively athletic population: these values do not apply to the sedentary patient, in whom the Polzer 2012 review finds good results with functional treatment (PMID 22465516).

A fourth synthesis, not restricted to athletes, points in the same direction without having the same strength: Wang's meta-analysis, of 11 articles and 404 participants with a mean age of 29.8 years, finds a favourable effect of surgery, of medium to large size, on the nonunion rate, the time to union and the time to resumption of activity22. Its interest is that it concerns a less selected population; its limitation is that it mixes zones.

Zone 1: the case where surgery changes little

The comparison by Valkier et al. covers 51 feet with an avulsion fracture, 31 treated without surgery and 20 operated on. An unexpected and instructive result: 11 of the 31 non-operated patients (35.5%) developed a nonunion, against none of those operated on (p = 0.004). But (and this is the second half of the sentence, which is often forgotten when citing), all the patients were asymptomatic at one year, whichever the group. The authors recommend surgery for avulsions displaced by more than 2 mm, and insist on realistic expectations13.

This is a useful reminder: a radiological nonunion is not a clinical nonunion. On the tuberosity, a fragment that never fuses can remain perfectly painless. A Chinese randomised trial of 46 young patients or athletes with an avulsion displaced by 2 to 3 mm points the same way: the functional score was better at 6 months in the operated group, but no difference any longer at 12 months ; only the time to full weight-bearing and to return to work was significantly shortened by surgery25.

Treatment strategies and level of evidence

An appraisal of the level of evidence following the GRADE principles, from the sources cited in this chapter

Moderate

Upfront intramedullary screw fixation for a zone 2 fracture in athletes : union, return-to-sport rate and time all superior, across 646 fractures and 22 studies, with three concordant direct comparisons5, corroborated by two other syntheses67.

Moderate

Functional treatment of zone 1 avulsions, including displaced and articular ones : six concordant prospective trials; the plaster cast boot significantly delays return to the previous level4.

Low

Early screw fixation of zone 3 stress fractures : significantly higher non-operative failure rate, shortened time to union and to resumption, from few prospective trials4.

Low

Lateral offloading insole after a zone 2 fracture with hindfoot varus : 100% union and no refracture in a series of 21 fractures, but without a control group8.

Very low

Very early resumption after screw fixation, before radiological healing : series of 26 fractures in 25 university athletes, mean resumption at 3.6 weeks without major complication23, but a systematic review explicitly advises against this practice6.

Not supported

Treating a zone 2 as a zone 1 : that is, allowing free weight-bearing without monitoring of healing. No source consulted supports this approach, which stems from a misreading, not from a therapeutic choice.

Assessment constructed according to GRADE principles from the sources cited, and not taken from a published GRADE evaluation: none of the reviews consulted produced a formal GRADE table on this question.

Key points

  • In athletes, screw fixation gives 97.3% union versus 71.4%, and a return to sport 3.5 weeks earlier5.
  • Polzer challenges the three-zone reading : according to prospective trials, zone 2 heals well with functional treatment, and it is zone 3 that fails4.
  • The contradiction is resolved by the population and the outcome : healing is not playing again.
  • In zone 1, radiological nonunion reaches 35.5% without surgery, and all the patients are asymptomatic at one year13.

Which factors predict nonunion and refracture?

Three families of factors, two of which can be corrected, and this is where the physiotherapist has a hold.

Foot axis: an attractive hypothesis, half confirmed

Raikin, Slenker and Ratigan measured hindfoot alignment in 20 patients operated on for a Jones fracture. The result is clear: 18 of the 21 hindfeet were in radiographic varus, and a clinical varus was present in 16 cases. The mean calcaneal pitch angle was 28.5° and the Meary angle 13° with superior convexity. All the patients healed and none refractured, with a mean follow-up of 49 months: the patients in varus having been fitted postoperatively with a lateral offloading insole for the hindfoot and forefoot8.

The authors' hypothesis is mechanically clear: a varus hindfoot overloads the lateral column of the foot, predisposes to the fracture, and predisposes to treatment failure.

A recent meta-analysis seriously tempers this reading. Riegger et al. pooled eight studies (296 patients), five of them in quantitative synthesis (132 patients), to compare three angles between fractured patients and controls. Result: only the adduction angle of the midfoot emerges, with a pooled mean difference of 4.62° (95% CI 1.31-7.92) and substantial heterogeneity (I² = 76.1%). Neither the calcaneal pitch nor the Meary angle differs significantly. In other words: midfoot adductus seems correlated with risk, but the relationship with hindfoot varus and pes cavus has not been demonstrated9.

Two retrospective studies from the same team, on weight-bearing CT and with small samples (level III), specify the target. Hindfoot varus and adductus do not distinguish zone 1 and 2 fractures from controls, but are associated with zone 3 fractures and with fractures of non-traumatic origin (Grün 2025: 45 fractures and 19 controls; Lintz 2026: 15 stress fractures and 15 controls). These are associations with the occurrence of the fracture, not with its healing, and no insole was tested in them: a factor to monitor, not an established target3031.

Factors associated with fracture, nonunion and refracture

Each factor is placed according to the strength of the evidence that supports it, and not according to how often it is cited

Risk factors for fracture and for treatment failure Established in meta-analysis: midfoot adduction with a difference of 4.62 degrees. Established in comparative series: high body mass index, protrusion of the head of the fifth metatarsal and a plantar gap greater than one millimetre. Suggested but not confirmed in meta-analysis: hindfoot varus and pes cavus, associated with zone 3 fractures in two small weight-bearing CT studies. Measured in a small case-control study: vitamin D insufficiency. CONFIRMED IN META-ANALYSIS Midfoot adduction: mean difference 4.62° (95% CI 1.31-7.92) Riegger 2022, 8 studies, heterogeneity I² = 76.1%: the only angle that emerges MEASURED IN A COMPARATIVE SERIES High body mass index and protrusion of the head of the 5th metatarsal Lee 2013: 4-5 intermetatarsal angle significantly larger in the refractured (168 elite cases) Plantar gap ≥ 1 mm on an incomplete fracture Lee 2013: healing in 115.5 days versus 73.9 days if the gap is under 1 mm MEASURED IN A SMALL SAMPLE 25-OHD < 30 ng/mL: odds × 23.3 Shimasaki 2016, case-control, 37 athletes in total, level III Justifies measuring, not promising that supplementation protects. NOT CONFIRMED Hindfoot varus, pes cavus Associated with zone 3 (weight-bearing CT), seen in the Raikin 2008 series, but neither calcaneal pitch nor the angle of Meary differs in meta-analysis.

Sources: Riegger M et al., J Foot Ankle Surg 2022 (PMID 35039196); Lee KT et al., Foot Ankle Int 2013, refractures (PMID 24216284) and plantar gap (PMID 23637237); Shimasaki Y et al., Foot Ankle Int 2016 (PMID 26596794); Raikin SM et al., Am J Sports Med 2008 (PMID 18443278).

When failure has already happened: what becomes of a nonunion

The question often arises in rehabilitation, with a patient who arrives with a fracture line still visible months later. The series by Hunt and Anderson concerns 21 high-level athletes who underwent a revision for nonunion or refracture of a Jones fracture, by intramedullary screw fixation combined with an autologous cancellous bone graft or with a mixture of bone marrow aspirate and demineralised bone matrix. All returned to their previous level of competition, on average at 12.3 weeks, with complete clinical and radiographic cortical union, and only one had a further refracture. The authors recommend a large-diameter solid screw (5.5 mm or more) and an autologous graft21.

The message is useful to pass on to the anxious patient: a failure of first-line treatment is not a dead end, and revision surgery has well-documented good results.

The timetable for resumption: the most actionable factor

This is the data most directly useful to the physiotherapist, and it comes from the series by Lee et al. covering 168 stress fractures of the fifth metatarsal in high-level athletes, treated by modified tension band wiring. Eleven nonunions and eighteen refractures were recorded. The factors associated with refracture were a higher weight and two radiological parameters reflecting protrusion of the head of the fifth metatarsal (4-5 intermetatarsal angle on the anteroposterior view, lateral deviation of the 5th MT on the oblique view).

But the most telling observation is chronological: all the refractures occurred after a new trauma, once healing was established; 13 of the 18 within the six months after the start of rehabilitation, and 8 within the first three months. The authors conclude that patients with a prominent 5th metatarsal head and a high body mass index should approach rehabilitation with caution before considering a return to their previous level of sport11.

The window of vulnerability does not close at healing. It remains open during the six months after the start of rehabilitation, and this is exactly the period when the patient feels cured.

The plantar gap, a radiographic sign worth knowing

A second series from the same team, covering 86 stress fractures of the fifth metatarsal, tested a simple radiographic criterion: the presence of a plantar gap of 1 mm or more on incomplete fractures. Result: incomplete fractures with a gap ≥ 1 mm healed in 115.5 ± 45.4 days, against 73.9 ± 26.7 days for those with a smaller gap (p < 0.001). Counter-intuitively, the complete fractures healed faster (67.5 ± 28.8 days) than incomplete fractures taken as a whole (103.2 ± 47.7 days)12.

This result deserves to be known by the rehabilitator, because it contradicts intuition: faced with two radiographs, the one that looks less serious (an incomplete line, with a thin plantar line) can herald a healing time twice as long.

Key points

  • Only midfoot adductus is confirmed in meta-analysis; varus and pes cavus are not9 ; two small weight-bearing CT studies associate them with zone 3 and non-traumatic fractures, not with zones 1 and 23031.
  • 13 refractures out of 18 occur within six months of the start of rehabilitation11.
  • Any plantar gap ≥ 1 mm lengthens healing from 74 to 116 days12.
  • An incomplete fracture can heal more slowly than a complete fracture12.

What do we rehabilitate, and on what timetable for return to weight-bearing?

With this fracture, rehabilitation is not primarily analytical work: it is the management of a return to weight-bearing within a window in which the bone is not yet safe.

What the sources allow us to state, and what they do not

We must be direct: none of the sources consulted describes a validated rehabilitation protocol for the Jones fracture. The studies measure times to union, return-to-sport rates and complications; they do not compare rehabilitation programmes with one another. What follows is therefore built from three solid elements (the measured times to union, the chronology of refractures, and the predictive factors of failure) and not from a published protocol.

Weight-bearing benchmarks after a fracture of the base of the 5th metatarsal

The timings in the frames are measured in the sources cited; the session contents come from common practice

Weight-bearing timetable according to the fractured zone In zone 1, weight-bearing is allowed from the outset with functional treatment, with pain-free walking at around six weeks. In non-operated zone 2, healing takes about thirteen to fourteen weeks. In screwed zone 2 in athletes, return to sport occurs on average at 9.6 weeks. The refracture window remains open during the six months after the start of rehabilitation. S0 S6 S10 S14 6 months Zone 1: weight-bearing from the outset pain-free walking ~6 wk (dancer's fracture: 6.1 wk) Screwed zone 2: mean return to sport 9.6 wk union 8.2 wk after screw fixation Non-operated zone 2: mean return to sport 13.1 wk, union 13.7 wk Refracture window: 13 of the 18 refractures within 6 months of the start of rehabilitation Plantar gap ≥ 1 mm 115.5 days to union versus 73.9: plan a longer timetable from the outset. Operated varus hindfoot Postoperative lateral offloading insole: 100% union, no refracture at 49 months.

Timings: Attia AK et al., Am J Sports Med 2021 (PMID 33740393) for the zone 2 values; O'Malley MJ et al., Am J Sports Med 1996 (PMID 8775129) for pain-free walking at 6.1 weeks in the dancer's fracture; Lee KT et al., Foot Ankle Int 2013 (PMID 24216284 and PMID 23637237); Raikin SM et al., Am J Sports Med 2008 (PMID 18443278). The zone 2 values come from athletic populations.

The four goals of rehabilitation

1. Steering the return to weight-bearing without outpacing the bone

This is the main goal, and it is chronological before it is technical. The benchmark is simple: pain on weight-bearing at the lateral border of the foot is the signal, and progression follows healing, not the theoretical timetable. In zone 1, weight-bearing is allowed from the outset and functional treatment does better than the plaster cast boot on time to return to the previous level4. In zone 2, the question depends on the strategy chosen and must be settled with the surgeon.

2. Recovering the ankle and foot without loading the fracture site

The period of immobilisation or offloading costs ankle mobility and triceps surae strength. Analytical work on dorsiflexion, midfoot mobilisation and open-chain strengthening can begin early without stressing the lateral border. Work on the peroneal muscles, however, calls for caution: the peroneus brevis inserts on the tuberosity14, and its resisted contraction tensions the zone 1 fracture site. Our article on peroneal (fibularis) tendinopathy sets out the load progression for these muscles.

3. Correcting what can be corrected in weight-bearing

The Raikin series provides the only documented item of orthotic management: the patients with varus were fitted postoperatively with a lateral offloading insole for the hindfoot and forefoot, with 100% union and no refracture at a mean follow-up of 49 months8. It should be read for what it is: a series without a control group, in which the effect of the insole cannot be separated from that of fixation with a 4.5 mm screw. But the orthosis is inexpensive and low in risk, which makes it a reasonable option in the face of a marked clinical varus.

4. Monitoring the refracture window

This is the goal that the literature supports most directly, and paradoxically the one most often forgotten: vulnerability persists for months after healing. An athlete who has resumed and who reports discomfort on the lateral border is not an athlete who lacks warm-up: it is an athlete to be reassessed.

What should stop rehabilitation and prompt re-referral

  • Pain that persists beyond three months with a fracture line still visible: delayed union, which responds well to screw fixation (97% union) but poorly to abstention (44%)6.
  • New pain after resumption, including on a healed fracture: all the refractures in the Lee series occurred on a healed bone11.
  • Mechanical discomfort from the hardware : skin irritation over the screw head is a reported complication, having led to three removals out of 26 fractures in the Watson series23, and hardware complications are frequent enough to have prompted a call to design specific implants26.

Key points

  • No validated rehabilitation protocol exists for this fracture: the benchmarks are deduced from the times to union and the chronology of refractures.
  • The peroneus brevis inserts on the tuberosity : its resisted tensioning should be progressed cautiously in zone 114.
  • The lateral offloading insole for a varus hindfoot is the only documented orthotic measure, based on a series without a control group8.

What do concrete clinical cases teach us?

Two published observations, chosen because they show what meta-analyses cannot show: what happens when the patient does not follow the treatment, and what a physiotherapist sees in first-line practice.

Three sumo wrestlers, three interrupted treatments

Hoshino T, Tateishi T, Nagase T, Yuki A, Nakagawa T, Tsuchiya M. Jones Fractures in Sumo Wrestlers: Three Case Reports. Case Reports in Orthopedics 2019;2019:9051327 (PMID 31772802).

The authors report three Jones fractures in sumo wrestlers. All three patients interrupted their treatment on their own initiative24. The two cases treated without surgery progressed to nonunion or delayed union; the operated case had a screw breakage. And yet, all three continued wrestling, with few consequences for their careers.

The authors identify the risk factors specific to this discipline: high body weight, and the training and competition characteristics specific to sumo. Above all, they explain why adherence is so difficult there: taking rest means losing rank, which makes it almost impossible to see out a sufficient duration of treatment.

What the case teaches. Three things, in order. First, weight is a load factor on the lateral column, as the Lee series on refractures confirms11. Second, a nonunion does not necessarily rule out practice, which should make us cautious about catastrophising prognoses. Finally and above all, the best treatment is the one the patient can follow : the authors conclude that it is essential to inform these athletes fully of the options and to decide with each one. For the physiotherapist, who sees the patient far more often than the surgeon does, this is where adherence is decided.

A 17-year-old tennis player, intermittent lateral pain, direct access

Bittner JS, Hartstein AJ. Fifth Metatarsal Avulsion Fracture in an Adolescent Tennis Player. Journal of Orthopaedic & Sports Physical Therapy 2019;49(8):620 (PMID 31366295).

A 17-year-old tennis player presents to physiotherapy through direct access, with intermittent pain on the lateral border of the left foot. Faced with positive fracture tests and applying the Ottawa rules for the foot and ankle, the physiotherapist requests an orthopaedic opinion and imaging. The radiographs reveal an undisplaced avulsion fracture of the fifth metatarsal.

What the case teaches. This is the most direct illustration of the physiotherapist's role on this subject, and it comes down to a decision rule: palpation of the base of the fifth metatarsal is part of the Ottawa rules, and exquisite pain at this level after a foot trauma justifies imaging. Intermittent pain, in an adolescent, without marked functional loss, is exactly the picture that does not suggest a fracture, and it is the picture of the published case.

Why these cases and not others

Clinical cases are the classic weak point of synthesis articles: the narrative that is too tidy, the athlete cured in eight sessions. The two observations above are published and indexed reports, cited with their PubMed identifier. They were chosen because one documents a real therapeutic failure, three patients who abandon treatment, and the other a diagnostic approach carried out by a physiotherapist. No case in this chapter was composed for the needs of the demonstration.

How do you apply all this from Monday morning?

What the reading of the sources changes in practice, for the patient who arrives with a painful foot and a radiograph in their file.

The decision tree, starting from the radiograph

Management of a fracture of the base of the fifth metatarsal

The first question concerns the site of the fracture line; the second, the patient's requirements

Decision tree for a fracture of the base of the fifth metatarsal First question: does the fracture line reach the joint between the fourth and fifth metatarsals. If not, it is a zone 1 avulsion suited to functional treatment with weight-bearing. If so, it is a zone 2 or 3. Second question: is the patient an athlete, or is the fracture line in zone 3. If so, discuss upfront intramedullary screw fixation. If not, functional treatment is possible with monitoring of healing. Fracture of the base of the 5th metatarsal Does the fracture line reach the 4th-5th joint? first rule out os vesalianum and Iselin's apophysis no ZONE 1: avulsion Functional treatment, weight-bearing allowed, even if displaced or articular yes ZONE 2 or 3: Jones fracture look for prodromal pain: stress or acute? Athlete, time-critical demands, or fracture line in zone 3? this is where the surgical indication is decided yes Upfront screw fixation Union 97.3%, return to sport 98.8% at 9.6 wk 10.2% refractures no Functional possible Good results in prospective trials (Polzer), but healing to be monitored IN ALL CASES Prodromal pain: measure vitamin D Clinical varus: lateral offloading insole

Tree constructed from the Lawrence and Botte classification as reported by Bušková 2021 (PMID 34673663) and Cheung 2016 (PMID 28144601), the conclusions of Polzer 2012 (PMID 22465516) and the figures of Attia 2021 (PMID 33740393). It reproduces no recommendation from a scientific society; there is only an expert consensus of surgeons limited to the elite athlete (IFASC 2025, level of evidence V, Balboni 2026, PMID 41451757).

What to say to the patient, and in what words

  • When it is a zone 1. “Your fracture involves the most proximal part of the bone, the part with the best blood supply. It heals well, even when the fragment is displaced, and you can walk on it.” It is useful to add that the fragment may never fuse on the radiograph without this being a problem: in one series, 35.5% of non-operated patients had a radiological nonunion and all were asymptomatic at one year13. This avoids anxiety at the follow-up.
  • When it is a zone 2. “Your fracture lies a few millimetres from the previous one, but in a zone where two blood networks meet without overlapping. This is what explains why it heals more slowly, and sometimes not at all.” The image of the vascular crossroads works well in consultation, and it is accurate3.
  • On resumption. “Healing does not mean being solid. Refractures occur after healing, and the majority within the six months after the start of rehabilitation11.” This is the most important message to get across, and the least spontaneously accepted.

Five costly errors

Common errors at the base of the fifth metatarsal and their consequence, with the source documenting the point.
ErrorConsequenceWhat avoids it
Confusing zone 1 and zone 2A high-risk fracture treated like a benign avulsionA single question: does the fracture line reach the 4th-5th joint?2
Labelling “ankle sprain” without palpating the base of the 5thMissed fracture, sometimes for weeksPalpation is part of the Ottawa rules27
Not asking whether there was pain beforeStress fracture mistaken for an acute fracture, systemic cause not looked forOne history question; measure vitamin D if yes10
Immobilising a zone 1 in a plaster cast bootSignificant delay in return to the previous level, with no benefitFunctional treatment does better, supported by prospective trials4
Considering the matter closed at healingRefracture, 13 of 18 of them within the six months after the start of rehabilitationExtend monitoring and load progression11

The decisive act is not therapeutic, it is radiological: looking at whether the fracture line touches the joint between the fourth and fifth metatarsals.

On the same territory

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between a Jones fracture and a fracture of the base of the 5th metatarsal?

All Jones fractures are fractures of the base of the fifth metatarsal, but the reverse is not true. The Lawrence and Botte classification distinguishes three zones: the tuberosity (zone 1), the metaphyseal-diaphyseal junction that extends as far as the joint between the 4th and 5th metatarsals (zone 2), and the proximal diaphysis (zone 3)1. Only zone 2 is a Jones fracture in the strict sense. The confusion is frequent because all three sit within a few centimetres of the same bone.

Why does this fracture not heal well?

Because zone 2 is a vascular crossroads. Smith's anatomical study of ten injected cadaveric specimens shows that the rich, redundant network of the tuberosity meets the territory of the nutrient artery of the diaphysis exactly in the region of poor prognosis3. A fracture there cuts off a supply without any back-up route taking over.

Should a Jones fracture be operated on?

In athletes, the answer from the available syntheses is yes: union reaches 97.3% after screw fixation versus 71.4% without, with a return to sport of 98.8% versus 71.6% and 3.5 weeks gained5 ; the review attached to the IFASC 2025 consensus nevertheless finds that athletes with a traumatic fracture all returned to sport, faster after surgery and with more failures under conservative treatment28. In patients with no time pressure, the question is open: Polzer's systematic review, which includes only prospective trials, finds good to excellent results with functional treatment for zone 24. The decision is made with the surgeon, according to the level of demand and the exact site of the fracture line.

How long before walking again, and before returning to sport?

For a zone 1 fracture, weight-bearing is allowed from the outset with functional treatment4. For a zone 2 fracture in athletes, return to sport occurs on average at 9.6 weeks after screw fixation and 13.1 weeks without surgery5. These values are averages from athletic populations, and a plantar gap of at least 1 mm on an incomplete fracture lengthens healing from 74 to 116 days12. The timetable is set by healing, not by the average.

Can the bone fracture again after healing?

Yes, and it is the most underestimated risk: the refracture rate reaches 10.2% even after surgery5. In a series of 168 stress fractures in high-level athletes, all the refractures occurred after a new trauma to a healed bone, and 13 of 18 within the six months after the start of rehabilitation11. This is why load progression continues well beyond radiological healing.

My podiatrist mentions a hindfoot varus: is it related?

It is a solid but unconfirmed hypothesis. Raikin found a radiographic varus in 18 of the 21 hindfeet of 20 patients operated on for a Jones fracture, and proposes that overload of the lateral column predisposes to the fracture and to its failure8. But Riegger's meta-analysis, of 8 studies, confirms neither hindfoot varus nor pes cavus: only the adduction angle of the midfoot emerges, with a mean difference of 4.62°9. Two small weight-bearing CT studies associate varus with zone 3 fractures and with fractures of non-traumatic origin, not with zones 1 and 23031. The lateral offloading insole remains a reasonable option in the face of a marked varus, although its effect cannot be promised.

I have a “little bone” next to the 5th metatarsal on my X-ray: is it a fracture?

Possibly an os vesalianum, an accessory ossicle whose prevalence the most recent meta-analysis, covering 21,312 feet, puts at 0.6%15. It is distinguished by regular, corticated margins, a constant position, and its usual presence on the other foot, which a comparison radiograph can reveal. In adolescents, it may also be the growth apophysis, oriented parallel to the long axis of the bone, whereas a zone 1 fracture is transverse.

What is the dancer's fracture, and is it the same thing?

No, and the prognosis is even the opposite. It is an oblique spiral fracture of the distal diaphysis of the fifth metatarsal, well downstream of the three proximal zones. The original series of 35 professional dancers reports mostly non-operative treatment, including for displaced fractures, with pain-free walking at 6.1 weeks on average and a return to performance at 19 weeks, with all the dancers having resumed without limitation18. It accounts for 25% of fifth metatarsal fractures, 80% of which occur in women17.

Bibliography

Twenty-seven references, all verified individually on PubMed: identifier resolved, title, journal, year and author list checked, abstract read before citation. The links point to the PubMed record.

  1. Bušková K, Bartoníček J, Rammelt S. Fractures of the Base of the Fifth Metatarsal Bone: A Critical Analysis Review. JBJS Rev. 2021;9(10). PMID 34673663
  2. Cheung CN, Lui TH. Proximal Fifth Metatarsal Fractures: Anatomy, Classification, Treatment and Complications. Arch Trauma Res. 2016;5(4):e33298. PMID 28144601
  3. Smith JW, Arnoczky SP, Hersh A. The intraosseous blood supply of the fifth metatarsal: implications for proximal fracture healing. Foot Ankle. 1992;13(3):143-52. PMID 1601342
  4. Polzer H, Polzer S, Mutschler W, Prall WC. Acute fractures to the proximal fifth metatarsal bone: development of classification and treatment recommendations based on the current evidence. Injury. 2012;43(10):1626-32. PMID 22465516
  5. Attia AK, Taha T, Kong G, Alhammoud A, Mahmoud K, Myerson M. Return to Play and Fracture Union After the Surgical Management of Jones Fractures in Athletes: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis. Am J Sports Med. 2021;49(12):3422-3436. PMID 33740393
  6. Roche AJ, Calder JD. Treatment and return to sport following a Jones fracture of the fifth metatarsal: a systematic review. Knee Surg Sports Traumatol Arthrosc. 2013;21(6):1307-15. PMID 22956165
  7. Yates J, Feeley I, Sasikumar S, Rattan G, Hannigan A, Sheehan E. Jones fracture of the fifth metatarsal: Is operative intervention justified? A systematic review of the literature and meta-analysis of results. Foot (Edinb). 2015;25(4):251-7. PMID 26481787
  8. Raikin SM, Slenker N, Ratigan B. The association of a varus hindfoot and fracture of the fifth metatarsal metaphyseal-diaphyseal junction: the Jones fracture. Am J Sports Med. 2008;36(7):1367-72. PMID 18443278
  9. Riegger M, Müller J, Giampietro A, Saporito A, Filardo G, Treglia G, Guidi M, Candrian C. Forefoot Adduction, Hindfoot Varus or Pes Cavus: Risk Factors for Fifth Metatarsal Fractures and Jones Fractures? A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. J Foot Ankle Surg. 2022;61(3):641-647. PMID 35039196
  10. Shimasaki Y, Nagao M, Miyamori T, Aoba Y, Fukushi N, Saita Y, Ikeda H, Kim SG, Nozawa M, Kaneko K, Yoshimura M. Evaluating the Risk of a Fifth Metatarsal Stress Fracture by Measuring the Serum 25-Hydroxyvitamin D Levels. Foot Ankle Int. 2016;37(3):307-11. PMID 26596794
  11. Lee KT, Park YU, Jegal H, Kim KC, Young KW, Kim JS. Factors associated with recurrent fifth metatarsal stress fracture. Foot Ankle Int. 2013;34(12):1645-53. PMID 24216284
  12. Lee KT, Park YU, Jegal H, Park JW, Choi JP, Kim JS. Prognostic classification of fifth metatarsal stress fracture using plantar gap. Foot Ankle Int. 2013;34(5):691-6. PMID 23637237
  13. Valkier C, Fallat LM, Jarski R. Conservative Versus Surgical Management of Fifth Metatarsal Avulsion Fractures. J Foot Ankle Surg. 2020;59(5):988-992. PMID 32684405
  14. DeVries JG, Taefi E, Bussewitz BW, Hyer CF, Lee TH. The fifth metatarsal base: anatomic evaluation regarding fracture mechanism and treatment algorithms. J Foot Ankle Surg. 2015;54(1):94-8. PMID 25441854
  15. Osiowski A, Preinl M, Osiowski M, Baran K, Jasiewicz B, Taterra D. The prevalence and clinical considerations of Os Vesalianum Pedis: A meta-analysis. Foot Ankle Surg. 2025;31(7):612-618. PMID 40268623
  16. Metzl JA, Bowers MW, Anderson RB. Fifth Metatarsal Jones Fractures: Diagnosis and Treatment. J Am Acad Orthop Surg. 2022;30(4):e470-e479. PMID 34932521
  17. Schwagten K, Gill J, Thorisdottir V. Epidemiology of dancers fracture. Foot Ankle Surg. 2021;27(6):677-680. PMID 33229215
  18. O'Malley MJ, Hamilton WG, Munyak J. Fractures of the distal shaft of the fifth metatarsal. “Dancer's fracture”. Am J Sports Med. 1996;24(2):240-3. PMID 8775129
  19. Kane JM, Sandrowski K, Saffel H, Albanese A, Raikin SM, Pedowitz DI. The Epidemiology of Fifth Metatarsal Fracture. Foot Ankle Spec. 2015;8(5):354-9. PMID 25666689
  20. Petrisor BA, Ekrol I, Court-Brown C. The epidemiology of metatarsal fractures. Foot Ankle Int. 2006;27(3):172-4. PMID 16539897
  21. Hunt KJ, Anderson RB. Treatment of Jones fracture nonunions and refractures in the elite athlete: outcomes of intramedullary screw fixation with bone grafting. Am J Sports Med. 2011;39(9):1948-54. PMID 21632977
  22. Wang Y, Gan X, Li K, Ma T, Zhang Y. Comparison of operative and non-operative management of fifth metatarsal base fracture: A meta-analysis. PLoS One. 2020;15(8):e0237151. PMID 32790794
  23. Watson S, Trammell A, Tanner S, Martin S, Bowman L. Early Return to Play After Intramedullary Screw Fixation of Acute Jones Fractures in Collegiate Athletes: 22-Year Experience. Orthop J Sports Med. 2020;8(4):2325967120912423. PMID 32426399
  24. Hoshino T, Tateishi T, Nagase T, Yuki A, Nakagawa T, Tsuchiya M. Jones Fractures in Sumo Wrestlers: Three Case Reports. Case Rep Orthop. 2019;2019:9051327. PMID 31772802
  25. Wu GB, Li B, Yang YF. Comparative study of surgical and conservative treatments for fifth metatarsal base avulsion fractures (type I) in young adults or athletes. J Orthop Surg (Hong Kong). 2018;26(1):2309499017747128. PMID 29228848
  26. Anastasio AT, Parekh SG. Existing fixation modalities for Jones type fifth metatarsal fracture fixation pose high rates of complications and nonunion. World J Orthop. 2022;13(4):408-410. PMID 35582152
  27. Bittner JS, Hartstein AJ. Fifth Metatarsal Avulsion Fracture in an Adolescent Tennis Player. J Orthop Sports Phys Ther. 2019;49(8):620. PMID 31366295
  28. Balboni JM, Semelsberger SD, Boggiano VJ, et al. Jones fractures in elite athletes-2025 International Foot and Ankle Sports Consensus and systematic review. Knee Surg Sports Traumatol Arthrosc. 2026;34(9):3120-3134. PMID 41451757
  29. Kingery MT, Kadiyala ML, Walls R, et al. Clinical and Radiographic Healing of Nonoperative and Operative Treatment of Jones Fractures. Foot Ankle Int. 2024;45(4):309-317. PMID 38546126
  30. Grün W, Luo E, Pozzessere E, et al. Foot Malalignment and Proximal Fifth Metatarsal Fractures. Foot Ankle Int. 2025;46(5):561-570. PMID 40077926
  31. Lintz F, Grün W, Pozzessere E, et al. Fifth Metatarsal Stress Fractures Are Associated With Increased Bone Density and Altered Alignment on Weightbearing CT. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2026;484(1):81-94. PMID 40658443

Methodological note

The bibliographic foundation was built before writing, by querying PubMed through the E-utilities interface: each identifier was resolved, each record checked for its authors, journal and year, and each abstract read before being cited. The figures put forward carry their source at the exact place where they are written, and the populations from which they come are specified when they limit their scope: most of the union and return-to-sport figures come from exclusively athletic series. A major contradiction in the literature, between the Polzer review and the surgical meta-analyses, is set out as it stands rather than resolved. Finally, the absence of a validated rehabilitation protocol for this fracture is explicitly stated, the benchmarks proposed being deduced from the measured times to union and the chronology of refractures. Article written on 15 August 2026.

Behind this article

An author who explains, a reviewer who checks.

How we write and check our content

Anthony Baillon, physiotherapist and co-founder of Physio Learning
✍️ Author

Anthony Baillon

Physiotherapist · co-founder of Physio Learning

Marked for life by his first four-hour lecture without a single image, he took a master’s in instructional design so that it would never happen to anyone again. He hunts down publication bias and unreadable slides with the same intransigence.

PhysiotherapistInstructional designerCare design
Follow on LinkedIn
Robin Vervaeke, head of scientific content at Physio Learning✓ Verified

Robin Vervaeke

Head of scientific content

Physiotherapist specialising in neuro-musculoskeletal practice and holder of a master’s in public health. He checks the methodological rigour of every article: primary sources, levels of evidence, no exceptions.

Neuro-musculoskeletalMSc Public health
Follow on LinkedIn

Share